清泉石上流 2023-07-26

2022.3.25 submit
2022.7.24 The comments are back, it's time for a major revision.
2022.11.24 Took 4 months before I returned for revision, there was a pandemic in the middle.
2023.3.28 The second round of comments is back, 1 major revision and 1 minor revision, and 1 direct rejection (thanks to the editor for suggesting not to directly reject it).
2023.4.19 Returned for revision. Doctoral interview in the middle.
2023.7.26 Accepted by the reviewers.
Submitted to a special issue, it took a long time, and there was a shortage of reviewers in both rounds of review, so it took a long time. But I also have my own reasons, the first round of revision took too long. If I can wait, then I will wait. I have been working on it from my second year of graduate school until graduation. Keep going!

CCCM 2023-07-12

Hello, I would like to ask how long the status "Under Review" has lasted? Does the capitalization of U and R in the journal's name have any relation to the manuscript's status? Thank you.

发个论文吧 2023-07-04

So slow, seven months have passed and there is no news at all...

Wangxinyi 2023-06-26

Excuse me, when will the proofreading be done after receiving the LDD?

Zinnia 2023-06-06

From submission to acceptance, it took over two months. It was accepted in early December 2022.

锦鲤柴 2023-06-05

Why did it become "under review" the second day after I submitted it? Is there no "with editor" stage?

发个论文吧 2023-06-02

How do I track the status of this journal? I haven't received any updates, and the system is not updating either.

lmc 2023-06-01

I also want to know why the first trial is so slow. Some cases seem to be quite fast. I also submitted a special issue, and it has been six months since the first trial. I don't know if I should remind them or not, as I feel it may not have much effect.

lmc 2023-06-01

Also focusing on companionship, the first trial has been going on for exactly 6 months.

锦鲤柴 2023-06-01

I would like to ask why my submission turned into "under review" the day after I submitted it. Is there no "with editor" stage?

吉利123 2023-05-29

Since I submitted the reply to the first-instance opinions on March 8th, it is still under review until now.

尼多力诺 2023-05-22

submit: 2022/4/5
Under review: 2022/5/1
Under Review: 2022/6/3
Under review: 2022/12/20
major revision: 2023/1/6
Under Review: 2023/2/22~now
The main focus is companionship!

Simonaa 2023-03-22

Submitted: 2022/9/13
With editor: 2022/9/16
Under review: 2022/9/26
Major Revision: 2023/1/30
Submitted: 2023/2/16
Accepted: 2023/3/21

lihuadan 2023-02-27

The review process is too slow. It has been three and a half months since the first review, and there is still no result. The editor replied that they are still waiting for the reviewer's feedback. I want to ask, is there no set deadline for the reviewer? I am afraid that after waiting for half a year for the first review, it will still be rejected in the end.

小蓝@妖艳 2023-02-16

Post cycle: 6 months.

小蓝@妖艳 2023-02-16

Accepted: 13 January 2023
Revision 6 - 10 January 2023
Revision 5 - 26 December 2022
Revision 4 - 22 December 2022
Revision 3 - 15 December 2022
Revision 2 - 3 December 2022
Revision 1 - 13 October 2022
Initial Submission
Submitted on 18 July 2022
The whole process went through a major revision from the reviewers, followed by a minor revision. There were 4 more minor revisions later: one was because I mistakenly uploaded the wrong attachment, and the remaining three were regarding three small statistical issues pointed out by the editor (I have to admit the editor's expertise in this area is strong).
After going through various hardships, I always believed that hard work would pay off. However, the acceptance came in January 2023, by which time the journal's ranking had dropped to the second tier (not even a Top journal). I cried for two days. It's hard to accept!
Although I admire the editor's expertise, I can't help but wonder why the statistical issues had to be raised three times, which really wasted a lot of time.
I thought my first paper would be in a Top journal, but it ended up being downgraded to the second tier.

椭圆三向箔 2023-02-16

Now, controlling the quality and quantity of manuscripts, there is still a chance to elevate it back up.

小蓝@妖艳 2023-02-16

Same experience, submitted in July 2022, accepted in January 2023. Discovered the rejection zone and cried for two days.

ethanxyf 2023-02-16

I have been searching for more than 20 days, only got "ee" assigned, and couldn't find "re". Is there still a chance?

吉利123 2023-02-09

This is not known to be a reduced area until December. My first-instance opinion has come back and found that it has been reduced.

天津大麻花 2023-01-09

Slow, too slow! It has been over 20 days since the submission, and the editor has not been assigned yet.

哈撒开 2022-12-25

26 Sep 2021
Submitted
29 Sep 2021
Submission Checks Completed
29 Sep 2021
Assigned to Editor
09 Nov 2021
Reviewer(s) Assigned
10 Dec 2021
Review(s) Completed, Editorial Evaluation Pending
28 Dec 2021
Editorial Decision: Revise Major
26 Jan 2022
1st Revision Received
28 Jan 2022
Submission Checks Completed
28 Jan 2022
Assigned to Editor
19 Oct 2022
Reviewer(s) Assigned
13 Nov 2022
Review(s) Completed
23 Dec 2022
Accept
It took 15 months. Luckily, there was no rush to use this article, otherwise it would have been really hard to wait.

tang11100 2022-11-24

You're too fast with this. It's been 2 months and still no news...

yang22@ 2022-11-15

Hello, I would like to ask how long after the first draft is modified should it be submitted. Thank you. The email reply did not include a "thank you."

yang22@ 2022-11-15

Hello, may I ask how long after making revisions to the first draft should I submit it? Thank you. There is no trouble in the reply email.

yang22@ 2022-11-15

Hello, may I ask how long after the revision of the first draft should it be submitted? Thank you. The email reply does not mention it. Sorry for the trouble.

yang22@ 2022-11-15

Hello, I would like to ask how long after the first draft is modified should it be submitted? Thank you. There was no reply in the email.

yang22@ 2022-11-15

Hello, may I ask how long after the first draft is modified before it is submitted? Thank you. There is no reply email.

yang22@ 2022-11-15

Hello, may I ask how long it takes to submit the revised manuscript after the first round of modifications? Thank you. Not written, huh.

yang22@ 2022-11-15

Hello, may I ask how long after the first draft has been revised should it be submitted? Thank you.