just in time 2022-12-15

How long did the editor wait for review?

yy-yy 2022-12-15

Already submitted for review, the review comments have been received, currently waiting for the editor's message.

just in time 2022-12-15

Did you submit your manuscript for review?

just in time 2022-12-15

Has your current submission been reviewed? What is your research direction?

科研废柴 2022-12-03

Feb 12, 2023 - Submitted to Journal
Feb 13, 2023 - With Editor
Feb 18, 2023 - Under Review
Feb 19, 2023 - Under Review
Feb 24, 2023 - Under Review
Feb 26, 2023 - Under Review
Feb 27, 2023 - Under Review
Mar 07, 2023 - Required Reviews Completed
Mar 07, 2023 - Major Revision
Mar 13, 2023 - Revision submitted
Mar 13, 2023 - With Editor
Mar 15, 2023 - Under Review
Mar 15, 2023 - Completed - Accept
Heung Nam Han, as always, with lightning speed.

MuTong 2022-12-02

May I ask if there is a page fee for the journal? How is the fee charged?

onedefour 2022-11-30

7.14 Submission
7.15 with editor (two months)
9.14 First reminder for submission
9.16 Under review
10.15 Major revision (20 days, one reviewer, minor comments)
10.25 Returned manuscript
10.26 with editor (three weeks)
11.16 Second reminder for submission
11.18 Under review
11.25 Accepted

yy-yy 2022-11-16

Posted on November 2nd, started with editor on November 8th, and still with editor at present. Everyone's status is more or less the same.

yy-yy 2022-11-16

I have also been with editor for 2 weeks.

robot 2022-11-16

Posted on October 30th, started with editor on November 8th, today is November 16th, still with editor, how long will this status continue?

Accepted-lucky 2022-11-14

May I ask who is the editor you encountered?

Accepted-lucky 2022-11-13

The translation of the text is as follows:

"Already submitted, unknown results. Submitted on 10.28. Still with the editor until 11.13. Not sure if it will have the opportunity to be reviewed."

yy-yy 2022-10-18

9.4 submit
9.6 with editor
9.7 Under Review
9.11 Under Review
9.24 Under Review
9.30 Required Reviews Completed
9.30 Minor Revision
10.17 Revision Submission
10.18 Accept

Translation:
9.4 submit
9.6 with editor
9.7 Under Review
9.11 Under Review
9.24 Under Review
9.30 Required Reviews Completed
9.30 Minor Revision
10.17 Revision Submission
10.18 Accept

mynx 2022-10-18

Excuse me, how do I select an editor? I couldn't find it in the submission system.

shyllen 2022-10-17

About one month, after modification, thanks to Song for editing, the processing speed is very fast.

LawLight_L 2022-10-01

2 months with editor, ultimately rejected due to excessive simulated content and insufficient experimental sections.

Legend.S 2022-09-30

There are many aspects to characterize the mechanical properties of metal materials. This time, the review process was average, with a total of two reviewers. The first reviewer accepted the invitation on the second day of submission, while the second reviewer took a long time and ultimately provided minor revision comments. After making the necessary modifications, the paper was accepted.

The editor is Professor Yu Qian, an electron microscopy expert from Zhejiang University. Thank you for the editor's patient support! Wishing the journal continued success!

Timeline:
7.31 Submitted to journal
8.9 Under review
9.21 Minor revision (20 days given)
9.26 Revision submission
9.28 Under review
9.29 Accepted

Aaron666 2022-09-30

Finally, after 27 days, it is Under Review.

Aaron666 2022-09-18

Oh my, this editor is too slow. I had my manuscript rejected and resubmitted, but it took 22 days even with the editor Aude Simar. This editor is incredibly slow!

LawLight_L 2022-08-21

Posted on July 26, 2022
With editor on July 28, 2022
With editor on August 21, 2022
Did I not choose an editor? Is it normal for the processing to be so slow? How can I find out which editor my paper has been assigned to?

AcceptedMaster 2022-08-12

Last year's article was under review for 4 months, and after a major revision, it was accepted. The editor is Professor Aude Simar from the University of Louvain in Belgium. I was hesitant during this submission and didn't choose an editor in the comments, so I was assigned to Professor Aude Simar again (must be a special fate...). One week after submission, it was with the editor for over two weeks. Because I had a pre-defense coming up, I wanted to get the results quickly. Yesterday, I sent an email politely inquiring about the decision and expressing willingness to provide any necessary assistance. Today, it was rejected (sigh): the volume of submissions was too high, and the lack of innovation in the article was overshadowed by the pressure to publish. It was a love affair.

小竹子樱 2022-07-27

Want to know how to choose an editor?

Qian Liu 2022-07-26

I also submitted on July 3rd, and until now, it is still "with editor". I don't know why it's like this this time.

XieJia 2022-07-12

Still with the editor, there has been no change. Did you switch to this journal or submit directly? My senior brother said that if you submit directly, selecting Min Song in the recommended editor section would be faster, but I switched, so I couldn't choose the editor.

斌斌scut 2022-07-11

Hello, may I ask if you are still in the "with editor" status? My "with editor" status has been 35 days already.

骑迹2017 2022-07-10

2021.12.23 submitted
2022.05.17 revision
2022.06.20 revision submitted
2022.07.09 accept

The journal was unable to find reviewers for a long time, and there were several changes in the "under review" status. In the end, there was only one reviewer's opinion, which required major revisions. The editor provided minor revisions.

During this period, there was no pressure to expedite the process, as the speed of review depended on the availability of reviewers. The editor's handling speed was average.

XieJia 2022-07-03

I initially submitted to another journal editor and received a direct rejection for the recommended "Materials Characterization." Then, I directly submitted to "Materials Characterization" and it has been two weeks with the editor. Has anyone else encountered this situation?

Bamboo-wanwan 2022-07-03

I'm sorry, but I am unable to access external websites. If you provide the text from the website, I'll be happy to translate it for you.

Bamboo-wanwan 2022-07-03

This editor is from the Powder Metallurgy Institute of Central South University.

Bamboo-wanwan 2022-07-03

This editor is from the Powder Metallurgy Institute of Central South University.