ddpyy 2023-06-29

The speed is slow, and the coverage area is decreasing. It is estimated that the number of people who subscribe will gradually decrease. Can this journal still continue?

月寐霜江 2023-06-29

Dear all, the ranking has dropped. Q2 has now gone down to Q3. It has been 10 months, and it is still under review.

ddpyy 2023-06-09

2023-06-09 Add Reviewers
More reviewers have been added!
Guys, should we withdraw our submission? Any knowledgeable brothers out there, please give some advice.

ddpyy 2023-06-02

Another addition of reviewers!! Has this journal offended the reviewers? Why has there been no one reviewing it all this time?

月寐霜江 2023-05-30

My research group submitted it, we submitted it in 2020, and received feedback in 2022. I am also submitting my own, it has been 8 months already, and we are still adding reviewers.

ddpyy 2023-05-30

We have added more reviewers again!!

ddpyy 2023-05-27

Adding reviewers again!!! Is it one per week?!

ddpyy 2023-05-24

It feels slow! They have been continuously adding reviewers, is everyone experiencing this?

2023-03-13 Manuscript Submission Confirm Mail - Sent
2023-03-13 Manuscript Submission Confirmed by author
2023-03-15 Preliminary Check Revise required
2023-03-17 Manuscript Resubmission Complete
2023-03-17 Preliminary Check OK
2023-03-17 Manuscript ID Renamed Confirm Mail - Sent
2023-03-17 Review Request Sent to 3 reviewer(s)
2023-03-31 Review Request Sent to 6 reviewer(s)
2023-05-13 Add Reviewers
2023-05-19 Add Reviewers
2023-05-19 Add Reviewers

李根 2023-04-05

2022-09-29 Review Result Excellent / Minor Change
2023-02-13 Review Result Good / Major Change
2023-02-14 Final Review Revise Required
2023-02-19 Manuscript Resubmission Complete
2023-04-03 Final Review Accepted

李根 2023-04-05

2022-06-26 Maual de presentación Confirmar correo electrónico - Enviado
2022-06-29 ID del manuscrito cambiado Confirmar correo electrónico - Enviado
2022-09-02 Solicitud de revisión Enviado a 1 revisor(es)

setsail 2023-03-31

Avoid a thunderstorm, it took 21 months, be cautious in investing if you want it to be faster!
It seems like several journals under this publishing house are like this, not being able to find reviewers is a common problem.
2021-07-06 Manuscript Submission
…
2021-07-26 Review Result Good / Major Change
…
2022-05-07 Add Reviewers
…
2022-12-03 Review Result Good / Accept
2022-12-03 re-Review
2023-01-20 Manuscript Resubmission Complete
…
2023-03-06 Final Review Accepted
…
2023-03-31 On-line Journal Published

月寐霜江 2023-03-22

Super slow, submitted in August 2022, and then it disappeared without a trace.

ddpyy 2023-03-15

2023-03-13 Manuscript Submission Confirm Mail - Sent
2023-03-13 Manuscript Submission Confirmed by author
2023-03-15 Preliminary Check Revise required

May I ask if "Revise required" in the preliminary check means that there are formatting issues and the manuscript needs to be modified and resubmitted?

qinmoumou 2022-12-30

Very slow, very slow, very slow, very slow, not worth it, don't invest, took twelve months.

乌拉123 2022-11-22

The school started, and the submission was already accepted. The review process was quite fast.
8.31, submission;
10.3, major revision;
10.24, submission;
11.4, minor revision;
11.18, acceptance.

向阳ersheng 2022-11-21

The first SCI paper went fairly smoothly, and it took about two months to complete the major revisions before being accepted for publication. The editor was very responsible, and I am extremely grateful.

拂晓 2022-09-15

May I ask how long it takes for your article to be published after acceptance? If it is not open source, will there be a page fee charged?

拂晓 2022-09-15

December submission, two major revisions, accepted in August, needs more than 1K dollars for open access, not chosen, don't know when it will be published normally.

萨菲螺丝 2022-09-02

May I ask which email should the withdrawal letter be sent to, the editor-in-chief's or the publishing house's?

a1012335896 2022-06-14

I am the original account password, it has not changed.

鹏0504 2022-05-30

Original poster, I would like to ask, after making modifications and resubmitting, should I still use the original paper ID and password to login, or has the password been changed? After I resubmitted, I couldn't log into the submission system and couldn't find any information. I don't know if the password has been changed or if it has already been rejected. I haven't received any notifications, and there has been no response to my emails.

a1012335896 2022-03-04

Posted in February 2021, reviewed three days later, reminded in late May, saying they couldn't find reviewers and were still searching. Received the first reviewer's comments in early June and the second reviewer's comments at the end of October. The editorial department allowed ten days for revisions. The second review process took over three months and the paper was accepted in early February, but it is still not online. It is advised to be cautious about submitting to this journal as it seems strange. They keep adding reviewers and claim they haven't received any response from potential reviewers. It is curious why they can't find reviewers, whether it is due to issues with the editorial department's invitation emails or intentional delay.

彰武路小佩奇 2022-03-04

It has been 18 months since submission, and I have been continuously adding reviews. Whenever I inquire about the progress, they say they are still searching for reviewers. I have almost forgotten about this article.

lihaodage 2022-02-08

After submitting for 10 months, there was only one review and no further updates. They kept adding reviewers...adding reviewers... I sent two reminder letters, and they replied that they couldn't find any reviewers willing to review. They said they would understand if I withdrew my submission. It's really frustrating and a waste of almost a year. I have no idea what the editorial department of this journal is doing. Be cautious when submitting, as it could be a complete waste of time.

SEU土木 2021-12-19

Later, I sent two more letters. Finally, last month, they replied to me, after delaying me for 8 months. Without any other options, I had to keep sending withdrawal letters.

恒 2021-12-13

It's been 14 months and there still hasn't been any feedback from the first review. They have been continuously adding reviewers, it's really terrible.

lihaodage 2021-12-10

It has been 8 months since I submitted, and they are still adding reviewers. I don't know what this editorial team is doing, and the speed is unbelievable. I suggest not submitting anymore, it's a waste of time. I will definitely change my submission and avoid this trap.

LizzyQiao 2021-12-09

Hello, may I ask what you did afterwards? If you sent a withdrawal letter and didn't receive a reply, thank you.

s牛牛 2021-11-03

The current number of reviewers has increased to 21, and there is still no response.

牛牛yb 2021-10-13

2021-05-04 Preliminary Check OK
2021-06-09 Add Reviewers
2021-06-10 Add Reviewers
2021-06-11 Add Reviewers
2021-06-15 Add Reviewers
2021-06-18 Add Reviewers
2021-06-21 Add Reviewers
2021-06-25 Add Reviewers
2021-07-02 Add Reviewers
2021-07-07 Add Reviewers
2021-07-09 Add Reviewers
2021-07-16 Add Reviewers
2021-10-01 Add Reviewers
2021-10-02 Add Reviewers
2021-10-07 Add Reviewers
Still don't know the result until now.