zyp210 2023-06-24

May I ask, when replying to the comments of the manuscript review, in addition to making changes in the article, is it necessary to directly address the opinions of the reviewing experts point by point?

Adiao 2023-04-15

After more than two months of submission without any progress, I sent an email inquiry and received a rejection stating that it "does not fit within the journal's scope for publication." I feel very frustrated.

Adiao 2023-04-04

It has been almost two months and it has not been submitted for review yet. Can I urge them? Is this a tragedy in the making?

Adiao 2023-03-03

Submitted on February 7th, the status is still "with editor" to this day.

Huiskie 2022-12-14

Second submission of PhB, a review article.
Two days after submission, external review was conducted, and 44 days later, the review was returned with two minor revisions.
One day after the revisions were made, the article stayed in the "with editor" status for a month before being sent for review again.
20 days later, the review was returned, and the same day, the editor accepted the revisions.
The editor highly respects the opinions of the reviewers and the journal is very friendly.

二两. 2022-03-11

Posted in early October, returned for revision after one month, and returned after 40 days of supplementary experiments. The second review took about one month. The second review included a minor revision and formatting changes in six places. It was returned after four days. Four days after being sent to the editor, it was directly accepted. Two days after acceptance, the proofreading draft was received, and it took two days to check. After submission, it went online the next day. In short, personally, I think it's not bad. The reviewers invited were also kind, and the editing efficiency was high. The whole process took about four months, I don't know if it was because of Christmas. Recommended!

Cyanide灰 2021-03-10

Share the submission process for everyone's reference:
2020/11/03 Submitted to journal
2020/11/04 With Editor
2020/11/09 Under Review
2020/11/21 Under Review
2020/12/04 Under Review
2021/01/08 Sent email to urge review
2021/01/12 Received reply, reviewer unavailability
2021/01/18 Under Review
2021/02/03 Under Review
2021/02/21 Major Revision
2021/03/05 Revised
2021/03/05 With Editor
2021/03/10 Accepted