&冬季 2023-07-19

I have already uploaded for four months, but the first review is quite fast!

zffc 2023-07-17

The revised manuscript has been uploaded for over two months and it is still "Under Review". Isn't this too slow? How long does it usually take to receive feedback on a revised manuscript?

&冬季 2023-05-10

Is it the email address of the editor-in-chief that I should send the email to, as stated on the journal's homepage?

马航 2023-04-11

I have urged several times already and sent a message to the editor-in-chief, and the editor-in-chief responded very quickly. This journal's reviewers are really frustrating. Can't they at least give a reply or any update? I have seen comments that are almost not more than four months old, so I guess I might have to wait for four months. The main issue is that I need it urgently.

IE小硕 2023-04-06

Three months is too normal...

马航 2023-03-27

It has been three months, and it is still under review. What's going on with this journal?

&冬季 2023-01-30

Just invested, don't know, hope the efficiency can be higher.

马航 2023-01-04

How long did everyone's "Under review" last?

小耗子123 2022-11-04

Hello, after my paper was accepted, I received an email to submit the final draft file. However, it seems that there has been a problem with replying to the email, as I keep receiving the same email. Could you please tell me how to submit the aforementioned file? Thank you!

上善若水 2022-10-23

Finally hired on October 20, 2022, after spending a year, it really wasn't worth it.

上善若水 2022-09-29

No, I have reminded 6 times in a month. Let's wait a few more days, if it still doesn't work, then I will withdraw the submission. It might be a problem with the chief editor. I will send an email to other chief editors, they usually reply quickly.

zcy_517 2022-09-29

Is there any news? I have been waiting for 6 months for the second repair to be returned, but despite all the reminders, there has been no response. It's really frustrating.

上善若水 2022-08-16

The journal with the longest review period has very low efficiency.
Submitted on October 29, 2021.
Major revision on January 28, 2022.
Revised on March 11, 2022.
Minor revision on May 17, 2022.
Revised again on June 7, 2022.
Under review since July 26, 2022.
Why did it take more than 50 days to be under review? This journal is too slow, and I do not recommend submitting to it.

翻译川 2022-06-05

How long does everyone's "Under Review" status last?

上善若水 2022-04-05

Has the original poster received any updates? It's been two months since I submitted my revised article and I haven't heard anything. I'm getting quite anxious.

爱祖国 2022-01-24

Excuse me, does this journal really require a recommendation for a reviewer? What should I do? It's so troublesome.

爱祖国 2022-01-24

Could you please explain the difference between the case study in this publication and regular research? Which category does a case study fall under in research?

小川03 2022-01-15

Brothers, keep it up!!

IE小硕 2022-01-13

2021-4-12 Submission
2021-4-14 Under review
2021-8-02 Evaluating recommendation
2021-8-27 Major revision
2021-10-11 Revision submitted
2021-11-19 Under review
No result yet, so slow. Hope to receive a good result soon....

精雕玉琢1 2021-11-28

Did your "under review" status last for 4 months? And then it directly changed to "evaluating recommendation"?

精雕玉琢1 2021-11-27

May I ask if this journal will remain under review until evaluating the recommendation? Are there any status changes such as "waiting reviewer assignment" in between?

My article has been under review for two weeks since it was submitted.

Chenlili 2021-10-26

Is there no formatting requirement for this initial submission?

IE小硕 2021-10-24

2021-4-12 Post submitted
2021-4-14 Under review
2021-8-02 Evaluating recommendation
2021-8-27 Major revision
2021-10-21 Revision submitted
It has been two weeks, and the editor has not processed it yet. I don't know what the situation is... It's too slow... I pray for a quick and good result...

Wanhong Li 2021-10-23

2020-11-25 submitted
2020-12-21 major revision
2021-01-04 revision submitted
2021-05-28 major revision
2021-06-02 revision submitted
2021-06-05 requested to resubmit to Wiley's new submission system
2021-06-18 under review
2021-09-20 minor revision
2021-10-02 revision submitted
2021-10-06 accepted
Underwent two major revisions and one minor revision. It took more than 10 months.

IE小硕 2021-09-01

2021-4-12 Submission
2021-4-14 Under review
2021-8-02 Evaluating recommendation
2021-8-27 Major revision
Make significant improvements, hoping to be accepted in the end!

IE小硕 2021-08-16

2021-4-12 Submission
2021-4-14 under review
2021-8-02 evaluating recommendation
No further updates until 8.16... It's really slow, hoping for a good outcome soon.

IE小硕 2021-04-18

2021-4-12 Post
2021-4-14 under review
Praying for a good outcome