小黑 2023-07-03

April 20th, submit to the journal
April 22nd, with editor
April 25th, under review
May 17th, reconsideration following revision
June 8th, resubmit
June 9th, accept

学术小趴菜 2023-06-01

After changing the language and returning, it was rejected again due to a high repetition rate.

CExplorer 2023-01-06

From June to October 2022, there were three rounds of revisions, as it was said that the final reviewer couldn't be found. On November 1, 2022, due to the highly positive evaluation given by the first reviewer, minor revisions were requested. Then, on November 15, 2022, the minor revisions were submitted, and on November 16, 2022, they were accepted.

memory111 2022-12-08

May I ask how long it takes for the results to come out for "under review"?

Leon8812 2022-12-06

Posted on August 4th, I submitted two recommended reviewers as requested. Then, with the editor, one recommended reviewer was chosen, while the other one was changed three times. Finally, on November 1st, feedback for revisions was received, stating that major changes were required. The second reviewer was very meticulous and pointed out all the issues regarding grammar, wording, and analytical methods. On November 30th, the manuscript along with the Response to Reviewers was re-uploaded. On the evening of December 5th, the system displayed "completed accept." The entire process took a total of 4 months, with 0.5 months for the editor's decision, 2.5 months for review, 1 month for revisions, and 5 days for the results after re-uploading. I hope this information can be useful for everyone.

学术小趴菜 2022-11-16

Currently in the process of revising, planning to finish the revision and re-submit.

CExplorer 2022-11-15

I also started by being rejected, then I made language revisions and continued to submit to this journal, and now it has been minorly revised.

hirako 2022-11-11

I also did. The manuscript I submitted a couple of days ago was immediately rejected, as they said my English proficiency did not meet the requirements. Did you resubmit it later?

学术小趴菜 2022-11-04

The submission was rejected after 3 days, citing language proficiency mismatch. It is recommended that someone whose native language is English should make the language revisions.

CExplorer 2022-10-08

Actually, you can just download a version of "just accept" and make some changes according to it.

dhjcp3 2022-09-02

Look at fate, some are fast, some are slow. The fast ones take around three to four months, while my manuscript review took eight to nine months. It took about a year overall before it was accepted.

讨厌韩国人 2022-08-22

4.16 Submitted
4.29 Under reviewer
6.14 First review comments returned, issues are not difficult
7.1 Returned
7.25 Second review comments returned, let me delete "共一"
8.1 Submitted
8.22 Accepted

Wsp 2022-08-09

Hello, may I ask how the final result is for everyone? It has been 8 months for me as well, sobbing. I am thinking of using the system's built-in email to send it. Is there a better way or any other editing email? Thank you.

艾小颠 2022-07-31

The slowest magazine I have ever submitted to, without a doubt.
Initially submitted on 22-1-5, after sending countless reminder letters, it is currently under review as of 6-29.

CExplorer 2022-04-17

Posted on February 9, 2022
Revised format on February 10, 2022, with editor
Decision in processing on February 12, 2022
Rejected on February 13, 2022
Reason for rejection: Suggested modification of the language in the article

Resubmitted on April 13, 2022
With editor on April 14, 2022
Under review on April 16, 2022

505105793@qq.com 2022-04-07

Is there any other way to contact the editor, or should I withdraw my submission now since it is still under review since August 21st and it is now April of 22nd year?

505105793@qq.com 2022-04-07

Submitted in August 2022, under review in October, still under review in April. I have sent multiple emails through the system to inquire about the status of the manuscript but have not received any response. Is there any other way to contact the journal? If it is going to be rejected, please don't waste my time anymore. I am feeling frustrated.

123wym 2022-03-29

The review process is extremely slow. It took six months to submit, and it has been under review all along. I followed up twice in the meantime, but received no response! After six months, the editor said there were too many submissions in this area and it lacked innovation??? I would like to ask, if that's the case, why send it for external review and waste six months of my time? It's terrifying! Please be cautious when submitting, it's unreliable!!

zbldulling 2022-01-17

A top journal in the field, belonging to the second-tier category, with a high level of professional recognition. Compared to other journals, the speed of manuscript review is relatively fast. Generally, manuscripts are reviewed within a week after submission, and it takes about 1-2 months to receive reviewer comments.

The overall submission process for this time is as follows: The manuscript was submitted on August 29th, and the editor requested language revisions. After revising the language, the manuscript was resubmitted on September 1st. There was a revision process in between, and the revised manuscript was submitted on January 4th. The acceptance notification was received on January 14th. Overall, the review process was relatively fast.

miles0 2022-01-14

Submitted on November 22, 2021, accepted on January 5, 2022, with one revision in between.

北雁南飞 2022-01-06

4.12 Submission with editor
5.24 Under review
7.24 Revision (three reviewers)
8.23 Resubmission with editor
12.9 Accepted

505105793@qq.com 2021-10-26

Submitted on August 10th, 2021, still with editor on October 26th, slow.