Verified Reviews - Nature Geoscience
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

一刀倾城 2022-10-14

Third round of review
Manuscript accepted - October 11, 2022
Decision sent to author - October 11, 2022
Manuscript under consideration - October 8, 2022
Editor assigned - September 30, 2022
Manuscript submitted - September 30
Submission in process - September 30

一刀倾城 2022-10-14

Second Round Review:
Resubmission received 30th September 22
Awaiting resubmission 21st September 22
Decision sent to author 21st September 22
Manuscript under consideration 12th September 22
All Reviewers Assigned 25th August 22
Manuscript under consideration 22nd August 22
Editor Assigned 22nd August 22
Manuscript submitted 21st August 22
Submission in process 21st August 22

一刀倾城 2022-10-14

First round of review
Resubmission received August 21, 2022
Decision sent to author July 15, 2022
Manuscript under consideration June 23, 2022
All Reviewers Assigned May 12, 2022
Manuscript under consideration May 6, 2022
Contacting Potential Reviewers April 26, 2022
Manuscript under consideration April 21, 2022
Editor Assigned April 15, 2022
Manuscript submitted April 13, 2022
Submission in process April 12, 2022

广西郭富城 2022-09-25

Big boss, congratulations.

一刀倾城 2022-09-23

The first sub-issue of life, focusing on a small problem that has been worked on for a long time, was repeatedly revised and submitted to Nature Geoscience. It took three months for the initial review and major revisions, and one month to complete the modifications and upload. After 25 days of re-review, an email was received from the editorial department stating that they would be happy to publish the article, pending minor revisions. As an individual, the article does not have any prestigious names attached to it. I am very fortunate and grateful to Nature Geoscience for giving me this opportunity.

111% 2021-08-16

Don't be discouraged, the fact that your research direction is geoscience (remote sensing) makes Nature Geoscience the dream of almost everyone in the field of earth sciences. With so many people around the world focusing on it, you can imagine how difficult it is to get published in this journal. There are only a few who can publish their work in the field of remote sensing, and even fewer in China. It's important to maintain a calm and positive mindset.

科研小白 2021-03-19

Submitted for 2 months, it has been under consideration as a manuscript all along, without being sent for review, and ultimately rejected. Moreover, the reasons for rejection are very perfunctory, stating that the subject matter is not suitable for publication. I really don't understand why this journal is so irresponsible. It took 2 months, and now there are many other good journals where the paper could have been published within 2 months. Please consider the time sensitivity of research results carefully.

有梦想的女博士 2021-03-05

May I ask how many days after each submission you will be notified to send it for external review?

Create your own webinar

Interested in hosting your own webinar? Check the schedule and propose your idea to the Peeref Content Team.

Create Now

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started