Dl113 2023-08-08

8.8 with editor

Dl113 2023-08-07

The text in English would be: "The article has not been submitted for review, try JHM. The professor chosen for editing is Uta Bor."

科研之路多大坑 2023-08-04

6.1 Submission
6.23 Under review
7.9 Required reviews completed
7.25 Decision in process
8.3 Transfer pending means it was rejected.

梦番地 2023-08-02

May I ask if the editor has been on vacation recently? I feel that the progress is very slow.

ChaiFF 2023-08-01

My manuscript will be submitted for review after 40 days in the hands of the editor.

fang7539 2023-07-29

Same question, anyone email the editor?

小川 2023-07-29

May I ask what is the result?

小川 2023-07-29

I also have the same problem, asking the same question...

小川 2023-07-29

After RRC, I also turned into DIP. Does it mean I am going to be rejected...

大杀特杀sci 2023-07-28

Are there any friends who have submitted for review after July 20? I have been editing there for 5 days, and I am exhausted.

小川 2023-07-28

7.3投的，陆陆续续六个审稿人接收，到7.28有5个审稿意见回来了，是不是必须要等六个人才行呀，有没有懂的人。

Translation: I submitted it on 7.3, and six reviewers have been receiving it gradually. By 7.28, I have received feedback from five of them. Do I have to wait for all six of them, or does anyone understand?

今天小杨学习了吗 2023-07-28

20230513 Submitted to Journal
20230515 with editor
20230516 under review
20230602 required reviews completed
20230609 major revision (2 reviewers, mostly positive comments, two major revisions suggested, also pointed out some weaknesses, 3-week response time)
20230629 revision submitted to journal
20230630 revisions sent back to author (issues with the formatting of the revised manuscript)
20230630 revision submitted to journal
20230701 with editor
20230710 under review
20230727 Accept

梦番地 2023-07-27

How did it turn out, OP?

梦番地 2023-07-27

May I ask what happened to the original poster in the end?

玄武盾 2023-07-26

6.8 sub
6.8/6.9/6.9 with
6.14 ur
6.28 rrc
7.6 ur
7.21 rrc
7.21 dip
And then rejected

victorysx 2023-07-25

It has been seven days since the submission, and the status has not changed.

大杀特杀sci 2023-07-25

Which editor did JHM submit to? Did they not send an email? Currently, there is only one successfully submitted email in the communication mailbox, and the status with the editor has changed three times.

fyh21 2023-07-25

5.22 submitted
5.24 under review
6.19 major revision; reviewers: 3
7.10 revision submitted
7.11 under review
7.17 accept
7.21 online
The advanced oxidation direction was pursued, with Sungjun Bae as the editor, and the efficiency was fast.

victorysx 2023-07-24

I submitted on the 18th, and until now it's still with the editor. It feels very slow, compared to others which seem to be quite fast.

梦番地 2023-07-24

Reviewed in 11 days, but only two reviewers accepted the review.

victorysx 2023-07-23

How long does everyone take to review and submit?

Pharon.lp 2023-07-23

Wow, brother, it's really excessive to have 27 reviewers for this.

山楂君 2023-07-23

Wuwuwu, among the 7 reviewers, did any of them say reject? I am also one of the 7, and 2 said reject, finally requiring major revisions.

山楂君 2023-07-23

Returned 7, counted 2 as rejections, the rest were revisions, and the edited version was given a major overhaul.

shadowpoem 2023-07-21

After my submission on June 7th, it has been showing that there is no reviewer assigned to review it, and it is still the same until now... I wonder if I can ask the editor about it.

朱啊朱啊朱啊 2023-07-20

May I ask how the situation is now?

上交学者 2023-07-19

5.07 submitted
A total of 7 reviewers, major revisions, and a response letter of nearly 100 pages were written.
7.08 accept
In the field of solid waste and gas waste, JHM is the top journal in the environmental field.
Both major and minor subjects are ranked as top journals in the first division of the Chinese Academy of Sciences.
I hope to publish another paper in the last year of my doctoral career!

梦番地 2023-07-18

May I ask how many reviewers did you find for the under review process?

禾岩 2023-07-18

20230507 submitted
20230509 with editor
20230518 under review
20230609 major revise
20230628 resubmitted
20230715 Accepted
Editor Zaher Hashisho

Translation:
20230507 submitted
20230509 with editor
20230518 under review
20230609 major revise
20230628 resubmitted
20230715 Accepted
Editor Zaher Hashisho

小树先生 2023-07-14

Since there was a reviewer who agreed to review it, "Under review" has not changed for two months. How much time did the editor give? Why do I have to wait 14 days for the review comments for JHM?