中中中 2023-08-04

The date above was written wrong. The submission was supposed to be on July 22nd, 2023, but now it's showing that it's under review on August 4th. It's another round of waiting.

中中中 2023-07-31

Posted on June 22, 2023, and has been in the "With Editor" status...

衣悲 2023-07-04

Received on July 4th.

aaas，truth 2023-06-21

Just submitted, still with the editor. Seeing this message is so scary...

Q 2023-06-20

It's so frustrating!!!! Applied at the end of November last year, and got rejected directly on June 15th this year. The third reviewer rejected it immediately. I don't want to say much more. I suggest the reviewers improve their speed and, if possible, their professionalism. It's not fair to reject someone after they have already graduated.

网志 2023-06-19

The communication email was rejected by the editor at 13:57, just three minutes after it was received at 13:54. At that time, the country was once again in chaos.

衣悲 2023-06-13

Posted on May 22nd, sent for external review on May 23rd, received revision comments on June 12th, this speed is way faster than ME.

我不是研究生 2023-06-09

3.03 Successful submission; 3.13 Editor processing (handled by the chief editor); 3.15 Editor processing (handled by the subject editor); 3.24 External review; 5.12 Revision comments; 5.24 Revisions requested; 5.28 External review; 6.08 Accepted. The review process for this review article took 3 months with 2 reviewers. Chul-Jin Lee's processing speed as an editor was relatively prompt.

EchoN7 2023-06-07

Submitted on the 6th, with editor on the 4th, originally still waiting for editor assignment, but rejected on the 7th directly.

阿拉阿巴 2023-06-05

The speed is very fast, and the editor is Yun Suk Huh, Ph.D. Once it reaches the editor, the editing will be processed the same evening.
The invited reviewers also handle quickly, with minor revisions and acceptance within half a month.

Vinda Sha 2023-06-05

On March 28, 2023, a comprehensive review was submitted and assigned to Editor HyoJong Yoo. The processing speed was very efficient, and it was placed under review on the same day.
On April 26, 2023, the review feedback was received, and both reviewers agreed to accept it, but provided some specific comments.
On May 22, 2023, the revised manuscript was replied to, and it was placed under review on the 26th.
On June 1, 2023, it was accepted.
Overall, the submission process was very satisfactory!

L.H. 2023-06-01

rejected by editor for more than 10 days

han- 2023-05-31

May I ask, how is the article now?

han- 2023-05-31

May I ask how many days your article has been halted in editing?

han- 2023-05-31

Have you received any news? It's been a week and still with the editor.

科研小虎子 2023-03-29

This journal is really slow, be cautious before submitting.

BelleHou 2023-03-29

Timeline of Submission:
January 25th: Submission
External review (3 reviewers)
February 11th: Received review comments (major revisions, one month to revise)
March 12th: Revised manuscript returned
External review (3 reviewers)
March 29th: Received review comments (all 3 reviewers agreed on publication)
March 29th: Received acceptance notification
The article is related to the field of membrane separation.
Both handling editors were Sung Young Park, Ph.D.
Average review time is 2 weeks.
The speed is acceptable.
Comparatively recommended.

WXFX 2023-03-25

Which editor did you assign it to?

JF 2023-03-24

The manuscript number will only be assigned after the status changes to "with editor". At that time, both the manuscript number and the assigned editor will be notified to the corresponding author by email.

WXFX 2023-03-24

What is going on if there is no manuscript number after submission? Can any expert who knows please tell me?

herk 2023-03-16

3.8 Under Review No reviewers accepted the manuscript until 03.16.

了-1 2023-03-07

2023.03.07 translates to March 7, 2023.

了-1 2023-03-04

The text "2023.03.04 rrc" is already in English. It appears to be a date written in the format Year.Month.Day, followed by the letters "rrc," which may be an abbreviation or initials for something specific. Without further context, it is difficult to provide a more accurate translation or interpretation.

了-1 2023-02-28

2023.02.07 rrc translates to English as "February 7, 2023 rrc"
2023.02.28 rrc translates to English as "February 28, 2023 rrc"

이길강 2023-02-28

I submitted my article in October of last year, and I was just informed today that it has been assigned a number and is with the editor. I will never submit to this journal again. It is a Korean journal, and I suggest everyone to be cautious when submitting to it. The journal is slow and has many issues, and considering the current poor relations between China and South Korea, please choose wisely.

herk 2023-02-26

Posted on February 22nd, it has not yet reached the editor's hands, status: Submitted to Journal.

月生木子 2023-02-24

It has been 10 days since it was submitted, but it has not yet reached the editor's hands. Status: Submitted to Journal.

读者665 2023-02-14

It has been 15 days, and it is still "with editor". I have already applied for withdrawal of the manuscript and submitted it to another journal with a faster review process.

JF 2023-02-12

Is it because of plagiarism that it was rejected?

那啊尼 2023-02-12

9% similarity check, rejected, even better ones than this journal were sent for review, speechless.