回复大头鬼 2023-08-05

May I ask what's going on with my paper "Reviews Completed" after a month?

爱你的女科学家 2023-01-24

You're right, after flipping through the papers in this journal, many of them lack high innovativeness. A lot of them just made a slight innovation on a few points.

mjy0501 2022-09-15

A highly recognized publication in the industry, I wonder why the Chinese Academy of Sciences has classified it into the fourth tier?
20220321 submitted
20220403 under review
20220602 Major revision
20220701 Revision submitted
20220719 Under review
20220915 Accept

毕业了论文还在审稿中 2022-03-07

2020.01.16 Post
2020.06.06 Entered review, under review
09 Nov 2020 Under Review
January 2021 Conducted three rounds of peer review
2021.3.24 Review completed, minor revision
2021.4.24 Revision submitted
2021.9.28 Seeking a second peer reviewer's report
11 Dec 2021 Accept
Summary: Graduated in June 2021, still undergoing review. Exhausted mentally and physically. However, it must be said that the review process is indeed rigorous.

毕业了论文还在审稿中 2022-03-07

Very slow, it took me a year to find reviewers for my paper.

handsome520 2022-01-12

The submission status "Editor Assignment Pending" has been going on for a month now. Who else is experiencing the same? Does this mean it has not been sent for external review yet?

132432 2021-08-11

2021--3--1, Invest
2021--3--12, External audit
2021--5--19, Major overhaul
2021--7--28, Minor repair
2021--8--10, Acceptance

fahksdhfosh 2021-08-11

Combination Optimization is a specialized journal, with the chief editor and editorial board mostly consisting of Americans. The review process is also mostly conducted by American teachers. The journal has a narrow focus, accepting articles that involve mathematical derivations as well as those in the field of production optimization. In comparison to other journals, its scope of acceptance is limited, unlike broad categories such as materials and energy, which accept any relevant articles and therefore have a high impact factor. This leads to fewer citations and a lower ranking for this journal. The proportion of Chinese submissions is small, and the journal emphasizes fundamental research rather than practical applications. It takes approximately seven to eight months from submission to publication. If one article is accepted, it can be used to replace two articles from other major journals, making it eligible for a Ph.D. application at the University of Minnesota.

2 2021-08-10

Combination optimization of corresponding journals, high-quality journals in operations research, mathematics field, comparably low attention rate.

LAL1 2021-08-06

The translation of the text "组合优化领域老牌期刊" into English is "well-established journal in the field of combinatorial optimization."

洞察 2021-08-03

2020.5 May - Submitted
2020.5 May - Under review
2020.7 July - Review completed
2020.7 July - Major revision (two experts, one additional experiment, five questions answered, multiple improvements in expression)
2020.8 August - Revision submitted
2020.8 August - Under review
2020.9 September - Minor revision (grammar and formatting errors)
2020.9 September - Revision submitted
2020.10 October - Decision in process
2020.11 November - Accept
The paper does not mention any funding sources, the authors do not include foreigners or multiple affiliations, and they do not recommend reviewers they know. It is a regular submission, and the journal is relatively fair. Even Ph.D. candidates without strong connections can submit their papers. This has been tested, and the journal does not prioritize titles or affiliations.

北所 2021-06-30

One of the excellent journals in the field of combinatorial optimization, it leans towards mathematical theory deduction and is relatively difficult. This journal hardly accepts articles that are purely application-based or framework-based (perhaps the editor-in-chief considers these to be myths or fantasies, but many top-tier journals are very fond of framework and application-based articles, such as those that construct models, propose frameworks, improve algorithms, etc.). It accepts more basic research articles, which leads to low citation rates because they involve mathematical deduction, which many people find dull or difficult to understand. Consequently, the journal's impact factor is also low. However, the articles published in this journal have guaranteed quality. The review experts for this journal are all mathematics experts (to my knowledge, many journals randomly select reviewers from a system, including students reviewing articles, even for many top-tier journals. This is the reason why acceptance is often dependent on luck. This journal uses its own pool of experts and does not accept author-recommended reviewers). If one has academic aspirations and does not excessively focus on the journal's impact factor and ranking, this journal is a good choice. It can serve as a representation of one's research value and achievements. The review process is also not slow, with a first decision given within two months. Our research group has included this journal in the recommended publishing list along with many high-ranking journals. If an article is accepted, a reward of 10,000 yuan will be given. However, currently, no one has successfully published in this journal, and the reasons for rejection are usually due to the article being too focused on frameworks and applications.

32432424 2021-06-09

The journal is very good and suitable for all bloggers to submit articles. This journal is in the field of mathematics and also accepts articles on optimization applications. The editor-in-chief is very meticulous, carefully verifying every piece of data and formula. The journal does not require too much innovation, only the solution to one or a few optimization problems is needed, but it must be practical. The only drawback is that it takes a long time, with at least a two-month interval between each revision. The journal is not well-known and can be considered as one of the hidden gems in the journal world. It focuses on running the journal steadily without competing with others. Those who are not in a hurry to graduate can give it a try.