Goatling 2023-07-13

The journal's processing procedure is not standardized. The post-review channel for articles is not closed after the decision, resulting in papers that have already been accepted for final decision being rejected. Additionally, the journal editor refuses to communicate and selectively replies to emails. The speed of manuscript processing is highly dependent on luck. It is advised to be cautious when submitting.

年轮 2023-06-21

Hello, may I ask if the status bar of this journal displays anything like "one reviewer agreed"? If not, it is indeed not possible to see how many reviewers have agreed to review.

年轮 2023-06-21

Hello, may I ask if the status bar of this journal displays phrases like "one reviewer agreed"?

piyangyang 2023-02-08

Very trashy, very slow, it took thirteen months for the first review, and no response was received no matter how many emails were sent in between.
I don't know what this editor is doing, it's very slow, four reviewers,
The editor is very irresponsible.
It's really not worth it.

Jack_ABC 2023-01-28

Have you tried closing the browser and restarting it? I encountered a similar issue in another journal and restarting solved it.

Coco_9354 2023-01-06

Slow, super slow. I submitted in March 2021, and it hasn't come back for the first review yet. I will withdraw the submission next week. It's garbage. When I submitted it, they required at least 7 self-citations and the manuscript format is unique. I submitted it before I graduated, and it's been half a year since I started working, and it still hasn't been reviewed. It's garbage. They have already put me on their blacklist.

大依旧 2023-01-01

It is civil engineering, with a focus on structures.

大依旧 2023-01-01

Dear experts, my review is finished, but there was a problem with the system when I tried to submit the revised manuscript. When I entered the system to submit the manuscript, it didn't show up. I don't know what happened. Has anyone else encountered a similar situation, either students or teachers? Please give me some advice. This thesis is my graduation requirement, so thank you all in advance!!!

flyingbird316 2022-11-04

2021-12-12 Manuscript Submission Confirmed by author
2021-12-19 Preliminary Check OK
2022-02-21 Review Result Average / Major Change
2022-03-16 One Review Completed/Two Reviewers
2022-04-11 Review Result Average / Major Change
2022-04-12 Final Review Revise Required
2022-05-12 Manuscript Resubmission Complete
2022-05-13 Review Result Average / Accept
2022-10-24 Final Review Accepted
2022-11-01 Proofs in Progress
2022-11-03 On-line Journal Published

Ben_ 2022-09-17

The review process is very slow.

linjiaxiang 2022-08-25

It took 11 months, I don't know how long it will take to retrieve.

linjiaxiang 2022-08-25

2022-07-28 Review Result Good / Major Change
2022-07-29 Review Changed to 550
2022-08-10 Final Review Revise Required
2022-08-18 Manuscript Resubmission Complete
2022-08-18 Re-review Required to Reviewer 6
2022-08-18 Re-review Required to Reviewer 7
2022-08-18
2022-08-25 Review Result Good / Accept

Cage Sun 2022-08-22

May I ask on which date will it be published? Thank you very much.

Cage Sun 2022-08-10

Dust has settled! After 13 months of review, it has finally been accepted! Sigh, maybe I will continue to submit in the future, but I can only choose articles that I'm not in a hurry for.

linjiaxiang 2022-08-05

2021-10-06 Manuscript ID Renamed Confirm Mail - Sent
2021-10-16 Add Reviewers
2021-10-18 Add Reviewers
2021-10-19 Add Reviewers
2022-01-19 Review Result Good / Major Change
2022-01-19 Add Reviewers
2022-01-25 Add Reviewers
2022-01-28 Add Reviewers
2022-05-07 Add Reviewers
2022-05-08 Add Reviewers
2022-05-15 Add Reviewers
2022-05-16 Add Reviewers
2022-05-17 Add Reviewers
2022-05-17 Add Reviewer
2022-07-28 Review Result Good / Major Change
2022-07-29 Review Changed to 550

Cage Sun 2022-08-03

Finally, after a month, feedback was given by three reviewers! Two were accepted after modifications, and one was requested for re-evaluation after modifications.

Cage Sun 2022-06-15

Anyway, I will absolutely not give you the review result!

Cage Sun 2022-06-14

2022-06-14 Review Result: Average/Major Change
I'm so pissed off. Does it have to be rejected by someone before the review can be finished?

Cage Sun 2022-06-13

2021-05-19 Manuscript Submission Confirm Mail - Sent
2021-05-28 Preliminary Check OK
2021-07-06 Review Result Good / Minor Change
2022-05-29 Review Result Excellent / Minor Change
And until now, they haven't provided me with any review comments. I have sent reminders for the manuscript several times, but I have never received a response!
I really don't understand why it's taking so long. Can't the editor just forward the reviewer's comments to me? Is it so difficult to complete such a simple task?

sulaile 2022-06-13

Submitted a revised manuscript, which had the exact same content as the March version, and it was accepted the next day. Updated progress:

2022-03-23: Final Review, Revision Required
2022-03-26: Manuscript Resubmission, Complete
2022-06-07: Final Review, Revision Required
2022-06-07: Final Review, Revision Required
2022-06-12: Manuscript Resubmission, Complete
2022-06-13: Final Review, Accepted

sulaile 2022-06-07

2022.06.07 I provided revised comments again, which were exactly the same as those given on 2022.03.23. This indicates that the editor did not even check my revised manuscript in the system (I checked it myself and confirmed that the revised file was submitted correctly). I am speechless. I suggest avoiding this pitfall.

wangbing0501 2022-05-19

Date Event Detail
2021-03-01 Manuscript Submission Confirm Mail - Sent
2021-03-01 Manuscript Submission Confirmed by author
2021-03-03 Preliminary Check OK
2021-03-03 Manuscript ID Renamed Confirm Mail - Sent
2021-03-03 Sent to the Chief Editor
2021-08-29 Review Request Sent to 2 reviewer(s)

This time it is extremely slow, and they never reply to the reminder emails. Is this the same situation for you?
Could it be that I have the wrong email address for reminding them?

IEM_XD 2022-05-17

This journal is so slow. It took a month to inform me that the number of citations for my article is not enough, and I need to resubmit it.

Cage Sun 2022-05-11

Dragged for a year without reviewing, I managed to turn a new article into outdated research, and then it was rejected for not being innovative enough. I will never submit to this journal again!

sulaile 2022-04-18

The status has not changed as of April 18, 2022.

Cage Sun 2022-04-17

Why is yours so fast? I submitted my article 11 months ago and it still hasn't gone through the first review.

qichu 2022-04-15

It's a system issue, the file got lost. I had to resubmit it later, and it took more than a week to reach the initial review stage. The response time for the manuscript is also a bit slow. I really hope it can be faster. Haha.

yhb_mm 2022-04-09

Step 1
http://www.techno-press.org/

Step 2
http://www.techno-press.org/?journal=scs&subpage=5

Step 3
http://www.techno-press.org/papers/

Step 4
http://www.techno-press.org/papers/?page=status

Step 5
Simply enter your account and password in the corresponding fields for the corresponding author.

yhb_mm 2022-04-09

Share my submission experience, there is a detailed explanation on Little Ant Forum, welcome to discuss. Q 572364562
http://muchong.com/t-15238895-1
2021-11-02 One Reviewer agreed (to reviewer)
2021-11-30 Review Result Good / Minor Change
2022-02-16 One Review Completed/One Reviewer
2022-03-16 Review Result Good / Minor Change
2022-03-17 Review Changed to 550
2022-03-19 Final Review Revise Required
2022-03-20 Manuscript Resubmission Complete
2022-03-29 Review Changed to 550
2022-03-29 Final Review Accepted

yhb_mm 2022-04-09

Do you know if your minor revision has yielded results? Generally, there is no need to submit it for review again, and the editor-in-chief can provide the final outcome.