lxj 2023-05-05

What happened in the end, mine also changed from editor invited to editor assigned, and then changed back to editor invited.

Boreas_Lee 2023-04-04

Hello, may I ask if the rejection was directly given by the editor, or was it rejected after being reviewed by the reviewer who provided comments that did not align with the research direction?

Boreas_Lee 2023-03-31

3.14投 - Submitted on March 14th
3.16 editor assigned - Editor assigned on March 16th
3.30 under review - Currently being reviewed as of March 30th

yifei 2023-02-09

After major repairs and returns, it took about one month to be hired, and it has been approximately five months since the first submission.

yifei 2023-01-06

01.05 under review

yifei 2022-12-30

12.26 Revised version submitted
12.28 Editor invited

comaclc 2022-12-11

Received a rejection notice last night, the reason being that it did not align with the journal's research focus. Well, I guess it's my fault for taking two weeks to submit it, I was just being too indecisive.

comaclc 2022-12-09

12.8 The status has changed back to editor assigned.

comaclc 2022-12-08

Yesterday, the status changed to Editor Invited.

comaclc 2022-12-07

It has been over a week since submission, but the editor has still not been assigned.

yifei 2022-10-31

2022.10.20 - Return to first-instance opinions, major revisions, numerous opinions, currently being adjusted.

yifei 2022-09-17

9.06 submitted
9.7 editor assigned
9.16 editor invited
9.17 under review

yifei 2022-09-13

Hello, may I ask what the reason is for not submitting the rejected manuscript for review?

Rubin8 2022-07-29

Two months, not submitted for review, according to the draft.

COSMOS 2022-07-19

9 reviewers, nearly 50 questions, the reviewers were very meticulous, and their feedback helped to improve the article three times.

Rubin8 2022-07-12

Has your situation changed? Any progress?

Rubin8 2022-07-11

Is there any progress on your side?

Rubin8 2022-07-04

No change in status.

Smlie20 2022-06-23

Submitted on June 14th, it is still editor assigned. I don't know how long it will take...

Rubin8 2022-06-09

Posted on May 21st, Editor Assigned on May 23rd. It has been half a month now, and there has been no change in status. I'm getting really anxious waiting.

ioicfish 2022-03-27

Uploaded the second draft on March 7th, passed the second review on the 24th, and accepted minor revisions. The publication date has not been notified yet. Excluding holiday time, the review speed is relatively normal (around 2-3 months in total), with a total of 7 reviewers. The major revision comments provided were very detailed, indicating that it is a relatively responsible journal. It deserves praise.

ioicfish 2022-02-18

Submitted on December 20th, but coincided with the Christmas holiday abroad. No one was working until mid-January when the review process began.
On February 4th, a notice for major revisions was issued, and it took approximately one month, including the deduction of 20 days for holidays, to receive the notice.
Currently, the paper is being revised, hoping it will pass... I am so anxious about when it will be published... Once it is published, it will be over...

houxiaoka 2022-02-15

Received the message of acceptance, happy, wishing the journal to become better and better.

houxiaoka 2022-02-10

Returned draft on February 8, 2022. Currently, it is "Editor Assigned." I am unsure if it will be sent for review again, but I am hoping for a positive outcome.

houxiaoka 2022-02-02

Impressive, impressive, four articles. What field are you in? May I add you as a friend to consult about submitting academic papers?

houxiaoka 2022-01-19

Posted on October 11th, 21. Major revision on December 16th. Reworked on January 17th, 22. Currently, it is an Editor Invited status, hoping for a positive outcome.

Jack07 2021-08-12

Submitted at the end of April, the first round of reviews will be received in two months. There are nine reviewers, and around 80 comments were received from seven reviewers. After major revisions are made, it will take about one month for minor revisions. After the minor revisions are made, it will take approximately one week for acceptance. Overall, the speed is acceptable. Wishing the journal continued success.

Y.R. Niu 2021-02-25

Because the research direction is relatively niche, it is difficult to find reviewers, so the process takes a longer time.
Submitted on 2020.08.26
Major revisions suggested on 2021.01.27
Modifications completed on 2021.02.18, second review
Accepted one week later.

Steven 2021-02-04

Journals have made significant progress in terms of efficiency of peer review, editors' attitude and fairness, professionalism of review comments, quality and quantity of published articles, impact factor, influence, and reputation. We hope that the journal can soon enter the second zone of the Chinese Academy of Sciences and Q1 of JCR. The achievements of the journal are not easy to come by and are the result of the joint efforts of authors, editors, peer reviewers, and readers. We hope that everyone can jointly uphold the reputation of the journal, create a more positive and healthy academic ecosystem, firmly resist negative influences that affect the development of journals, support the benign development of journals through practical actions, and promote the progress of everyone's academic and professional career, achieving a win-win goal for the development of the journal and our personal development.