Verified Reviews - JOURNAL OF MATERIALS RESEARCH
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

疯猪cp 2023-05-18

2.10 Submission
2.19 Editor assigned
3.17 Under review
3.31 Review comments: Major revisions
4.29 Revisions requested
5.4 Under review
5.15 Returned to the editor
5.17 Accepted
Overall, the process is slow, but the reviewers' comments are insightful and require thorough responses. Pay attention to the journal's submission format.

Lan Shou 2023-05-10

What happened next?

pan piao 2023-04-19

11 Feb 2023 New Submission
13 Feb 2023 Editor Assigned
15 Feb 2023 Editor Assigned
25 Feb 2023 Editor Assigned
07 Mar 2023 Reviewers Assigned
23 Mar 2023 Reviewers Assigned
I can only say be cautious when submitting, it's really slow, really slow! The article in the fourth round is not very meaningful, and I withdrew it since there was no news. Do any seniors know if there is a status called "Under Reviewers"? I'm scared.

pan piao 2023-04-19

My assigned reviewers have been taking more than a month already, and I don't know what this journal is doing. Can they just reject it in one sentence? It's too dragging.

李毛毛 2023-03-20

It has been three months, still "Reviewers Assigned".

Haoshan丶 2022-12-14

So slow, submitted on 11/16, and still "Editor Assigned" on 12/14.

yesterdayyyy 2022-10-14

Just follow the requirements in the submission guidelines to make the changes.

yesterdayyyy 2022-10-10

What is the issue with your format? This journal does not allow you to write your own keywords; you can only select from its own keyword database that matches your article. Also, when filling in the article title and keywords, pay attention to punctuation. When filling out the webpage, make sure to switch to English input method.

骑着蜗牛混一混 2022-10-08

How can I change this format? I also had to revise the format after it was returned to me.

勇敢的心啊 2022-10-06

Do I need to send an email to ask about this situation? Or should I continue waiting?

勇敢的心啊 2022-10-06

8.25 Major revision
9.17 Revised
9.19 Slight change, still Editor Assigned
It has been over two weeks now. Is this situation normal? It seems like the editor has not been found...

yesterdayyyy 2022-09-12

Why is it taking so long? Have you sent an email to inquire about it?

sdjsdj 2022-09-11

4.13 submission, currently still under review.

yesterdayyyy 2022-09-08

6.14 successfully uploaded (previously submitted twice, did not understand the keyword format, returned for format modification)
6.22 arrived in the hands of the editor
7.02 sent for review
7.23 returned to the hands of the editor
7.25 received comments from reviewers, major revision
8.10 revised and resubmitted
8.23 received comments from reviewers, minor revision
8.26 revised
9.06 accepted

期盼毕业 2022-07-05

I'm the same. I have been in the position of an assigned reviewer for a month now and I have no idea what this journal is doing. It's so slow. I hope they don't reject it in the end and delay my graduation.

sdjsdj 2022-06-14

My reviewer assignment also changed twice, but it has never been under review. How about yours?

yezhizhen126 2022-06-07

After assigning reviewers, it is under review. However, there was also a period of time in between.

sdjsdj 2022-06-02

Is "under review" after "reviewers assigned"?

sdjsdj 2022-05-01

4.13 Submission
4.15 Editor assigned
4.20 Editor assigned

yezhizhen126 2022-04-28

3.21 Submitted
3.28 Editor assigned
5.2 Editor assigned
5.3 Reviewers assigned
6.1 First review rejection: One reviewer rejected, the other two agreed, and the editor rejected it.

Long waiter 2022-04-22

The reviewer assigned changed their availability twice, what kind of journal is this?

Long waiter 2022-04-15

4.11 Editor Assigned
4.14 Editor Assigned
Does anyone know what this situation is? Couldn't find a suitable deputy editor?

Long waiter 2022-04-13

08 Apr 2022 new submitted - This means that something new was submitted on April 8th, 2022.

11 Apr 2022 Editor Assigned - This means that an editor was assigned to a task or project on April 11th, 2022.

蛆蛆 2022-01-12

Is this journal charging a page fee?

nj72426 2022-01-09

Hello, may I ask if JMR does not have a Word template?

Zh1993 2021-12-30

22 Dec 2021 New Submission
29 Dec 2021 Editor Assigned

一只阿四儿 2021-08-13

Translation:

21.03.18: Submission
21.04.17: Revision
21.05.14: Accepted
21.06.03: Online
The speed is still good.

hjc987251 2021-08-12

5.10投稿 translates to "Submission on October 5th."
8.2接收 translates to "Received on August 2nd."

Dance of Mat. 2021-08-10

Submit in mid-May, provide major revisions around June 20th, and after detailed modifications, accept the offer by the end of July.

学术小黄牛 2021-07-12

OP, what stage is your thesis at now? I'm anxious to graduate and unsure whether I should submit it or not, based on everyone's comments.

Find Funding. Review Successful Grants.

Explore over 25,000 new funding opportunities and over 6,000,000 successful grants.

Explore

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started