琢磨 2023-08-09

Is there a dip after the first trial? Why did I get stuck after the first trial?

24March 2023-08-09

I have been submitting to UR for a total of one month. It has been three weeks since I submitted to UR. Currently, I have invited 21 reviewers, 2 have accepted the review, and 1 has completed the review. The website to view the reviews can be found in the email sent to the corresponding author after UR, or you can enter the manuscript number and corresponding author's name on the journal service of WeChat's Ithinker Scientific Research Publishing Society GZH to view the reviews.

好运好运 2023-08-09

Stuck in the same DIP after repair. I checked the latest issues of the journal, and there haven't been any acceptances for July or August yet. It seems like the person in charge is on vacation. Last year, they also started accepting around August 19th. So, everyone doesn't need to be too anxious, let's wait together for good news!

jsdfasb 2023-08-09

07-27-2023 Submitted to Journal
08-01-2023 With Editor
08-02-2023 With Editor
08-03-2023 Under Review
08-08-2023 Under Review

Translation:
07-27-2023 Submitted to Journal
08-01-2023 With Editor
08-02-2023 With Editor
08-03-2023 Under Review
08-08-2023 Under Review

晴天小Y 2023-08-09

My submission was changed to DIP on August 4th, and I thought there would be news soon. It's already been two semesters... I submitted it on February 21st and it's been a hassle for six months...

琢磨 2023-08-08

Until the 15th, who exactly has been having issues? The decision is still not being made, isn't it because others are still working on the drafts?

墨斗鱼 2023-08-07

8.6 RRC后DIP 当天给了Substantial

After the 8.6 RRC, DIP gave a substantial amount on the same day.

民科来灌水了 2023-08-07

It has been almost 30 days, already numb.

阿克瑟普特 2023-08-07

I have been in a dip since 7.15, not much movement. Sigh.

我是一棵小草 2023-08-07

Comrade, you have been absent for 24 days, right? Any news?

WEIYIABCDE 2023-08-06

Excuse me, teacher, do you have any news about your article now? It has been almost a week for my DIP as well.

琢磨 2023-08-03

The dip after the RRC in this periodical is too normal, but the dip has not ended now. I have been in a dip for 19 days.

琢磨 2023-08-03

I dare not rush for the manuscript, so I can only politely ask the customer service to remind them.

zhaogaolei 2023-08-03

On July 30th, it showed "Required reviews complete." On August 3rd, it suddenly changed to "Decision in Process." Does this mean it will be rejected?

我是一棵小草 2023-08-03

First decision made, the responsible editor-in-chief copied Jevans and Manali, not sure if either of them, Dip, has been unresponsive for 18 days, can I write a letter to urge the editorial department?

向云端嗯嗯嗯 2023-08-03

Same question, my submission has been under review for 19 days, and now it seems like another long wait...

小伙 2023-08-02

I submitted it on July 27th, so I can only envy those who had shorter time.

琢磨 2023-08-02

It's already the 18th day of the dip, but I wonder which editor is on vacation. I see that others in the same field are still working on the manuscripts.

民科来灌水了 2023-08-02

You are probably the reviewer who is hanging up. I have also encountered it. One reviewer delayed for one and a half months.

在读研究僧 2023-08-01

I dare say there should be no one slower than me!!!

2022.12.27 Submit to journal
Forgot when it was with the editor
2023.01.13 Under Review
2023.05.29 Required reviews complete (This was only completed under my urging. It has been five months since submission. Urged on May 28th, required reviews complete on May 29th. If I hadn't urged, who knows when it would have been completed.)
2023.06.01 Received reviewer's comments (minor revisions)
2023.06.13 Submit to journal
2023.06.16 Under Review (since then, the status has remained unchanged)

(For the second review, two reviewers were invited. Both reviewers accepted the invitation, but it's unclear if they are the same as the previous reviewers. One reviewer has returned their comments as of June 26th, but the other one still hasn't provided any results. Did they go on vacation? Does it really take this long for minor revisions? I submitted in 2022 and it's still not finished. I'm so frustrated. I will be more cautious about submitting to JEM in the future. Their efficiency is so low, it's almost comparable to Urban Climate's inefficiency. I wonder if any fellow researchers have any suggestions on how to contact the second reviewer. I have already sent reminders through the system and to Elsevier, I dare not send another one.)

在读研究僧 2023-08-01

Could it be that the damn reviewer went on vacation? Even Chinese teachers usually have a maximum of two weeks off, but I've been waiting for my minor revisions to be reviewed for almost two months. Speechless.

zhhhui 2023-08-01

Under review for 4 days, the first batch invited 12 reviewers, but not a single one has accepted the invitation yet. Starting to worry about being rejected.

阿克瑟普特 2023-08-01

Recently, many of my research friends have been stuck at a bottleneck stage, and I hope that August will bring good results.

民科来灌水了 2023-08-01

I should also update. It has been 20 days since DIP... I can only suspect that the editor is on vacation, otherwise I can't accept it.

琢磨 2023-08-01

It has been 17 days already, and there is no movement.

Ge5ge 2023-07-29

Did you all only make changes once? Why is it so fast?

24March 2023-07-29

Hello, how do you view several reviewers?

玩命书生000 2023-07-28

Translated text:

The first time I submitted to JEM, everything went smoothly from submission to acceptance. The reviewers and editors were very prompt in handling the process! Thumbs up!
Sharing the timeline:
6.1 Submission
Around one week - First reviewer's comments returned
7.7 Comments from two reviewers returned - Minor revisions
7.25 Revised manuscript returned
7.28 Accept

ZWZ1 2023-07-28

How is RRC now?

小精灵 2023-07-28

7.10 submit, 7.24 with editor, 7.27 back to with editor, 7.27 (same day) under review, thank you for the opportunity to review, it got rejected by other journals, lowered expectations, just going with the flow.