Chang0001 2023-07-31

Sharing submission experience
2022-10-12 submit manuscript
with editor This process really takes a long time
2023-2-28 under review
2023-5-24 1st reminder, received a reply 3 days later.
2023-6-12 Received feedback, accepted after minor revisions.
2023-6-21 Received revised manuscript.
2023-7-30 Accepted for publication.
The process is a bit slow. This is mainly due to the low number of published papers in the journal, especially the time taken from initial submission to peer review.

i6277 2023-06-09

Sharing the submission experience
Submitted on December 25, 2020
Reviewed by the editor one month later
Received reviewer comments on December 23, 2021, made minor revisions and published directly, with 5 reminders during the process.
Returned revised manuscript on December 27, 2021
Accepted on May 27, 2022, with 3 reminders during the process
Online on June 3, 2022
Entered SCIE on June 29, 2022
Officially published on August 2022
The process was very slow, possibly due to the scarcity of published manuscripts.

felix Guo 2023-05-22

What are the levels of revision for revise?

Chang0001 2023-05-15

Posted for 7 months and still under review.

tb96553712 2023-05-04

Submitted ten months ago and still under review.

tb96553712 2023-05-04

My submission has been pending for 10 months.

王皆书 2023-02-05

Four months of rejection, this journal is simply too slow, don't submit.

皮卡丘博士 2022-12-25

Look at the district, I just discovered today that when I voted, it was still District 2, but now it has changed to District 3. It's all a mystery.

i6277 2022-12-23

Now, the classification of the Chinese Academy of Sciences is mainly based on major categories or subcategories?

HijackS 2022-12-01

11.28 Submitted to Journal - This means that a document or article was sent to a journal for review or publication on November 28th.

11.30 With editor - This indicates that the document or article is currently being reviewed or processed by the editor on November 30th.

i6277 2022-10-18

The journal is very good, but the speed is slow. It takes a year for the review process to give minor revisions and publish. After submitting the revised version, it took 5 months to be accepted, and it will be indexed at the end of next month.

Hao0576 2022-07-14

One month with the editor

SCI_accepted 2022-07-14

It has been two and a half months with the editor. Do you all think it is necessary to withdraw the submission?

SCI_accepted 2022-06-30

I would like to ask everyone which email we should contact to urge manuscript submission. It seems that the submission system of this journal does not have a "send e-mail" option.

SCI_accepted 2022-06-30

I would like to ask everyone which email address to contact for submission reminders. It seems that this journal's submission system does not have the "send email" option.

xiaoz123 2022-06-14

May I ask how to contact the chief editor to remind them about the manuscript when it has been in the "with editor" status for a long time?

Hoist 2022-05-23

Today is 91 days away from the deadline (February 22, 2022). The status has been "with editor" all along, and it seems unlikely that I will be able to meet the deadline for the graduation scholarship. 0 0...

Hao0576 2022-03-31

2022-1-17 Submitted to journal office (With editor)
2022-1-22 Under review
2022-2-22 Decision in Process
2022-2-24 Major revisions
2022-3-11 Submitted to journal office (With editor)
2022-3-13 Under review
2022-3-28 Required Reviews Completed
2022-3-30 Reject

Translation:
2022-1-17 Submitted to journal office (With editor)
2022-1-22 Under review
2022-2-22 Decision in Process
2022-2-24 Major revisions
2022-3-11 Submitted to journal office (With editor)
2022-3-13 Under review
2022-3-28 Required Reviews Completed
2022-3-30 Reject

法国科研小白 2022-03-17

投出 - Submitted
一审 - First review
共3个月 - A total of 3 months
速度“正常” - Speed "normal"
6月出结果大修 - Results came out in June, major revisions
7月修回 - Revised in July
石沉大海了 - Sank into oblivion
9月份还在with editor - Still with editor in September
发邮件催过以后 - Sent emails to urge after
变成under review - Changed to under review
到2022年一月份 - Until January 2022
没消息 - No news
发邮件催 - Sent emails to urge
找不到审稿人 - Unable to find reviewers
让推荐审稿人 - Asked to recommend reviewers
推荐审稿人之后 - After recommending reviewers
又到现在完全没结果 - Still no results until now
保持每月一份邮件催稿 - Kept sending monthly email reminders
从投出到现在整整一年 - A whole year from submission until now.

枫间舞 2022-03-12

I am almost seven months old, really amazing.

wang2022211 2022-02-11

How long is the review period?

Bitliu35 2021-11-09

2021.03.20 Submission to the system;
2021.03.23 Assignment of manuscript code and review within a week;
2021.07.12 Feedback received, major revisions requested, with one month given for revisions;
2021.07.26 Revisions completed, resubmitted to the system, review received after a week;
2021.11.04 Acceptance.

The work was on robot control, and the entire process went relatively smoothly. Although there was a major revision during the first review, there were only 2 reviewers, and the second reviewer had no comments and approved it directly. The first reviewer had more comments, so after receiving the feedback, I thought there would be minor revisions, but I was informed directly that it was accepted. The reviewer's comments were quite professional, covering theoretical and experimental aspects, addressing issues that are of concern in the field. I made thorough revisions and provided positive responses, which resulted in good feedback and helped improve the quality of my paper.

hhhhit 2021-10-29

A couple of years ago, it was invested. The journal is highly recognized within the industry.

ai3yinuo 2021-10-21

The manuscript was reviewed for five months, and then it was rejected outright.

XYH_09 2021-10-18

2021.07.26 Submitted
2021.08.01 Under review
2021.08.12 Required reviews completed
2021.08.16 Decision in process
2021.08.21 Revise (Major)
2021.09.16 Submitted
2021.09.20 Required reviews completed
2021.09.22 Decision in process
2021.10.18 Accept

Translation:
2021.07.26 Submitted
2021.08.01 Under review
2021.08.12 Required reviews completed
2021.08.16 Decision in process
2021.08.21 Revise (Major)
2021.09.16 Submitted
2021.09.20 Required reviews completed
2021.09.22 Decision in process
2021.10.18 Accept

花の鳥 2021-08-30

This is simply a divine journal, with divine editors.
With the editor for 3 months.
After review, required reviews were completed in over a month.
Asked the secretary for 5 reviewers, 2 declined, 2 completed, and 1 didn't respond. Of course, the result still hasn't been released.
Now I only hope to be rejected soon so that I can submit to another journal. Otherwise, I will have to withdraw the manuscript after some time.

花の鳥 2021-08-15

How long does it take to get the results?

打工仔 2021-08-06

I have also been waiting for two months, and it is still under review. I don't know if I will be selected.

ai3yinuo 2021-07-02

It has been over two months and Mechatronics is still under review. I'm extremely anxious.

ai3yinuo 2021-07-02

It has been over two months and it is still under review in Mechatronics.