Miao Chio 2023-08-01

Jun, 8th, 2023 - Submitted to the journal
Jun, 12th, 2023 - Under editor's review
Jun, 16th, 2023 - Under review
Jun, 30th, 2023 - Major revision required
Jul, 19th, 2023 - Revised manuscript submitted to the journal
Jul, 16th, 2023 - Under editor's review
Jul, 17th, 2023 - Under review
Aug, 3rd, 2023 - Accepted

LGM-111 2023-07-24

How many days have you been in the editor over there?

LGM-111 2023-07-24

with editor 6 days

LGM-111 2023-07-24

"In with editor"

123SHHBHJBC 2023-05-30

Why are you still editing? It has been five days since you started editing.

叶小乐 2023-04-25

From what they say, the difficulty is average, I'm not sure myself. Anyway, when I look back at all the papers I submitted, I feel like they don't match up.

科研小童 2023-04-19

What is the difficulty level of the submission?

叶小乐 2023-04-07

You will know whether there is a comprehensive summary or not by checking on their official website.

Justin123 2023-04-02

May I ask the experts here, is this journal good for submitting a comprehensive review? Has anyone in the group submitted to it before?

叶小乐 2023-03-07

The translation of "3.7 accept" into English is "3.7 accepted".

叶小乐 2023-03-05

2.8 rrc: Not applicable

2.12 Major revision edited by Professor Wanqin Jin
2.23 resubmit to journal
2.26 under review
3.5 minor revise The reviewer feels that the reference format is not quite correct. Okay, let's make the changes.
3.5 resubmit

suncare014 2023-02-05

I am a novice in the field of inorganic membranes, and the responsible editor is Jerry Lin.

叶小乐 2023-02-04

Wow, you're so amazing. May I ask what field you're in? Who is the editor?

suncare014 2023-02-03

2023-01-19 Submitted to journal
2023-01-21 With editor/under review
2023-01-25 RRC/Revise
2023-01-30 Resubmitted to journal
2023-02-01 With editor/under review
2023-02-02 RRC/Accept

Translated:

2023-01-19 Submitted to journal
2023-01-21 Under review by editor
2023-01-25 Requires revisions and resubmission (RRC)
2023-01-30 Resubmitted to journal
2023-02-01 Under review by editor
2023-02-02 RRC/Accepted

叶小乐 2023-01-29

1.29 Reviewer 2 agrees to review.

叶小乐 2023-01-29

1.24 submit
1.28 under review
1.29 Reviewer 1 agrees to review
Everyone has a low opinion of this journal. Is it really that slow? I would like to ask which top journals are available for filtering or if there are any rankings for journals in the same field.

Liang89 2023-01-13

2022.12.29 resubmit to the journal
2023.01.03 accepted

Xu's editorial efficiency is very high, and the valuable comments from the two reviewers are very helpful for future research. I wish the journal continued success!

lydx 2022-12-29

Three reviewers provided comments from three different perspectives.

Liang89 2022-12-24

2022.11.29 - Submitted to journal
2022.12.3 - Under review
2022.12.16 - Required reviews complete
2022.12.21 - Major revision

Liang89 2022-12-17

2022.11.29 - Submitted to journal
2022.12.3 - Under review
2022.12.16 - Required reviews complete

承欢晦慕 2022-12-15

A pretty good journal, submitted but did not get accepted.

拼嘻嘻 2022-12-01

I usually place the highlighted version directly after the response to the reviewer. The main text of the manuscript is the modified version without highlights.

WilliamZZ 2022-11-11

19 July with editor - This means that on July 19th, the submission was received and is currently being reviewed by the editor.
24 July under review - On July 24th, the submission was still being reviewed.
5 Aug required reviews completed - On August 5th, the required reviews for the submission were finished.
19 December major revision - On December 19th, a significant revision was made to the submission.
2 November resubmitted the journal - On November 2nd, the submission was resubmitted to the journal.
11 November accept - On November 11th, the submission was accepted.

Haki 2022-11-07

I am also a reviewer and have been accepting reviews for two months.

WilliamZZ 2022-11-01

Encountered a problem: in the membrane science repair system, only an unmarked version needs to be submitted, but the editor requires highlighting in the revised version. How should this situation be handled? Brothers who have already experienced this, please help clarify. Thank you.

WilliamZZ 2022-10-29

可能跟逢催必拒有关系 translates to "It is possible that it is related to the idea of meeting and being rejected."

Haki 2022-10-26

It seems like everyone has been reviewing manuscripts, and I have also been reviewing manuscripts for nearly two months.

歪歪 2022-10-26

It's better to reject it. The recent two experiences of investing in film science have been very poor, and I will not invest again in the future.

Haki 2022-10-26

I am completely speechless. Why didn't you reject it when it was just submitted, wasting four months of time?

123SHHBHJBC 2022-10-26

The reasons mentioned are really unfair for the original poster.