Verified Reviews - Small
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

小白就是我 2023-07-30

Similarly, I also came from the 7th and 15th. It has been 15 days and it hasn't been processed yet. Last year, I submitted an article and it was accepted in 20 days. This time it's really slow.

第二性原理@xf 2023-07-30

7.20 transferred over from am and said it will be submitted for review.
7.30 it is still submitted, the speed is really speechless, how much longer will it be dragged on?

少爷 2023-07-29

Which one, CEJ or Small, is more recognized by Loulou?

Dr. g 2023-07-29

Does the editing of "small" directly provide results after "under review"? Is there a status of "required reviews completed"?

XYZ 2023-07-29

Is there still no result? Did the reviewer reject the manuscript during the first review? I guess it's the reviewer who hasn't responded with feedback.

XYZ 2023-07-29

Does "under review" mean it will be accepted directly?

其实sir 2023-07-28

After revising, it will directly be under review.

XYZ 2023-07-28

After completing the submission, is there a status called "with editor"?

XYZ 2023-07-28

Is there no other status after revisions submitted? Is it directly accepted? Is there no "with editor" status?

XYZ 2023-07-28

After the resubmission status, is there a "with editor" status?

东阳同学 2023-07-28

2023.07.28 13:04 Still no news.

navier 2023-07-27

Hello, I am also in a similar situation as you. My AEM submission was rejected, so I switched to Small. I have submitted the revised draft, do I need to submit it for a second review? Thank you.

XYZ 2023-07-27

How long does it take from online publication to print publication?

xiao 2023-07-27

Translated text: On March 25th, transferred from AFM to small. On July 27th, still under review (first review result unknown). On June 26th, I inquired about the situation once, and the editor said that currently only one reviewer has replied. I need to receive a first review that can provide recent updates because the wait has been too long.

AXB111 2023-07-27

7/27 under review

东阳同学 2023-07-26

2023.05.03 Submitted to Angew, rejected, resubmitted to small
2023.05.07 Submitted to small
2023.06.19 Major revision
2023.07.07 Resubmitted
2023.07.10 Under Review
2023.07.26 11:25 No news yet.

Yongfeng-YZU 2023-07-26

"Confirmation required on Small system login."

往前走 2023-07-24

No changes yet, I don't know what's going on. Urgent!

其实sir 2023-07-24

Thank you for the reviewer's kindness and acceptance.

其实sir 2023-07-24

At the beginning, it was indeed slow, but it got faster later on. Haha, it's finished, celebrate!

Yusheng Luo 2023-07-24

Has the original poster changed?

tzl6880 2023-07-24

Is there any progress, OP?

tzl6880 2023-07-24

05 Jul 2023 AEM Transfer
10 Jul 2023 With Editor
Until now With Editor
Is it necessary to write a reminder letter (it has been under preliminary review for 19 days, no progress, and has not been submitted for review)?

xj1730 2023-07-22

7.15 Under Review, 7.22 还是Under Review translates to "7.15 Under Review, 7.22 still Under Review" in English.

Renqin 2023-07-22

I also want to ask, why is it so slow?

少爷 2023-07-21

5.29 Transfer AFM (First submission to the Wiley system, the supervisor is not a prominent figure, so it was not sent for review)
6.14 Under review
6.27 Major revision (1 major revision, 2 minor revisions)
7.03 Resubmit
7.04 Under review
7.21 Accept

Xueyingyingying 2023-07-21

How is the original poster now? Is it still submitted?

细胞外囊泡 2023-07-21

Why is your school's manuscript so fast? I was accepted on July 6th, and today is the 21st, but I still haven't received the manuscript email.

今天努力了吗 2023-07-19

Have you received a reply from the editor? I just reviewed it a month ago as well.

zhenzhen 2023-07-19

My submission was sent on May 20th, but I haven't received any news yet. I sent an email two days ago to inquire about it~

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started