HanHanWen 2023-08-01

I have been audited for 8 months already...

乘风去追梦 2023-07-11

It has been more than a month and a half, and I am still with the editor. Sigh, feeling mentally exhausted.

yhz123 2023-07-10

Are you in RRC state now? I have been in this state for almost half a month, and the review process has been going on for about 3 months.

HijackS 2023-07-09

It has been over three months with no news...

Benny丶 2022-10-18

The speed is really too slow. It has been five months since the external review, and there is no news.

仗剑走天涯 2022-09-18

I have been waiting for the first round of review for nearly half a year, and still haven't received any review results (checked on the official submission-tracking service). After seeing your situation, I have already requested a withdrawal from the editorial department. However, until now, it has been two weeks and the withdrawal has not been processed yet.
In addition, the review speed of this journal is extremely polarized. Some articles are reviewed within two to three months, while others can take up to a year or more. It's quite puzzling.

Alex_NUAA 2022-07-05

I have sent 10 emails, the results are unknown, and it took a total of 21 months.

折枝远处 2022-04-19

Each time the repair increases the number of reviewers, with 3 reviewers for the initial review, 2 additional reviewers for the first revision, and 1 additional reviewer for the second revision, making a total of 6 reviewers before and after.

折枝远处 2022-04-19

Here is the review process:

2021.5.17 Submitted to the Journal
7.29 Major Revision
8.21 submitted to the Journal
8.XX With editor
8.30 Under Review (review process begins)
9.15 Under Review (first review comments)
10.26 Required Reviews Completed (second review comments)
11.02 Under Review (change)
11.19 Under Review (change)
11.30 Under Review (change)
2022.1.18 Required Reviews Completed
1.21 Major Revision
2.25 Revision Submitted to Journal
2.25 With Editor
2.28 Under Review
3.7 Under Review
3.22 Under Review
4.11 Required Reviews Completed
4.12 Accept

hongss 2022-04-19

Big brother, how is your situation now? I have been waiting for the editor's review for over ten days now. I have heard from others that this journal is very slow, and I am getting anxious. Can you please share your contact information so that we can exchange experiences? My QQ number is 821314717 (please add a note with "big brother").

Alex_NUAA 2022-03-01

I have sent 8 emails, and the outcome is unknown.

爱民 2022-01-13

May I ask, after submitting the manuscript, is it necessary for all authors to confirm before the editor will review it?

Alex_NUAA 2021-12-24

Congratulations, congratulations! Rubbing on some European luck!

scccsccc 2021-12-21

Why did the upgraded version drop back to Zone 3? I don't quite understand the classification system of the Chinese Academy of Sciences. The quality of this journal is really not bad.

鸡鸡叫，哇哇哇 2021-12-21

It took nearly a year, but finally received, happy!!!

Alex_NUAA 2021-10-15

Oct 19, 2020: Submitted
Sep 25, 2020: Under Review
Oct 15, 2021: Results unknown, reminded 4 times
Aug 12, 2022: Took 22 months, sent 14 personal emails during the process, advisor sent 3 emails, finally rejected
Editor's attitude is okay, but actions are inefficient, be cautious in choosing.

yijunhui 2021-08-21

Posted in February 2020, the manuscript has been in the hands of the editor for two months without any news. During this period, I have reminded them twice, and only found a reviewer in the end. During the four months of reviewing, I reminded them twice, and they said they couldn't find a suitable reviewer. In the end, they directly rejected it. They won't take any initiative if you don't remind them. The feedback they provided after six months is also very vague. It's a waste of time for nothing!

笨柳 2021-04-30

Where did you find your Word template?

鸡鸡叫，哇哇哇 2021-03-30

Is this journal good?

鸡鸡叫，哇哇哇 2021-03-30

You only had one month for the first trial?

贪吃蛇恒恒 2021-03-22

2020.01.03: Submitted
2020.02.19: First review, major revisions, received over ten comments from three reviewers, two of which were quite critical
2020.03.10: Revisions required
2020.04.20: Accepted directly

shawxu 2021-03-12

May I ask why you shouldn't directly respond to the comments from the review?

yijunhui 2021-01-30

Hello, I would like to ask what is the similarity checking rate for this journal?