jiaovv 2023-01-30

Is there a difference between "Under Review" and "under review"? Which one indicates "under review"?

jiaovv 2023-01-30

Is "Under Review" different from "under review"? Does "Under Review" mean it is still under editing? Which one indicates it has been sent for external review?

jiaovv 2023-01-30

Is "Under Review" different from "under review"? Which one indicates that it has been sent for external review? Does "Under Review" mean it is still being edited?

狗儿狗 2023-01-25

2022-10-30 sub. - Submitted on October 30, 2022.
2022-12-1 M.R. - Meeting/Review on December 1, 2022.
2023-01-09 resub. - Resubmitted on January 9, 2023.
2023-01-20 M.R. - Meeting/Review on January 20, 2023.
2023-01-25 Acce. - Accepted on January 25, 2023.

niu 2023-01-20

This is my submission time, hoping it will be helpful for everyone.
Submitted on October 7, 2022. If there is no news within a week, it means it has been sent for review. It is recommended to check the system after 7 days of submission. It will change from "associate editor assigned" to "in peer review".
The average review time for the editor to send it to reviewers is three weeks, and the decision will be given in the fourth week. So, the first review without arbitration takes about a month. After receiving the comments from the first round of review, there were major and minor revisions, and the editor gave a major revision.
On December 17, 2022, additional experimental data was provided and the review comments were returned.
It may be because I took too long for the major revision. Generally, the editor would send the review comments back to the original reviewers. However, there was only one week between Christmas on December 25 and January 7, when the reviewers were on holiday, so the second review took a bit longer. The comments from the second round of review only had suggestions to change the wording in the title. The editor gave a minor revision.
Accepted on January 17, 2023.
Signed the copyright transfer agreement on January 18, 2023.

花柳朵 2023-01-06

Watering is becoming increasingly serious, many of which are not necessary to study, and it is getting worse and worse.

蓝天白云5167 2022-12-14

Under Review means it is being sent for external review, while Under review means it is at the editing stage.

蓝天白云5167 2022-12-14

2022.10.02 First submission
2022.10.10 Editing request to shorten the length, move relevant content to SI, deadline is one month
2022.10.21 Return to authors
2022.10.22 Under review
2022.11.01 Review process completed, two reviewers, major revision and minor revision, editor assigns major revision, deadline is one and a half months
2022.11.21 Return to authors
2022.12.08 Accepted
The experience is to respect the opinions of the reviewers and editors, try to follow the suggestions of the reviewers, and if unable to make the changes, explain thoroughly. Explain the various methods attempted but unable to solve the issue, as well as the specific reasons for the problem. It is best to include references. In short, it is an attitude problem.

nbmt580 2022-12-13

Yes, there were no review comments, just mentioned to modify a few labels.

xihawuchang 2022-12-02

Wow, it only took half a month to complete the acceptance!

xiaox 2022-11-25

I would like to ask you, after submitting, will it show "in peer review"? It has been 10 days since submission, and the status in ACS Publishing Center has been "Associate Editor Assigned" all along.

xiaox 2022-11-25

I would like to ask you, it has been 10 days since submission, and the status in ACS Publishing Center has been "Associate Editor Assigned". Could you please clarify if this status means it has been sent for review? Or will it be displayed as "in peer review" after the review process?

xihawuchang 2022-11-22

2022 08 11 Post
2022 09 10 It is also the day when the Youth Fund is announced, double happiness.
2022 10 17 Return after repair.
2022 11 22 Acceptance.

Overall, it went quite smoothly!

moumou south 2022-11-22

Analytical chemistry is so difficult.

苜淖 2022-11-14

September 19th Submission
September 23rd Editing requires formatting changes and shortening of content, with relevant experimental parts moved to the Supplementary Information (SI).
September 26th Re-submission
October 17th Minor revision and direct acceptance
October 20th Revised submission
October 25th Article accepted

糖水水水水 2022-11-12

The two recent submissions I made encountered very unreasonable reviewers. They directly rejected the manuscripts and their language was particularly offensive. They did not provide any professional opinions, which was very disheartening.

xinguobiexinhua 2022-10-19

June 17th - Submission
June 20th - Editing request to reduce length
June 22nd - Return
August 12th - Minor revision, major revision, rejection
September 25th - Response
October 10th - Received format changes
October 12th - Response again
October 17th - Accepted

苜淖 2022-09-24

Did your article get accepted without being reviewed?

ethanolalcohol 2022-09-19

Recording my ups and downs in the first submission process, I am grateful for the submission experiences shared by the experts before, supporting me through this long 5-month journey.
April 22nd: Submitted the article
April 25th: Assigned to Editor
April 25th - June 14th: Under review throughout (contrary to what some people said)
June 15th: Minor revision, major revision, rejection with almost all lowest scores. Editor requested resubmission by August 1st. Also sent Supplementary Journal Cover Invitation.
Around June 21st: Declined Supplementary Journal Cover Invitation (needed to conduct experiments and didn't have time)
July 26th: Sent an email to the editor requesting a deadline extension to August 15th due to additional experiments. Editor probably didn't see it, and on August 2nd, I logged in to find that the submission system had closed due to exceeding the response time (almost cried). Immediately sent another email to the editor, this time with read receipt. Editor replied that the deadline could be extended. The submission system reopened. (Lesson learned: should have set read receipt for the first email)
August 14th: Resubmitted the article
August 15th: Assigned to Editor
September 17th: Accepted (✿✿ヽ(°▽°)ノ✿)

Stern 2022-09-13

It's really fast.
Submitted on 7.15.
Major revision on 8.12.
Revision submitted on 8.23.
Accepted on 9.9.

拜托拜托顺利顺利 2022-09-07

6.14 Submission
7.29 Received minor revision comments
8.8 Sent revised manuscript
9.1 Formatting changes made
9.2 Sent revised manuscript again
9.5 Accepted

一枚不正经的女博士 2022-09-06

The review speed is quite fast, generally about one month or so. The impact factor has finally surpassed 8 this year. I wonder if it has the potential to break 10.

USTCETH 2022-09-05

The text means: Your manuscript has been assigned to an Associate Editor (Dr. Jonathan Sweedler) for further evaluation. May I ask the senior experts for further assessment, does the editorial department have any objections to the article?

Echo 2022-09-03

20220902 manuscript accepted translates to "Manuscript accepted on September 2, 2022."

USTCETH 2022-08-28

Hello, may I ask if we can choose to edit when submitting a manuscript to AC?

Echo 2022-08-25

20220817 minor revision → Minor revision on August 17, 2022
20220825 revised manuscript submission → Revised manuscript submission on August 25, 2022

Echo 2022-08-10

The translation of the text into English is: "There won't be any notification for submission, as long as you haven't received a rejection message, it means it has been submitted for review."

LL505 2022-08-07

How long after being assigned as an associate editor will it be sent for review?

LL505 2022-08-07

8.1 submit - To hand over or present something for consideration or judgment.
8.3 Associate Editor Assigned - An associate editor has been designated or appointed.

定西 2022-08-02

Hello, may I ask how many reviewers are there?