nikoe 2023-08-08

Does this journal have a template?

NIUBI 2023-06-15

PR series journals, the difficulty of submitting articles is high, with PRL being the most difficult, followed by NJP, PRA, and PRE. After major revisions, minor revisions are made, and finally accepted. The level of the editors and reviewers is very high.

optics 皮卡丘 2023-04-05

Has your manuscript been submitted for review?

xxlxaxx 2023-03-29

How difficult is the pra now? It was said before that it was very difficult to get it approved.

努力的逍遥 2021-07-21

You should not engage in scientific research if you are this kind of person. Mindless criticism, apart from the University of Science and Technology of China (USTC), you have published a lot in Physical Review A (PRA); there is even more publication in Physical Review B (PRB), isn't that just more watered down? Every journal has some low-quality articles, but overall the Physical Review series is still acceptable.

BDong 2021-03-18

Submitted on September 24, 2020, accepted on March 1, 2021.

The first impression is that it was slow. The first review took two months, and the feedback was a major revision without a specific deadline for modifications. The second review took over two months, and the last reviewer did not provide any feedback. One reviewer provided feedback three days after the associate editor's acceptance.

The second impression is that it was thorough. The reviewers were highly skilled and pointed out structural issues in the article. Their questions were well-thought-out. After acceptance, the proofreading by the publishing department was the most meticulous I have ever encountered, with many grammar issues being corrected.

Overall, it was a very pleasant submission experience.