SCUH 2023-07-27

Is there any latest result?

Hzw_SCIES 2023-06-15

Still need one more reviewer, finding a reviewer is so difficult.

Hzw_SCIES 2023-06-15

I previously submitted to Chomesphere because the Nine-Dash Line required the removal of irrelevant inserted lines related to academia. Then I enlarged the image, and as long as the entire Nine-Dash Line was not displayed, there was no problem. Finally, because I couldn't find a reviewer, I transferred to this journal. However, I could only find one reviewer all along, and I still need one more. It's so frustrating.

wmxz 2023-06-14

The editing department returned the edited manuscript within two days, which was quite fast. However, besides providing academic advice, the reviewer also expressed strong political bias. Since my research area is the South China Sea, I included the nine-dash line in the overview of the study area. The reviewer seized on this point and continuously emphasized that the 2016 South China Sea arbitration ruling implies that our country's claims are not recognized. The deputy editor probably rejected the manuscript based on this reviewer's opinion. Setting aside the political factors, the reviewer's advice was still good, but I decided to decline it directly.

Hzw_SCIES 2023-05-16

Posted on April 27th, under review on May 11th, looking forward to a good result.

caden 2022-12-23

Received, it's okay.

大海啊全是水 2022-11-22

No additional fees without open source.

顽强的打工人 2022-11-13

May I ask if you have contacted you for the next step? I want to know if this journal is not open source, will there be any extra fees for it?

顽强的打工人 2022-11-12

Submission 2022.07.02
First review minor revisions 2022.09.28
First review submission 2022.10.24
Second review minor revisions 2022.11.10
Second review submission 2022.11.11
Accepted 2022.11.12
The journal is very good. There shouldn't be any major issues as long as you make the revisions according to the reviewers' comments. This is my first SCI paper. I will continue to work hard in the future.

大海啊全是水 2022-11-04

Posted on August 21st, reviewed with editor on the 23rd, under review on the 24th. Received first-round comments on September 21st, revised on October 16th, received second-round comments on October 30th, revised on November 1st, and accepted on November 4th. The journal's quality feels good, and the reviewers are very responsible. Both reviewers' comments amounted to a total of 8 pages, and the revision explanation exceeded 40 pages, but it greatly improved the quality of the manuscript. The current impact factor is 2.16, and it is predicted to reach 4.67 by 2023. I hope it will continue to improve.

caden 2022-10-24

It has been reviewed for two months.

龙咩咩 2022-10-13

Brother, how are you doing? I submitted my application in July and it is still under review until now.

大海啊全是水 2022-09-22

Finding reviewers is a good thing, just wait, but I'm afraid it's always inviting reviewers and still not finding the right kind.

caden 2022-09-22

The main issue is that there is a reviewer who constantly does not understand the comments.

大海啊全是水 2022-09-21

The average review cycle for website updates is 6.2 weeks. Just wait a bit longer, mine was submitted exactly one month ago and the status has changed to Required Reviews Completed.

大海啊全是水 2022-09-21

Exactly one month, the status has become "Required Reviews Completed", indeed quite fast, I hope for good luck in the future.

caden 2022-09-20

Didn't they say it would be fast? It has been over a month of review...

大海啊全是水 2022-08-30

Posted on August 21st, with the editor on the 23rd, under review on the 24th. Waiting for further results to see if it is really as fast as rumored.

Nora 2022-02-06

Hello, may I ask how long does it take for your first draft review?

碧海蓝天WGP 2021-12-20

The latest upgraded version of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS) classification for 2021 has been downgraded to Zone 2, no longer in the top category.

tianyeouc 2021-04-05

Rejected after ten days of submission, reason: more suitable for an atmospheric genre.