Verified Reviews - MECCANICA
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

喜欢就去争取 2023-05-31

05/31 Email reminder, it has been over 8 months since the first review, and the outcome is unknown.

深海深夜深 2023-05-11

投出 - Submitted on December 7th
接受 - Accepted on May 7th
大约2个月出一审意见,大修 - Approximately 2 months to receive the first review comments and make major revisions
一审回复后,大约再过2个月接受 - After receiving the first review response, it will take approximately another 2 months to be accepted.

喜欢就去争取 2023-05-08

05/07 under review. It was quite fast to have someone willing to review it, but the outcome is still unknown.

喜欢就去争取 2023-05-06

05/05 reviewers assigned I don't know if the previous person finished reviewing, so find another reviewer or ask the editor to find a new one if there has been no response.

喜欢就去争取 2023-05-05

It has been seven months since the submission, and there is still no result. I have sent four reminder emails, but no one has replied. Only one reply was received from the editorial office, stating that they had found a reviewer who agreed to review the manuscript. The waiting has been difficult, and I have decided to withdraw the submission if there is no result by June. I request careful consideration for a fast publication.

2022/09/21 new submission
2023/02/02 under review

叁饼 2022-11-17

May 27 submission;
August 4 major revision after the first review;
September 2 revised version;
October 17 minor revision after the second review;
October 20 revised version;
November 15 acceptance.

I personally think the speed is quite good, the entire process took less than 6 months, and the reviewers and editors were very diligent and responsible.

Dynamo Pooh 2021-08-25

It seems that now Springer requires submission to be synchronized with Research Square, which means the peer review process will be made public. Everyone will be able to see your article.

ABCDABCDABCD 2021-05-10

May I ask how you selected the "Research Square" option when submitting your manuscript?

Wales 2021-02-23

An SCI paper about a centrifugal pendulum vibration absorber was submitted on October 22, 2020. A major revision was requested on January 4, 2021, primarily focusing on significant improvements in language. After Letpub's polishing, it was resubmitted on February 2, 2021. On February 22, acceptance notification was received.

Create your own webinar

Interested in hosting your own webinar? Check the schedule and propose your idea to the Peeref Content Team.

Create Now

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started