robot 2022-10-31

Today is October 31st, a full 20 days. The review process has been about 3 weeks, and I am looking forward to a positive outcome.

ABCDEDDFVS 2021-08-26

After one month of reviewing and major revisions, followed by a minor revision, the manuscript was accepted for publication the next day after the minor revision was submitted.

朱 2021-06-29

There will definitely be news after two months of review. The editor is relatively good.

Review process:
First review, one rejection and one revision request, the editor requested major revisions.
Second review, one rejection and one acceptance, the editor rejected it.

The reasons for the two rejections are not clear. The reviewers who were rejected thought it was due to data errors (which were not explicitly mentioned in the first review, so the revisions were not made in a timely manner).
In fact, it was a misunderstanding and not a data error, but rather an overlap in the peak spectrum (I would like to explain). I don't really like the vague rejection style of the reviewers, it seems they just don't like this short article.
In the end, the editor rejected it and there was no chance to explain.
I submitted two articles before and had similar issues (one rejection and one acceptance). The reviewers who rejected it seemed to have a higher level of subjectivity.
It's a very good journal! I will submit again if I have good data.

小小明 2021-01-29

9.20 submitting to journal
9.21 with editor
9.22 under review
、、、During the waiting process, send an email to inquire on 1.22
1.23 minor revise
1.25 resubmitted to journal
1.25 accepted

小小明 2021-01-16

How are yours? Mine still has no movement.

shawangrenjian 2021-01-08

2020.08.20投
It has been 5 months and still no news.
Is it because of the new coronavirus or something??