伊芙利特之祭 2023-07-05

First submitted to Angew, the editor transferred it to AOM, Small, and Small Structures as options, promising that it would definitely be reviewed. Then, on the same day, it was transferred to Small. The next day, the new impact factor came out and it was discovered that Small Structures exceeded Small. Hahaha. However, Small Structures has a higher proportion of new journal reviews and a smaller number of publications. It is currently in Zone 2 according to the Chinese Academy of Sciences classification and still has a long way to go in the future. For now, it is still preferable to choose Small for publication.

Regarding the progress:
2023.6.27 Submitted (Transfer)
2023.7.04 With Editor
2023.7.05 Under Review

This timeline is provided for everyone's reference. Updates will be provided if there are any changes later.

NJ777 2023-07-05

Just started slow, then it got faster.

sunsky633 2023-07-05

5.1 Advanced science submission rejected
5.5 Submitted small
5.12 Major revision, not submitted, asked for AS's comments before replying, 20 days
5.25 Revision submitted
6.13 Major revision, 3 reviewers, the reviewer who previously rejected the manuscript still insists on rejection, the other two accept, 20 days for revisions
6.30 Revision submitted
7.4 Under review
It's so difficult, this submission.

YOLO 2023-07-04

Posted on June 19th, still in the submitted state as of July 4th.
I'm in a rush, should I withdraw the submission?

Lau4vla666 2023-07-04

Is it that the editing suggestion was rejected and not submitted for review?

FeifeiXin 2023-07-03

Has it been sent for review? How long has it been sent for review?

FeifeiXin 2023-07-01

How long after submission does it take to be "with editor", and how long does it take to be "under review"?

天神学院-荒 2023-07-01

4.3 submitted
4.23 Under Review
5.24 Major Revision
6.13 Return for major revision
6.23 Second revision
6.27 Return for second revision
6.29 Accepted

糯米团子只糯不团 2023-07-01

Return the revised manuscript at 5 pm on June 23rd and submit it for review by 9 pm.

糯米团子只糯不团 2023-07-01

5.10 submitted
5.26 under review
6.13 major revision
6.23 revised return 3h under review
6.29 accept

zhenzhen 2023-06-29

The review comments for June 29th have not yet been received.

Lau4vla666 2023-06-29

I am too, how is your situation now, brother?

lyjnjht 2023-06-29

Not being a big shot, just lucky enough to have coincidentally caught the attention of the editor. It might take around 5 or 6 days to submit, because once I submitted it, I didn't keep an eye on it. After a week, I checked and it was already under review.

lyjnjht 2023-06-29

June 12th, Submission
Unknown with editor
June 12th (display issue), under review
June 27th, major revision, 3 reviewers, 27 questions, only the third reviewer suggested major revisions, requested to submit before July 17th.

其实sir 2023-06-28

The following text translated into English is: "Regarding the transfer to Small, may I ask how long it took for your approval? I submitted it for review on June 5th, and there is still no outcome now."

回家乘客喝茶 2023-06-28

Submitted on May 16th, reviewed on June 6th, received review comments on June 27th, and requested to submit the revised manuscript by July 25th.

Yusheng Luo 2023-06-28

May I ask when it was submitted?

AXB111 2023-06-28

AFM recommends transferring

回家乘客喝茶 2023-06-27

Four reviewers, two rejections, the editor gave a major revision, which I did not expect. The main issue is that those two rejected reviewers did not provide any substantial feedback. I don't think their opinions will be considered in the second review.

zzhhzz 2023-06-27

How did you finish it so quickly? How long did the submission last?

lyjnjht 2023-06-27

23.6.12 Status: Submitted
23.6.11? Status: Under review (there seems to be a display issue)
23.6.26 3 reviewers: Major revision required

回家乘客喝茶 2023-06-27

If I can give a transfer to AOM, it would be pretty good.

Cyril00 2023-06-26

6.7 submit: Submit
6.26 transfer: Transfer
Family, who understands it? It's really too slow. In the morning, it was said to be submit, but in the evening, it was rejected. Even the editor apologized for the delay, but there was no reason for the rejection. I'm really speechless!!!

huangbuliuqiu 2023-06-23

6.7 submitted, 6.23 still submitted, don't know when it will be updated.

小民咕咕 2023-06-21

3.20 Submitted to AFM. One week later, it was suggested to transfer the submission. At the end of the month, transferred to the small category. Submitted for 14 days, under review on the 15th day. A month for major revisions. Two out of the top 15% were rejected, and after 15 days of revision, unfortunately, the rejection was maintained by the reviewer. The editor requested major revisions, which were completed and resubmitted within one week. Under review for 17 days. Accepted on 6.20. The overall process took 3 months. Wishing everyone smooth submission experiences!

合成大芝麻 2023-06-19

After one month of submission, the AFM (Academic Journal) rejected the manuscript and suggested submitting to a smaller journal. The revised manuscript was submitted on June 7th and received a response from the editor the same evening. On June 16th, the manuscript was directly accepted.

Cyril00 2023-06-19

Thank you for sharing! Wishing you good luck!

小呆呆 2023-06-16

I submitted an angew review at the end of April. The next day, I decided to switch to small and promptly made the switch. However, my manuscript remained in the submitted status for 10 days. During this time, I kept checking this platform to read others' comments and noticed that everyone was in the same situation. On the 11th day, I checked in the morning at 12 o'clock and it was still in the submitted status, but when I checked again at 4 o'clock in the afternoon, it had changed to under review. So, I patiently waited. Originally, I thought it would take a long time, but on June 3rd, I received the feedback. One paper was accepted directly and another one was basically accepted with a few minor issues raised. There was also one paper that required major revisions, but there were no major concerns, just a request to modify the outlook section. It took me 10 days to make the revisions and I submitted them on the 13th. I thought I would have to wait for a long time again, but to my surprise, it was accepted just two hours later. I was a bit astonished.

Based on the recent situations of everyone, I think it might be an issue with the Weily system's display. If it shows "submitted" for over a week, it is most likely under review. So, everyone should patiently wait. I wish everyone success.

冉宸宝 2023-06-16

It has been nearly 30 days since the revised manuscript was submitted, and it has been under review the whole time. Has the original poster received any updates? Should they send a reminder?

煮⑧jie 2023-06-15

Only the first corresponding author's email address is able to access the submission status in the small journal, while co-authors cannot see it.