vivalavida 2023-07-28

I have submitted it once, which was the editorial letter for the first review. The email stated "revise and resubmit." But now I just checked the system and it shows "major revision and rereview." It's confusing me. Could it mean a significant revision?

Zinc 2023-07-28

It's not a major overhaul. Your submission is just a revised version for resubmission. The editor approves of your work and asks for it to be modified according to the requirements before submitting it again. There is a high probability that it will be sent for external review.

vivalavida 2023-07-28

I submitted the revision and resubmission mentioned in the editorial letter. I didn't directly mention whether it should be rejected or require major revision, so I'm not sure if it means that it needs significant changes.

Zinc 2023-07-28

2023.05.12 submitted
2023.05.13 with editor
2023.05.14 under review
2023.06.25 major revisions
2023.07.01 returned for revisions
2023.07.25 accepted

I submitted Solar Energy on May 12th, 2023. It took over a month for the review process, and unfortunately, it was rejected by a reviewer who clearly did not understand the background of the article. This wasted a lot of time.

I decided to resubmit it to another journal, and to my surprise, it entered the "under review" stage just three days later. There were two reviewers who provided a total of 8 comments, all of which were very professional. After making the necessary revisions, the article was accepted without further delay. It was a great experience with this submission. This article was a pure simulation, and it took about two months to be accepted. Experimental articles usually get accepted even faster. I am very grateful for Aryasomayajula Subrahmanyam, Ph.D.'s thorough work and I wish the journal continued success!

知秋 2023-07-28

Friend, how are you now?

huey 2023-07-01

The reviewer's comments seem to have returned, but the editor has not provided a decision for over two weeks. The people who were emailed to remind them of a response are also not editors, which feels very unreasonable. I will not submit to this journal again, and I advise friends who want to submit to be cautious.

huey 2023-06-13

Since last December, after submitting the manuscript, it is still in the second round of Peer Review. I feel like I can't find any reviewers, and it has wasted a lot of time in the process. Friends who are in a hurry should be cautious about submitting.

huey 2023-01-27

12.3 First Submission
12.20 The status has not changed since it is Under Review...

I wonder how long the deadline is for reviewers in this journal?
I am involved in research related to thermochemical energy storage, and it seems to have been assigned to Editor Zhang.

Tsolmon 2022-11-11

June 18th submission
July 7th first-round review comments
August 25th revised manuscript resubmission
September 18th second-round review comments
October 3rd revised manuscript resubmission
October 18th acceptance

I remember this journal used to be in Zone 1 before, now it has dropped to Zone 2, and it's not even TOP anymore. Is it worse than Solar Energy now? Do we still have hope to get back to Zone 1?

Kingke 2022-07-04

2022.5.15 submitted, 6.26 accepted.

jedream 2022-04-27

8 Feb 2022 Submitted
12 Apr 2022 Minor revision
21 Apr 2022 Resubmitted
26 Apr 2022 Accepted

After the first submission, there was a change in the editor, which caused a delay of about ten days. Otherwise, the review process would have been faster. The paper was initially submitted to Corro Sci and was rejected by an unfamiliar reviewer. It was then revised based on the comments of another reviewer and submitted to this journal. However, the same reviewer from Corro Sci was encountered again, resulting in three minor issues. These were quickly addressed during the revision process.

大鲶鱼 2022-04-13

Submission period: 10 months

sulcast 2022-02-13

Nov. 01, 2021 submitted
Nov. 17 under review
Jan. 05, 2022 required reviews completed
Jan. 09 major revision
Jan. 28 returned
Feb. 04 under review
Feb. 10 required reviews completed, accept
Overall, the process was much faster than rumored, and Professor Zhengguo Zhang's efficiency was also very high. Thank you to the editors and reviewers.

Wesley-1 2022-01-17

The review process is too slow.

Blackbody 2021-11-18

2021.07.15 submitted
2021.07.16 under review
2021.09.13 major revision and rereview
2021.09.26 revision submitted
2021.09.29 under review
2021.10.20 major revision and rereview
2021.10.29 with editor
2021.11.04 accepted
There was a reminder sent in the middle, and the efficiency of the editor was still very high, although the reviewers might have been a bit slow.
Many thanks to editor Aline Rougier and the reviewers.

sciscisci1986 2021-08-13

Received! Not easy, submitted for acceptance for over 7 months.

sciscisci1986 2021-06-23

Hello, how many months in total will it take to receive it?

sciscisci1986 2021-06-23

Hello, how long does it take to receive in total?

小帅123 2021-06-11

Last year I got one article published, and this year I got another one published. I would like to express my special gratitude to Editor Zhang. After being rejected seven times in the first zone, I decided to submit to the second zone, thinking that this journal offers a high cost-performance ratio. The overall speed is much faster than last year. The review process took one month, with just a few questions, and after making the revisions, I waited for half a month before it was directly accepted. Once again, I would like to thank the Solnat journal, Editor Zhang, and the reviewers. I hope Solnat continues to thrive.

小洁的养乐多 2021-05-26

Thank you to editor Xavier Mathew and the reviewers.

sciscisci1986 2021-05-10

Review process took 3 and a half months, with 2 months given for revisions. It has been 1 and a half months since the submission of the revisions, currently under review, waiting for news.

sciscisci1986 2021-05-10

How long after you submitted your modifications did you receive them? Thank you!

sciscisci1986 2021-05-10

How many months after your modifications were accepted?

翡翠湖小蜗牛 2021-03-31

2021-1-15 submitted；
2021-2-12 under review;
2021-3-21 minor revision;
2021-3-28 revision submitted;
2021-3-31 accept.

flory999 2021-02-15

It has been six and a half months since submission. I reminded once when it reached five months, and now I am patiently waiting. I am not in a hurry at all.

sciscisci1986 2021-01-27

Submitted for 2 and a half months, it has been under review the whole time. I don't know what the situation is.