WT121 2023-08-03

Jan, 2023: Submit
Apr, 2023: Revise and Reconsider
Apr, 2023: Resubmit
25-Jul, 2023: Completed Accept
Both reviewers are fellow professionals, to put it bluntly, they seem to be less competent than expected.

小蜜蜂2018 2023-07-28

Admire the fast review process.

强化学徒 2023-07-26

Both the first and second trials can be single-column, there is no specific requirement.

强化学徒 2023-07-26

My shift is from July 8th to July 24th, over. So it depends on the situation, good luck.

强化学徒 2023-07-26

I noticed that many friends in the comments mentioned the issue of NP's 80% acceptance rate. I also paid attention to this data and found that it is biased. Last year, NP accepted around 1500 articles in one year, but the number of submissions far exceeded 4000. Especially after becoming a top journal in Zone 2 this year, I guess the total number of submissions for the entire year of 2023 will exceed 8000. So everyone needs to reassess this journal.

强化学徒 2023-07-26

The first review had two reviewers who are both experts in the field of reinforcement learning. One reviewer, Reviewer A, highly appreciated the writing, innovation, performance, and impact of this article. The other reviewer, Reviewer B, also appreciated it but provided some crucial suggestions for modification. For example, they suggested that I include information about the cost, time consumption, and computational complexity of the proposed method, as well as adding more baseline comparison curves.

强化学徒 2023-07-26

On February 15th, 2023, submission.
On April 10th, 2023 (Monday), at 2:27 PM, received the first review comments, revision.
Need to submit the revised version before May 22nd.
On May 19th, 2023, I submitted the revised version.
On July 9th, 2023, the number of reviews met the requirement.
On July 24th, 2023 (Monday), at 5:15 PM, received the acceptance email.
Submission cycle: 5 months.

justin 2023-07-18

How long have you been with the editor?

justin 2023-07-18

Avec l'éditeur

zfshi 2023-07-11

+1, with the editor rejecting it for a month. At that time, I submitted this for review, but it was not reviewed.

小蜜蜂2018 2023-07-10

It has been a month and a half since the submission of the second round of minor revisions, and there is still no result.

小蜜蜂2018 2023-07-10

The second trial has taken 10 months, and it has been a month and a half since the minor revision was submitted, but there is still no result. It has been 18 months since I first submitted it...

zyq121 2023-07-10

The rejection speed is very fast, without any review, directly rejected.

angeliacc 2023-07-07

Has your status changed? I have been with the editor for twenty days. Also, I would like to ask, what does "with editor" becoming "editor invited" mean? Does anyone know?

zfshi 2023-07-07

Can I ask if your situation has changed? I have also been with the editor for almost a month.

闲于 2023-07-02

Just invested, and found out that it's already over number 3600 in the queue.

zzr 2023-07-02

June 13, 2023 submission
June 14, 2023 with editor
July 2, 2023 with editor
This is too slow.

lll 2023-06-30

Just submitted, looking forward to the results. I wonder if this journal requires that references must cite papers from this journal.

nature and science 2023-06-28

Does "Decision in Process" mean that the associate editor has already made a decision and returned it to the editorial department, or does it mean that the associate editor may still be handling it?

nature and science 2023-06-28

I don't know why it's so slow. My second review has been in "Decision in Process" for twenty days already, and there is still no outcome.

hubhub 2023-06-27

I have been with the editor for a month as well.

上交彭于晏 2023-06-25

2023.06.02 Submitted with editor.

2023.06.25 Still with editor.

zzr 2023-06-22

How are you doing? I am also with an editor now.

CharlotteYYY 2023-06-20

If you haven't learned how to speak, you don't have to say anything. Everyone can communicate equally, and you're just here spewing nonsense, you idiot.

lei.... 2023-06-14

May I ask if this journal has a specific formatting requirement?

吉大吴彦祖 2023-06-13

Then you should probably know the result in the next two days. I hope you can win.

吉大吴彦祖 2023-06-13

Then you will probably know the results in the next two days.

上交彭于晏 2023-06-12

Submitted on June 2nd, still with editor.

吉大吴彦祖 2023-06-12

Don't believe the claim that LetPub has an average acceptance rate of 80%. From 2019 to 2022, they have accepted an average of 1500 articles per year, with submission numbers ranging from 6.1 to 3000+. The rejection rate can reach up to 75%. It is advised to be cautious when submitting to them.

吉大吴彦祖 2023-06-11

Being rejected with such a reason is really annoying.