科研小白 2023-08-01

7.9 with editor: This means that the given text has been reviewed and has received a score of 7.9 by an editor.

8.1 under review: This implies that the text is currently being reviewed and has not yet received a final score.

科研小白 2023-07-25

It has been nearly a month and still with the editor, too slow.

大海2 2023-07-20

Exactly one month, Fan editor rejected my submission. Suspect deliberately timing the rejection. This is the second time this has happened, giving random reasons that do not match the theme for rejection. Both times happened to be exactly one month apart, it's truly frustrating.

大海2 2023-07-15

It has been almost a month with the editor, why is there still no news? It would be nice if they could reject the manuscript promptly as well.

Klaus 2023-07-12

2023.5.20 - Submitted to journal
2023.7.4 - Under review

大海2 2023-06-20

I want to know how to avoid submitting the manuscript to the fan editor. Do you have any experienced brothers who understand this?

可乐ii 2023-06-07

Yu editor's processing speed is very fast, thank you.

可乐ii 2023-06-07

2023.4.6 submitted to journal
2023.4.7 returned, format incorrect
2023.4.20 under review
2023.5.9 major revision
2023.5.22 with editor
2023.5.24 under review
2023.6.7 accepted
The review process was fast, with two reviewers. The first reviewer provided 3 major revision suggestions and several minor revision suggestions. The second reviewer provided around twenty suggestions.

阡陌yyds 2023-05-18

2023.3.16 submitted to journal.
2023.3.22 with editor
2023.3.23 returned, incorrect format
2023.3.25 submitted to journal
2023.3.28 with editor
2023.4.15 under review
2023.5.1 major revision
2023.5.9 submitted
2023.5.11 with editor
2023.5.12 under review
2023.5.17 accepted
The first submission took a while for the editor to process, but the review was quick. It took ten days for major revisions and the paper was directly accepted. It was my first time publishing a paper, and luck was on my side. The chief editor was very nice.

素昕 2023-05-09

With the editor for nearly a month, and directly rejected. It is advised to urgently switch to a different journal. Be cautious when submitting, as the processing speed of the manuscript is quite slow.

vlk 2023-04-09

With editor will send you an email, and below there will be a signature. If it is still with editor after a month, there is a high probability that it is Academician Fan. If it is Editor-in-chief Wu, the speed will be very fast.

学术阳 2023-04-06

Waited for a whole three months, but what I received was a rejection! Two reviewers, one suggested resubmission, while the other recommended rejection. The final decision was to reject it. Many of the reviewers' comments were also quite forced, so I really advise everyone to be cautious when submitting and avoid pitfalls!

期待论文中 2023-04-06

It has been almost a month since I submitted my manuscript to the editor. How about yours?

期待论文中 2023-04-06

It has been almost a month since I submitted mine, how about yours? Has it been reviewed?

期待论文中 2023-04-06

Brother, may I know where you saw the assignment of which editor? It has been almost a month for me too, still "with editor".

叁浪 2023-03-12

2022.11.14 submitted to journal;
2022.11.16 with editor;
2022.11.30 under review;
2022.12.15 under review;
2023.01.10 under review;
2023.01.19 under review;
2023.02.06 under review;
2023.02.07 under review;
2023.02.16 major revision;
2023.02.27 submitted;
2023.02.27 with editor;
2023.02.28 under review;
2023.03.08 accept.

The review process took three months, with each round of editing taking half a month. The first review required major revisions, which were completed and resubmitted within ten days, resulting in immediate acceptance. The handling by the editor-in-chief was relatively fast.

vlk 2023-03-04

Academician Fan's behavior is truly speechless. He tells me that my grammar is not good after more than a month. I have previously submitted two articles here, both of which were edited by Editor Wu smoothly. I really don't understand why Academician Fan suddenly comes up with this reason. It would be better if they could provide a normal reason for rejection. After waiting for more than a month, the editor finally gives me this reason.

BertramAZhang 2023-02-25

Afterwards, I discovered that the relevant emails were sent to the corresponding author, and my submission email and corresponding author's email are not the same. Generally, if there is a change in status, you will receive an email quickly (the efficiency of PT editors is very high, so I want to thank them). If you haven't received any emails, you can remind the corresponding author to check their email. I wish all teachers and students a smooth submission!

BertramAZhang 2023-01-29

Hello everyone! After the article was accepted, the following changes occurred:
Offprint order letter sent to you for completion

But it has been two days now, and I have not received any related emails. Is this normal? Has anyone else encountered this issue? How did you handle it?

良人无梦 2022-12-16

Has your submission been reviewed? Mine has been with the editor for almost one.

xxff 2022-12-16

22.12.11 Post
22.12.13 With Editor
Hurry up and submit for review

良人无梦 2022-12-15

Has it not been submitted for review yet? Have you also encountered this problem?

做个混子 2022-12-11

Excuse me, has it been submitted for review now?

Xinn19 2022-12-09

The final submitted paper has an overall similarity rate of less than 15%, with an individual literature similarity rate of less than 1%.

良人无梦 2022-12-06

I submitted it on November 23rd, and it is still in the editor's hands on December 6th.

摸鱼选手 2022-12-03

May I ask what is the usual control rate for duplication?

Xinn19 2022-11-23

2022/11/23 accept - This phrase is already in English.

Xinn19 2022-11-23

Resubmission process:
2022/8/23 submitted to journal
2022/8/30 under review
2022/10/18 required reviews completed, minor revision
2022/11/04 under review
2022/22/23 accepted
Handled by Editor Wu, the speed is really fast!

大王来寻山 2022-10-16

May I ask how long it takes to go online and be published?

大王来寻山 2022-10-16

May I ask how long it takes to be indexed and searchable after going online?