该叫个啥呢 2023-08-08

Which editor? Did the two reviewers complete the review and does it mean RRC?

mei2023 2023-08-08

The second review is still pending for four completed drafts.

该叫个啥呢 2023-08-07

It seems that one out of the three reviewers has disappeared for the second review. Looks like I'll have to wait another month.

该叫个啥呢 2023-08-07

The first review requires major revisions. In the second review, there is a reviewer who consistently does not accept the evaluation. What should be done? There are a total of three reviewers.

Mr cc 2023-08-04

Why is there no reply after withdrawing the submission and sending an email?

wang_dachui 2023-08-04

No, let me correct it. It has been over 6 months, my family members.

wang_dachui 2023-08-04

Update, there has been a major renovation in progress for over 7 months, my family members...

李棉花 2023-08-04

I have been with the editor for a month, with no changes. I don't know if I should write a letter to urge them.

小木木木 2023-08-03

May I ask what the current status is now? It has been a month with my editor.

REck1ess 2023-08-02

It is one of the more recognized journals in the industry.
The submission and review process is quick, and the editors are very careful and dedicated.
In the first round, three reviewers provided major revisions with over thirty questions in total.
There were 20 days given for the revisions, and an additional 20 days were requested via email.
In the second round, two reviewers agreed, but one reviewer rejected the submission due to one specific issue.
The editor provided another major revision, but even after careful explanation and modification, the reviewer still refused to accept it, resulting in the rejection of the submission.
Overall, the journal's editors are responsible and efficient.

浑水摸鱼打老虎 2023-08-02

The second reviewer has been reviewing for 8 weeks and still no news. What's going on, family?

浑水摸鱼打老虎 2023-08-02

The first two reminders have been sent. There is still no response from the second reviewer. It has been two months now with the editor and two months under review.

空臆 2023-08-01

A submission I made in early June has not received any reviews yet. I have sent 15 submissions in total and I estimate that the result will be the same as yours. Another submission made in early July has been rejected today.

该叫个啥呢 2023-08-01

Several reviewers have completed the manuscript review in the second round.

SCI交流 2023-07-31

Mar 04, 2023 - Mar 04, 2023 Submitted to Journal
Mar 04, 2023 - Mar 06, 2023 With Editor
Mar 04, 2023 - Apr 06, 2023 Under Review
During this time, it remained under review, and a reminder was sent once.
Today, I received an email stating that they couldn't find an appropriate reviewer and decided to reject the submission directly.
Very speechless...
Four months of time and nothing.

mei2023 2023-07-31

The previous timeline dates were written incorrectly, here is the corrected version:

March 22, 2023: Submitted
March 30, 2023: Under review by the editor
April 30, 2023: Under review
May 17, 2023: Required reviews completed
May 25, 2023: Decision in process
May 30, 2023: Major revision required
June 14, 2023: Resubmit
June 29, 2023: Under review
July 31, 2023: Required reviews completed
August 2, 2023: Decision in process

mei2023 2023-07-31

July 30, 2023 RRC
After 4 reviewers dropped out, the review process was completed by finding new reviewers. We hope the new reviewers will be lenient in their judgments.

mei2023 2023-07-31

July 30, 2023 RRC
After 4 reviewers dropped out, the review process was restarted and new reviewers were sought. We hope the new reviewers will be lenient in their judgment.

小木木木 2023-07-31

What is the current situation on your end? I have been with the editor for a month now...

Anboyu 2023-07-30

Brother, have you withdrawn the paper? How should I write a withdrawal letter?

chensiya 2023-07-30

The text translates to: "My submission on June 15th is still with the editor."

Anboyu 2023-07-30

Brother, are we urging for submission or withdrawing the manuscript?

Anboyu 2023-07-30

The following text translates to English as: "It's been too long with the editor, what's the editor up to?"

wulixianming 2023-07-29

Brother, are you under review?

wulixianming 2023-07-29

7.12 submit
7.29 with editor
Why is "with editor" taking so long? Does anyone know the reason? If it's not possible, I will withdraw the submission.

GoTo 2023-07-29

1. Now update the review status.
2nd revision became 3 reviewers on 7.22.
2nd revision required reviews complete on 7.27.
Now waiting for the final result.
2. Reply to the comment below.
Submit normally according to the author's guidelines.
To know the status, follow the official WeChat account of Elsevier Publishing.
Indeed, the review period of this journal is relatively long.

潮汐习 2023-07-28

I want to ask if the reference list for the submission needs to have detailed article information deleted as well.

代号table 2023-07-28

May I ask how you know how many reviewers there are and their status? I only see "under review" here.

该叫个啥呢 2023-07-27

The second trial has taken so long...

DTApple 2023-07-25

I have been envious of the person who is still "with editor" since 7.3 until now.