00mmmn 2023-07-17

20230717 with editor translates to "July 17, 2023 with editor."

00mmmn 2023-07-17

20230709投稿 translates to "20230709 post" in English.

Jax1111 2023-07-17

The article was first submitted to Angew, and reviewed the next day. The review process took a month, and both reviewers' comments were positive regarding the novelty of the research, but they mentioned that it lacked depth. The overall feedback was relatively positive. The editor recommended three transfer options: Small, Small Structure, and Chemsuschem. Finally, it was decided to choose Small, which had higher recognition. At that time, the editor of Angew said that after responding to the comments of the two reviewers, the article would be returned to them or accepted directly.

On May 9th, 2023, Angew rejected the article, and it was transferred to Small on the same day.

On May 27th, 2023, the comments from the two reviewers were returned to Small.

On June 21st, 2023, Small returned the review comments. One reviewer agreed to accept without any comments, while the other raised a few questions. The editor requested major revisions. I'm not entirely sure why major revisions were requested in this case.

On July 12th, 2023, the second round of review comments were returned. It seems that it was sent back to the reviewer who had questions.

As of July 17th, 2023, there is still no news.

往前走 2023-07-17

Has anyone encountered a situation where the review process has taken 47 days and there are still no results? I'm in a hurry.
6.1 Under Review
7.17 Still Under Review

其实sir 2023-07-16

It was indeed slow at the beginning, especially during the first review. However, it improved afterwards with revisions.

shalanzui 2023-07-16

Why has it been so slow recently? Does anyone know the situation? It has been 11 days since the 7.5 submission, and it is still submitted. What is the editorial department doing? Have they gone on vacation?

FDDXC 2023-07-15

1. Receive the revised manuscript within seven to eight days.
2. Under review on the same day it was sent back for revision.

其实sir 2023-07-13

July 12 under review

shier 2023-07-13

After you accepted it, did you proofread it now?

小学渣爱学习 2023-07-13

7.1 Submission, 7.12 Directly connected changes, with e to under R, also don't know if it entered peer review (someone said that capital R means external review, uh, don't really understand, first time submitting something small). By the way, isn't it a bit watery...

XYZ 2023-07-12

Do you have any news now?

其实sir 2023-07-12

May I ask how long it takes to submit for review after revision?

sunsky633 2023-07-12

7.12 accepted, the editing process is quite fast.

XYZ 2023-07-11

I submitted mine on May 15th, and it has been under review so far.

其实sir 2023-07-11

Why is the review process taking so long recently?
5.18 transferred from AM
5.26 with editor
6.5 under review
6.29 major revision
7.10 resubmitted

AXB111 2023-07-11

After complaining for one hour, it will be submitted for review.

mustc 2023-07-11

Posted on 4/26, the status is still under review. This is really abnormal, isn't it? Why is it taking so long?

AXB111 2023-07-11

Now basically it's just stuck at 15 days with an editor.

其实sir 2023-07-11

Yes, recently why is Small so slow?

其实sir 2023-07-11

May I ask if it was sent for review after being revised? How long does it take to reach the editor's hands after being revised?

AXB111 2023-07-10

7/10 still submit really slow to scratch feet.

tianshi 2023-07-10

I submitted it on 6.23 and it is still submitted.

louie7 2023-07-10

I also submitted on the 24th, and it is still in the submitted status. Has yours changed?

Dr. g 2023-07-07

Recently, it has been too slow. Generally, it takes half a month to assign an editor.

miserablee 2023-07-07

I submitted it on 6/24 and it is still submitted.

FDDXC 2023-07-06

The review process was a bit slow, but the editing was really fast! Finally completed and celebrating!
5.1 submitted
5.19 with editor
5.19 under review
6.2 major revision
6.19 resubmitted
6.27 accepted

水手有点不怕水 2023-07-06

4.23 submitted
5.15 under review
6.6 major revision
6.26 revised
7.6 accepted

Translation:
4.23 submitted
5.15 under review
6.6 major revision
6.26 revised
7.6 accepted

xj1730 2023-07-06

7.1 日 submitted 7.6 日 still in the old state, a bit sluggish.

AXB111 2023-07-05

7/5 submit is slow and gives me a headache, AFM also took half a month to submit before.

我就改个名字 2023-07-05

4.7 AFM converted to small
5.24 Major revision
6.12 Revised
6.26 Accept
7.4 Online