哈哈哈哈哈 2023-03-24

Do you have a copyright statement for you to upload? I have been waiting since I submitted the minor edits.

yolo 2023-02-27

I have been awaiting reviewer selection for twenty days now. I'm wondering what comes next for me. I see that many people don't have this option.

Hokir 2023-02-24

2023-02-24 Provisionally Accepted
Throwing flowers~! Finally, it's over!

Hokir 2023-02-23

2023-02-22 en attente de recommandation

Hokir 2023-02-09

2023-02-03 Major Revisions
2023-02-09 Revision submitted

Chemelec 2023-01-24

Here is the English translation of the text:

"Here is some additional information about the submission process for everyone's reference:

2022-12-06: Submitted
2022-12-31: Major revision
2023-01-11: Revision submitted
2023-01-23: Accepted"

Hokir 2023-01-16

20230116 Awaiting Recommendation

This text is already in English and does not need to be translated.

zouzhixiang 2022-12-22

I just received an article that used to be in Zone 2 in the past few years. It is highly recognized within the industry, with over 120 articles published each year. This year, it has been downgraded to Zone 3. I don't know what to do about job searching next year. Sigh... I don't understand this new zoning.

Chemelec 2022-12-21

The flagship journal of the American Electrochemical Society, which is considered one of the few outstanding purely electrochemical journals. Many classic papers have been published in it, both in terms of knowledge dissemination and the rigor of the article's argumentation process, making it an authority in the field of electrochemistry! Unfortunately, its reputation and influence cannot surpass what the Chinese Academy of Sciences calls the "impact factor." Not long ago, I submitted a valuable part of my work to JES, not for the sake of its ranking, but today, after seeing the latest ranking, I couldn't hold back anymore. Not maintaining the original ranking would have been understandable, but I was forcibly placed in the fourth tier. On the contrary, some domestically produced journals that have just obtained an impact factor have entered the first and second tiers. Both in terms of emotions and logic, I feel that the Chinese Academy of Sciences has gone too far! It is a good journal, but unfortunately, it still has to bow down to the influence factor. This may be the last time I submit to JES, sigh.

Hokir 2022-12-15

Share the progress:
16-Nov-2022 SUBMITTED
17-Nov-2022 Awaiting AE Assignment
17-Nov-2022 Awaiting TE Decision
26-Nov-2022 Awaiting Reviewer Assignment
30-Nov-2022 Awaiting Reviewer Scores

Kreveng 2022-10-28

It can indeed be considered as a flagship journal in the field of electrochemistry. I have submitted an article to this journal before and received very professional review comments. The reviewers provided me with a lot of knowledge on the underlying mechanisms and formulas. I haven't submitted to this journal recently due to its classification reasons (forgive me for being somewhat superficial, but I can't help it with the way the Chinese Academy of Sciences operates). I still psychologically recognize the significance of this journal and hope that it will regain its classification in the future. I want to mention that even EC has been classified as a third-tier journal now. I really can't understand the principles behind the Chinese Academy of Sciences' classification and its reasoning. Reputation and influence cannot simply be quantified based on Impact Factor alone...

Kay Chen 2022-10-28

Where can I download the review comments? I have been searching for a long time on the author's page but cannot find where they are located. The review process has already ended. Does it mean that only the first author has the corresponding option?

Kay Chen 2022-10-28

Where can I download the review comments? I have been searching on the author page for a long time but I can't find where they are. It already shows that the review process has ended.

琦锅锅 2022-09-20

Very much agree with the viewpoint above, the current zoning of the Chinese Academy of Sciences is indeed unfair. JES is the flagship journal of the American Electrochemical Society. From 1902 until now (how many journals have such a long history?), JES has consistently been one of the most cited journals in the field of electrochemistry and solid-state science and technology.

琦锅锅 2022-09-20

Top is unlikely, but this prestigious journal has indeed had a glorious past and is still highly recognized within the industry.

琦锅锅 2022-09-20

Yes, it is the flagship journal of the American Electrochemical Society, a very prestigious and well-established journal that is highly regarded by industry professors. However, it is not ranked very high in terms of impact factor.

zhenglong55 2022-09-12

Original text: 楼主，请问这个结果最后咋样了？

Translation: OP, may I ask what happened in the end with this result?

zhenglong55 2022-09-12

May I ask what happened to your situation in the end?

崎岖 2022-09-07

Feels very fast, two reviewers, nine opinions.

speedlimite 2022-08-31

February 19th, 2022: submission
March 11th: Major revision
April 3rd, 2022: resubmission
April 14th, 2022: Major revision
May 16th, 2022: Minor revision
May 19th, 2022: Accepted

Z邹小田 2022-08-25

01.20 accept translated into English is "January 20th, accept."

科研小鼠 2022-07-29

Under normal circumstances, it takes within 2 weeks to receive online submissions.

教练，我不想输了 2022-07-29

Hello, I would like to inquire how long it takes for submissions to be accepted and published online in your publication. Thank you.

长路未远 2022-07-11

Free, non-OA.

YKT 2022-07-07

I also submitted on June 10th, and now I am still awaiting TE decision/ Awaiting reviewer assignment. This is too slow. I thought the journal was fast, so if it doesn't meet expectations in another month, I will withdraw the submission.

swimvc 2022-07-03

The slowness of this journal is incredibly frustrating. It took nearly 5 months for them to give me their first feedback on my submission, making it the slowest and by far the worst experience I've ever had.

kkkks 2022-06-28

Ah, we have already fallen to this extent. The impact factor cannot increase, and the ranking has directly dropped to Zone 3. We have also lost our top position.

古月命之 2022-06-22

2022.4.10 Submission
2022.4.14 Sent to the editor for review
2022.5.16 Major revision
2022.5.25 Revised manuscript
2022.5.26 Submit copyright form
2022.6.20 Pre-acceptance
2022.6.21 Formal acceptance

Toki1 2022-06-08

Has anyone ever experienced the situation where "Awaiting Reviewer Scores" changed to "Awaiting recommendation" and then changed back to "Awaiting Reviewer Scores"? What is going on with this?

zht0831 2022-06-03

May I ask how your result is? I am currently in the same state for the second review as well.