yibuxiao 2023-07-28

2023/7/24 提交 (Submit on 2023/7/24)
2023/7/24 与编辑 (With editor on 2023/7/24)

m22 2023-07-04

This journal's external review process only requires one feedback to become "required reviews completed", then pay attention to the time changes to know if there is any feedback returned. Once all feedback is received, it will become "decision in process". The editor is quite efficient and fast.

KneeYu 2023-06-29

The rejection speed is fast and does not meet the journal's direction.

KneeYu 2023-06-23

Jun 23, 2023 Submitted to Journal

DJJDKK 2023-06-12

Look forward to the result coming out.

愤怒的蛋炒饭 2023-06-12

The third review has only four minor issues, and it has been half a month already but it is still under review. I wonder how much longer I have to wait.

BoLing 2023-05-09

Submitted at the end of November 2022
Received in early May 2023
Underwent a major revision and a minor revision during the process
The handling speed of the manuscript was fast, and the editor was very friendly. It could have been accepted even faster.
The first review came back within a month, with three reviewers who provided positive feedback.
The review process after resubmission took longer, around three months, because one of the reviewers did not respond. After sending reminders, the editor proceeded without waiting and requested a minor revision.
One reviewer agreed to accept the paper, while another provided two minor suggestions.
After the second resubmission, the paper was accepted in less than two weeks.
I don't know if this is survivorship bias, but this was my first submission and the process was very smooth and friendly.
I will submit my next paper to this journal as well.

科大小冯 2023-03-23

Hello, I would like to ask about the status of your previous submission to the Flexible Services and Manufacturing Journal. How long has the editor been waiting pending? Since I am unable to send a private message, I can only inquire here. Thank you for your understanding.

swjtu_lxr 2023-03-15

Who should I contact for a reminder about the manuscript?

Davarishi 2023-03-14

At the beginning, one of the two reviewers did not provide feedback. So, in July, we sought two new reviewers again, which is why the process took a long time.

大工张露 2023-03-14

The cycle is so long, I remember seeing other people coming in about three months.

Davarishi 2023-03-13

The speed of handling manuscripts in the journal is very fast, mainly depending on the reviewing speed of the reviewers.

Submitted in January 2022.
During the process, two reviewers agreed to review, but by July, only one opinion was returned. After urging, two more reviewers were added, making a total of three reviewers. In August, a notice for major revision was received.

Revision submitted in September 2022.
Second revision in November 2022.
Revision submitted in November 2022.
Third revision in December 2022.
Revision submitted in December 2022.
Accepted on March 11, 2023.

KKKKKZ 2023-02-27

Definitely need to write a response.

nihao001 2023-02-19

Good brother, how long has it been since you were not "with editor" in your current state?

wbt 2023-02-12

May I ask what is the full name of the conference you have applied for?

qiangbiyao 2023-01-20

Thank you! Now I know that the "revise and resubmit" of this journal is equivalent to the "revise" of other journals, and a response is required!

KKKKKZ 2022-12-26

I have been waiting for a long time for my submission with the editor this time. Usually, in this kind of situation, it may have already been sent for review, but the status hasn't changed.

AIPHM 2022-12-25

Why am I still "with editor" after one and a half months of submission?

流浪的风 2022-12-18

Submission in September, received revision notice in October. This journal does not offer online revisions. Generally, after receiving revision suggestions, they ask for resubmission. There are two reviewers, the first one had positive comments, while the second reviewer found issues with the innovation. After making the necessary modifications, the paper was submitted again. Acceptance was received after 1.5 months. Overall, the process was relatively fast.

helloscience123 2022-11-02

May I ask how long did the last review process last?

yibuxiao 2022-10-24

It's just a matter of a few days. Please wait a little bit longer.

德仔 2022-10-19

Hello, may I ask how long it takes for the status of the editing to change to "decision in process"? I'm a bit anxious.

yibuxiao 2022-10-13

First time submitting to this journal, writing about manufacturing systems, it aligns well with the journal's requirements. Approximately 5 months after submission, it was accepted, and I am grateful.

The first review raised many questions, and I wrote a response spanning several pages. There were only a few issues during the second review, and after revisions, it was sent to another reviewer for evaluation. It was only on the third review that it was accepted.

I'm not sure why, but this journal has a very high impact factor.

Received at Editorial Office 19 May 2022
First revised
Second Article revised 5 Sep 2022
Article accepted for publication 8 Oct 2022

时光昵称已注册 2022-05-06

Overall, it went smoothly. There were four reviewers for the first round of review, with one negative comment, one direct acceptance, and two positive comments, which were all very good suggestions and easy to modify. The revised version was sent back in about twenty days. One month later, it was directly accepted.

Submitted to the journal on January 22, 2022.
Required reviews were completed on March 09, 2022.
Revised on March 11, 2022.

With the editor on April 01, 2022.
Accepted on May 02, 2022.

su309 2022-04-23

Do journals charge page fees?

su309 2022-04-23

Is your paper open access?

科研届的一只小白 2022-01-03

Overall, after undergoing a major revision and a minor revision, the whole process took nearly 4 months. The feedback for the major revision in the first review came back in just one month, with two reviewers suggesting major revisions. The feedback for the second review also came back in about a month.

Submitted to Journal Aug 19, 2021
Required Reviews Completed Sep 23, 2021
Revise Oct 03, 2021 Major

With editor Nov 16, 2021
Decision in Process Dec 17, 2021 Minor

With editor Dec 29, 2021
Accept Jan 02, 2022

fanyasy 2021-09-15

The text "9.13accept" does not have a clear meaning or context. It does not require translation as it appears to be a combination of numbers and letters without a specific language or message.

修炼的韭菜 2021-07-06

Submitted on May 24th, within a month, I received the review comments. There were three reviewers who generally approved of the work but provided many revision suggestions. After two rounds of revisions, it was accepted on July 5th. The process was very fast!

fanyasy 2021-06-05

4.23submit: April 23rd, submit
4.26under review: April 26th, under review
6.1required reviews completed: June 1st, required reviews completed