wb123 2023-06-30

What does the review process of this journal look like? How come the submission is directly listed as "under review", and there is no response even after sending withdrawal request? I don't know what the situation is.

嘿嘿2021 2023-05-21

19-Mar-2023 submit
21-Mar-2023 under review
24-Apr-2023 moderate revision
04-May-2023 submit revision
08-May-2023 minor revision
12-May-2023 submit revision
16-May-2023 editing format
21-May-2023 accept

Translation:
19th March 2023 - Submitted
21st March 2023 - Under review
24th April 2023 - Moderate revision
4th May 2023 - Submitted revision
8th May 2023 - Minor revision
12th May 2023 - Submitted revision
16th May 2023 - Editing format
21st May 2023 - Accepted

阿尔弗雷德 2023-02-05

The review process is slow, but they want you to make changes quickly. After making the changes, it takes a long time for them to continue reviewing. Even after being accepted, it has been 4-5 months and it is still not online. They keep promising to publish it soon. I checked and found out that the articles published in the first issue of 2023 were actually accepted in 2020. It really wastes a lot of time, and the journal's impact factor is not that great either. It's not even in the top 1-2 quartiles, so it's not worth waiting for.

cuiliwei 2022-12-28

Initial submission in early May 2022, and it has been under review until the end of November. I asked the editor (who responded quite nicely) and they said it was due to the university's anniversary celebration. I would like to inquire if the anniversary celebration is related to the speed of external review? It feels like I have wasted half a year for nothing!

亚历哈大XING 2022-12-01

Progress update:
13-Aug-2022 major revision (20 comments in total from two reviewers; 4 comments from the editorial department, requiring resubmission within two weeks)
25-Aug-2022 revised manuscript submitted
29-Nov-2022 minor revision (4 formatting comments); resubmitted on the same day
1-Dec-2022 accepted

钟世燊 2022-11-18

I have just accepted as well. Can I leave a contact information? I would like to inquire about some follow-up processes.

武痴马保国 2022-10-27

It's been almost three months, and I still haven't received the proofread copy.

中华龙卷风 2022-10-15

May I ask how to contact the reminder for the manuscript? It has been several months now and it has been in "under review" status. I cannot reach the editorial department by phone.

阿尔弗雷德 2022-10-14

After being hired, will there be a final proofreading stage?

阿尔弗雷德 2022-10-14

After the hiring, will there be a final proofreading stage?

阿尔弗雷德 2022-10-14

May I ask if the current status is "Awaiting Production Checklist"? Will there be a final proofreading process after this?

阿尔弗雷德 2022-10-14

Apart from being slow, everything else is actually fine.

中华龙卷风 2022-09-24

It has been over 20 days since the submission, and it has been in the "Under Review" status all along. I'm getting a little anxious. How long did it take for everyone else to get reviewed?

葫芦瓢 2022-08-14

Excuse me, does this journal require a publication fee?

葫芦瓢 2022-08-14

May I ask if this journal charges a page fee?

武痴马保国 2022-07-29

Overall, the review process is not considered long. The manuscript was submitted in December and the feedback was received in April of the following year. After revisions, it took approximately one and a half months to receive the second review result. The acceptance was granted in June.

Alayaprajna 2022-06-09

As one of the few SCI journals in the country, we are committed to creating a high-quality journal and keeping up with other high-quality journals in the industry. The quality of articles has been improving year by year, and the acceptance threshold is also increasing. The only drawback is that the system information updates are a bit slow, which can be frustrating for waiting individuals. It is important to note that after contacting the editor for a reminder, the attitude of the editor was very friendly and they promptly answered any questions. The following is the entire submission process:
21-Feb-2022 submitted
15-Apr-2022 Moderate Revision
08-Jun-2022 Accept

亚历哈大XING 2022-05-26

21-Mar-2022 Submit
28-Mar-2022 Under review
26-May-2022 Results unknown

I have to complain about the slow system update; it has been under review all this time.

jwfreefool 2022-05-15

Submission by the end of December 2021.
First review comments returned by the end of February 2022, minor revisions.
Revised manuscript submitted in early March 2022.
Second review comments returned in March 2022, only one comment.
Returned in March 2022.
Accepted in April 2022, online.
Currently awaiting publication...

青椒小丑 2021-12-25

Within 2 months after submitting the article, some minor revisions were suggested. The journal is published by a geological university and has high quality requirements. However, the updating process in the submission system is slow. It is hoped that the system can be updated in a timely manner in the future, so that authors can track the progress of their articles.

小小林 2021-10-25

Hello! Has your manuscript been accepted now?

flow507 2021-10-25

What's the situation now? Did you receive any submission? It has been a month for mine as well, and it's still "no assigned."

RS飞行员 2021-06-23

Journal of Earth Science

ArcticPWW 2021-05-27

The journal introduction does not mention including oceanography. Can oceanography be submitted?