109000 2023-07-24

5.9-submit
7.4-moderate revision
7.13-submit
7.24-accept

Translation:

5.9- Submit
7.4- Moderate revision
7.13- Submit
7.24- Accept

泓- 2023-07-19

Has the status of the manuscript review changed now?

HAHAHHAA 2023-06-29

When will the status change, may I ask?

HAHAHHAA 2023-06-29

From transferring from JPD, the status has always been "Transferred In". It has been a week, does anyone know when the status will change?

liali1 2023-06-27

What was thrown in January, had a major overhaul on April 13th, submitted on May 8th, and until today, June 27th, there has been no news at all. What's going on? I'm so anxious.

jinyan121 2023-06-20

Has it been four days since the transfer from JPD to draft status? Is this normal? How long does it usually take to start reviewing the manuscript?

SCI+EI 2023-06-11

2022.11.30 Manuscripts submitted
2022.12.10 Under review
2023.2.16 Major Revision
2023.3.15 Resubmit
2023.4.10 Moderate Revision
2023.4.18 Resubmit
2023.4.28 Formal Accept!
The entire process went smoothly. I conducted aerodynamic acoustics calculations, which belong to the nonlinear dynamics section of this journal. Both reviewers asked very professional questions. Especially the second reviewer, who highlighted and annotated specific details of the article, greatly helped improve its quality. Additionally, the senior and junior editors at the editorial department were very friendly. They reviewed the article patiently, although there was a slight delay due to a signature issue, they were understanding and provided time for proofreading revisions. Overall, this submission was very friendly and the experience was great. It is suitable for academic beginners. I hope everyone submits more articles to this journal. Hail to the journal!

L.L.L. 2023-05-18

How long does it take to receive the review comments? There has been no response so far...

WLXJX 2023-05-15

Excuse me, everyone, how is the processing speed of the recently submitted manuscripts by the editors? I returned the revised manuscript on April 25th, and the status is still "Manuscript Received" now. How about yours?

tdon 2023-04-29

Also, JPD transferred here, but it has been four to five days and the status still shows as "transferred in." May I ask how long it takes to change on your side?

yyllly 2023-04-24

The editing speed is fast, but the speed of the reviewers is a bit slow. It has been revised three times.

辛苦的科研狗 2023-04-19

Will it be resubmitted for review after the manuscript is rejected?

liali1 2023-04-12

I submitted it in January, and it has been over 20 days since it's "awaiting decision." I'm so anxious and worried that it might delay my graduation.

chaos_ 2023-04-07

It has been two weeks since I submitted, and it is still "manuscript received"... speechless...

忆一怡 2023-04-07

It has been 8 days since submission, and it is still "Manuscript Received." How long does it take to undergo review?

zhangyuxiwnag 2023-03-24

In the past three and a half months, I mainly wasted a month by myself. The editor is quite responsible and does a good job.

littlepig 2023-03-21

May I ask what format the transferred number is in? Why is my number just "draft"? The status has always been "Transferred In".

kkzj 2023-02-17

May I ask what is happening now?

jingda 2023-01-27

A work from our research group has been submitted to JPD and transferred here. I don't know what the status will be like, but let's see how our peers handle it. Overall, the difficulty is expected to be lower than JPD.

suvar 2022-12-29

Transferred from the optical magazine, the editing efficiency is very high. I hope the journal will continue to improve.

maibeibu 2022-08-30

What are the different statuses for manuscript submission in this journal? It has been around ten days since I submitted, and the status has remained as "Manuscript Received."

Tomyuan 2022-06-29

Does this journal require a publication fee?

sypsyp 2022-06-18

Here is the translation of the given text into English:

Received 4 May 2022
Revised 14 June 2022
Accepted 17 June 2022

lingxuan 2022-05-08

31-May-2021: Submitted
16-Jul-2021: Major revise
11-Aug-2021: Submitted
14-Aug-2021: Awaiting Referee Reports
09-Sep-2021: Awaiting Decision
16-Sep-2021: Submitted
17-Sep-2021: Awaiting Referee Reports
27-Sep-2021: Awaiting Decision
27-Sep-2021: Provisionally Accepted
30-Sep-2021: Formal Accepted
30-Sep-2021: Online

sypsyp 2022-04-16

2022/1/21 Submit
2022/2/17 Reject to Resubmit
2022/3/05 Minor Revision
2022/3/08 Formal Accept
A very fast journal with continuously increasing impact factor!

jingda 2022-04-05

During my second year of research, I received an invitation to review for this journal. This is because I have previously reviewed papers for JPD, which is also a journal under IOP. The evaluation options for the review are basically similar to JPD, and generally speaking, as long as the content is not obviously inadequate, passing the editorial review is not too difficult. Compared to the content, everyone pays more attention to innovation. Making some major revisions should be enough to pass.

Engeoman 2021-12-19

Physica Scripta is a journal sponsored by the Institute of Physics (IOP) and the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences. It is highly regarded by European researchers. It is relatively niche in China, but last year, a study on roadbed dynamic response was fortunate enough to be recognized and published. The first and second rounds of review typically take about two months each. Once accepted, the article receives a DOI within 24 hours, and an unformatted version can be downloaded online. The proof system is user-friendly, but only provides a one-day window for revisions. After proofing, the article will be officially published within 10 days. It takes an additional two weeks to one month for the article to be searchable on Web of Science (WoS).

212121 2021-12-15

The translation of the text "速度很快，祝期刊越办越好！" into English is: "Very fast, I wish the journal to continue to improve!"

ma111 2021-09-17

Great journal! The review and editing process is very fast. I hope it continues to improve.

资深柚子 2021-09-17

The research group has never submitted before, and they were worried about rejection after seeing the evaluations here. They decided to give it a try and the results were very promising. It seems that this journal is relatively niche in China, with not many people around aware of it. The quality should be slightly lower compared to JPD.