冰魂 2022-05-02

202.4.30 Required Reviews Completed

This means that all the necessary reviews that were required have been completed as of April 30, 202.

THUHT 2022-05-01

20220310 submitted - Submitted on March 10, 2022.
20220312 with editor - With editor on March 12, 2022.
20220320 under review - Under review on March 20, 2022.
20220415 major revision - Major revision on April 15, 2022.
20220420 revision submitted - Revision submitted on April 20, 2022.
20220425 minor revision - Minor revision on April 25, 2022.
20220428 accepted - Accepted on April 28, 2022.

The review process was fast, with all four reviewers providing positive feedback. The editors responded within a day. The minor revision was due to the first major revision missing a PDF with revision comments. There are certain language requirements. In terms of the direction I took, the quality of the paper in the SCT journal is much higher compared to the ASS journal. Before 2018, they were not even in the same league. It is a rigorous and efficient journal, and I hope its impact factor can increase soon.

LHLH 2022-04-28

4.28 under review.

炼金术士 2022-04-27

20220220 submit to journal: Submitted to the journal on February 20, 2022.
20220222 with editor: Under the editor's consideration since February 22, 2022.
20220226 under review: Under review since February 26, 2022.
20220311 required reviews completed: Required reviews were completed on March 11, 2022.
20220317 required reviews completed: Required reviews were completed on March 17, 2022.
20220328 major revision: Major revision requested on March 28, 2022.
20220419 submit: Resubmitted on April 19, 2022.
20220420 with editor: Under the editor's consideration since April 20, 2022.
20220421 under review: Under review since April 21, 2022.
20220425 Required reviews completed: Required reviews were completed on April 25, 2022.
20220427 accept: Accepted on April 27, 2022.

LHLH 2022-04-27

4.27 with editor

LHLH 2022-04-26

Submitted on April 21st, but it is still in the "submitted" status. Isn't this journal always known for being fast?

Cretorwj 2022-04-25

Friends who have submitted manuscripts, how long does this status usually last? This is my first time submitting to this journal.

Cretorwj 2022-04-25

2022.03.25 submit - Submitted on March 25, 2022
2022.03.28 under review - Under review since March 28, 2022
2022.04.11 Required Reviews Completed - Required reviews completed on April 11, 2022
2022.04.23 Required Reviews Completed(日期改变) - Required reviews completed (date changed) on April 23, 2022

Cretorwj 2022-04-25

"My status on 4.11 is 'required reviews completed,' and it is still the same. The date has changed to 4.23..."

Cretorwj 2022-04-25

Hello, have you recorded it?

冰魂 2022-04-05

2022.4.2 提交期刊
2022.4.4 经过编辑
2022.4.5 正在审查

冰魂 2022-04-04

2022.4.2 提交日志
2022.4.4 与编辑

增材达人 2022-03-26

2022.03.09 submit - Submitted on March 9, 2022.
2022.03.10 under review - Under review since March 10, 2022.
2022.03.24 required reviews completed - Required reviews were completed on March 24, 2022.

njust_wjy 2022-03-23

2022.3.7 - Submitted
2022.3.8 - With editor
2022.3.9 - Under review
2022.3.21 - Change in status date, still under review

清漪 2022-03-20

3.19 Required Reviews Completed (The date has changed, but the status has not changed). The reviewer's comments have not been received yet.

增材达人 2022-03-19

Hello, have you received the review comments now?

清漪 2022-03-16

3.16 Required Reviews Completed

风起兮 2022-03-14

Was the major revision rejected?

清漪 2022-03-02

Has the external review been completed or has it just been sent for external review?

清漪 2022-03-02

2022.2.27 Submission
2.28 With editor
32 Under review (ongoing updates)

plqx 2022-03-02

2022.01.07 submit
2022.01.11 under review
2022.01.18 required reviews completed
2022.01.27 major revision
2022.02.15 revised version submit
2022.02.16 under review
2022.02.24 accept
2022.02.28 online
2022.03.01 published

The efficiency is really high. Thank you to the editors and reviewers!

腐蚀&磨损狂热爱好者 2022-02-12

2019.10.16 First submission, 2019.12.7 Rejected with advice to redo experiments and resubmit, coincided with the outbreak of the pandemic, so redoing experiments was delayed until August 2020. After conducting the experiments and performing analysis, the resubmission was made in December 2021. I am extremely grateful to Editor Allan Matthews for his diligent and meticulous review work! I urge you not to give up on redoing the experiments and resubmitting, and to make the necessary revisions according to the suggestions of the reviewers!

2021.12.5 Submitted to the journal
2021.12.7 Under editor review
2021.12.8 Major revisions requested
2021.12.28 Under review
2022.1.27 Major revision requested
2022.2.9 Under editor review
2022.2.10 Accepted

小白白~ 2022-01-20

I have also been continuing for 5 days, and there is still no result.

plqx 2022-01-20

May I ask how long your required review was completed for?

ls 2022-01-15

The review process is quite fast, and it was accepted after major revisions.

AA137435 2021-12-29

May I ask, how many days has your required review been completed? What is the current status now?

AA137435 2021-12-29

How many days has your required review been completed? What is the current status?

xiaoyan 2021-12-26

November 5th: Submitted, under review for five days.
November 26th: Major revision.
December 16th: Submitted for revision.
December 18th: Under review.
First SCI article, the editor was very helpful, and the reviewer's comments were also of high quality.

翔鹰 2021-12-22

9.17 Submission
10.18 First review returned, major revisions, over thirty comments, not many related to the discussion section, given three weeks to make revisions
11.8 First review revisions submitted
11.27 Second review returned, minor revisions, four comments, given two weeks to make revisions
12.6 Second review revisions submitted
12.10 Under review
12.22 Accepted
In total, it took a little over three months from the submission to acceptance for the second review, which is quite challenging. It is fortunate to have it accepted before the Christmas and New Year holidays overseas.

半醋柠檬 2021-12-21

It should be said as the basic version, and the upgraded version is classified as Class 2 in the main category and Class 1 in the sub-category.