科研患者 2023-08-07

How did it turn out after such a long dip?

Lls2023 2023-07-19

2.23 Submission
4.18 Major revision: Four reviewers and the editor provided 64 modification suggestions, with a deadline for resubmission by 5.23. ((lll￢ω￢))
5.28 Revised: Sent an email requesting a one-week extension, and the editor readily agreed. (64 suggestions, not enough time at all - -)
7.3 Minor revision: Two reviewers agreed to accept, while the other two provided 5 modification suggestions.
7.10 Revised: Not many suggestions, but the workload was actually quite large.
7.15 Submitted at noon, accepted in the afternoon. It seems that the editor made a decision after reading it and did not show it to the reviewers again.
Perhaps the content of the article matched well, and the overall efficiency was quite high. The journal emailed me to remind me, I didn't have to remind the journal, haha.

芳华待灼 2023-06-29

I feel like ATE has slowed down recently.

科研小菜鸡儿 2023-06-16

Thank you Associate Editor and thank you Professor Christos Markides, the Editor-in-Chief! Thank you, thank you!

Mr.thermal 2023-06-13

In the past 19 years, I published one paper. In the middle, I probably submitted three papers to ATE, which is relatively slower compared to the previous year. Fortunately, the results were good. Usually, after being rejected by a first-tier journal, I would submit to this journal, where the quality varies.

蓝蓝蓝洛 2023-06-12

I have also been editing it for a long time, almost a month. Now the reviewer hardly gives any feedback... The editor has slowed down the process.

iimp314 2023-06-06

May I ask how you know if the reviewer has accepted the review?

YmhhZjgg 2023-06-04

It has been 5 days since submission. The ones submitted one day before and one day after mine have already been sent for review, but mine is still "with editor". Does the editor think it doesn't meet the journal's requirements? I'm very anxious. Have any of you brothers or sisters encountered a similar situation?

Leonard_THX 2023-05-31

5.31 The status is still DIP. Is there anyone who has had a similar experience? After the first trial, being in DIP for so long, does it mean something?

Leonard_THX 2023-05-31

Hello, do you have any results now?

Leonard_THX 2023-05-27

4.15 submitted
4.22 With editor
4.23 With editor
4.25 under review
4.28 under review
5.12 under review
5.22 review completed
5.24 DIP
It has been in this status for 3 days, does it mean it will be rejected?

Qz 2023-05-24

Brother, your ID has been sold to ATE.

HMT 2023-05-22

Feb 14, 2023 Submitted to Journal
Feb 19, 2023 With Editor
Feb 23, 2023 With Editor
Feb 24, 2023 Under Review
Mar 26, 2023 Decision in Process
Mar 27, 2023 Major Revision
Apr 04, 2023 Revision Submitted to Journal
Apr 09, 2023 With Editor
Apr 12, 2023 Under Review
May 07, 2023 Decision in Process
May 07, 2023 Accept
May 16, 2023 Online

Translated:
Feb 14, 2023 Submitted to Journal
Feb 19, 2023 With Editor
Feb 23, 2023 With Editor
Feb 24, 2023 Under Review
Mar 26, 2023 Decision in Process
Mar 27, 2023 Major Revision
Apr 04, 2023 Revision Submitted to Journal
Apr 09, 2023 With Editor
Apr 12, 2023 Under Review
May 07, 2023 Decision in Process
May 07, 2023 Accept
May 16, 2023 Online

何弃疗啊哥 2023-04-30

Today is 4.30, the status remains as "submitted to journal".

wang410 2023-04-27

1.05 Submission
3.14 Major Revision
3.29 Revised
4.27 Accepted

Leonard_THX 2023-04-26

15th April submitted
22nd With editor
24th With editor
25th under review

Translation:

15th April submitted
22nd With editor
24th With editor
25th under review

何弃疗啊哥 2023-04-25

4-19 submission
Still pending with editor
Looking forward to a good outcome

航发打工仔 2023-04-24

Submitted a paper on the direction of heat transfer in aviation engines, took 6 months, the speed was much slower than before, but the journal editor was still responsible and after three reminders, finally received a good result.

蓝蓝蓝洛 2023-04-22

The first time to publish a paper in the field of heat transfer on ATE, it can be considered as a report of one year's work for the first year PhD student.

zmg 2023-04-17

Still need to remind for the manuscript, second review with the editor. Remind on the same day after half a month, record on the same day. The editor's processing speed is slightly slow.

YuxuanJump 2023-04-14

22.10.20 Submitted to Journal
22.10.23 With Editor
22.11.8 Under Review
23.2.4 Major revise
23.2.24 Revision Submitted to Journal
23.3.1 Under Review
23.3.27 Required Reviews Complete
23.4.11 Decision in process
23.4.13 Accept

The editor's decision greatly determines the speed of the entire process. A colleague who submitted their paper to ATE two months later than me was accepted on the same day as me, but their processing time in WE, RRC, and DIP was much shorter than mine. The handling speed of the Editor-in-Chief, Christos Markides, is relatively slow.

Based on experience, papers that enter the editing stage at the beginning of the month are usually processed faster than those that enter at the end of the month, and each stage generally does not exceed 21 days. If there has been no progress for a long time, it is polite to send an email to inquire about the status (preferably indicating that it is not a reminder for the paper). I couldn't bear the wait after 14 days in RRC, so I gently reminded them.

There were two reviewers for the first review. Reviewer 1 rejected the paper, while Reviewer 2 accepted it directly, but required major revisions. I carefully and positively answered all the questions and pointed out any misunderstandings by the reviewers. The second review did not have any comments and the paper was accepted, although the wait was agonizing.

zmg 2023-04-12

The editing process is a bit slow. All second-round reviewers have unanimously accepted it. The editor made minor revisions and sent it back right away. It has been 10 days, and until now it is still "with editor."

LE 2023-04-10

Brother, has your article entered the next stage?

LE 2023-04-04

May I ask, after submitting this manuscript, do all authors need to click on the confirmation before it can proceed to the "under review" stage?

LE 2023-04-03

I have submitted it for 5 to 6 days already, but it is still "with editor". I don't know how much longer I have to wait.

mjyang 2023-03-02

2023-03-2 required reviews completed The fourth change of date.

mjyang 2023-03-02

I would like to ask all the research experts, what is the reason for the constant change in the "required reviews completed" date during the first review? It has changed three times within a period of over ten days.

mjyang 2023-03-01

2023-03-1 تم إكمال المراجعات المطلوبة

Translation: The required reviews for 2023-03-1 have been completed.

mjyang 2023-03-01

It's normal for it to take more than 20 days for review. Let's wait a little longer and see. Previously, when I submitted to JES, it took about two months for review.

mjyang 2023-02-26

2023-02-25 significa 25 de febrero de 2023. "Required reviews completed" se traduce como "Revisiones requeridas completadas".