Verified Reviews - Journal of Cleaner Production
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

xiaofanfan 2023-06-20

May I ask how to view the edits?

yyyaccept 2023-06-19

Dear experts, how can we know who the editor is during the "with editor" stage after submission? I kindly request some guidance.

三叶草2311 2023-06-19

My submission is still in progress, and I'm not sure if it can be reviewed. The word count is a bit over.

fit 2023-06-19

Hello, may I ask how long it usually takes for the review process? I have changed from 529 to "with editor", but there have been no updates until now.

fit 2023-06-19

Hello, may I ask how long it usually takes to undergo review? I have changed from 529 to "with editor" status, but there has been no update until now.

不忘初心+1 2023-06-18

Yes, last time I submitted a manuscript, I deleted everything that could be deleted, totaling 7995 words, and it was rejected directly, stating that it exceeded the journal's word limit requirement. I suppose there might be other sections that are also counted as words.

三叶草2311 2023-06-18

Dear experts, do all authors need to confirm this journal? Also, will exceeding the word limit have any impact?

康帅 2023-06-17

Is Sachin Kumar Mangla an Indian editor? He is just a stupid idiot. MD.

Xiaopi Ding 2023-06-17

This editor is very slow and feels very irresponsible. I have submitted twice, and the last time it was transferred to another editor who said that my repetition rate was a bit high. This editor did not take any action or provide any useful replies.

Xiaopi Ding 2023-06-17

I have reminded twice, delayed for 30 days, without any opinions, it was directly redirected to a cleaner OA sub-journal. I will never submit again, it's disgusting.

童童童1 2023-06-16

Did you submit it for review after the reminder to submit the manuscript?

xiaopang123 2023-06-15

Is it basically a rejection or is it for review?

xiaopang123 2023-06-15

Is it mostly rejection?

Rake 2023-06-15

Jin Mingzhou is very slow. Usually, it takes about a month to get a reply, which is not very reliable.

Rake 2023-06-15

Jin Mingzhou is very slow. Normally, it takes him a month to handle something. I reminded him once, and he directly asked me to submit an article to a low-quality magazine where he is the editor-in-chief. He is extremely irresponsible.

Rake 2023-06-15

My editor is Dr. Zuo Jian, hired for three months, and a major revision.

Hsxxxx 2023-06-15

I really didn't expect to be accepted within a month. Submitted on 4/20 and accepted on 5/29. One major revision and one minor revision were done. On 6/7, it was published online. I am grateful to the Korean editor with the surname Kim who, single-handedly, improved my impression of Korean people.

Xiaopi Ding 2023-06-14

Do you have Mingzhou Jin's?

Xiaopi Ding 2023-06-14

I just followed up today, followed up a week ago, and submitted the manuscript on the 18th. Are you also Professor Jin Mingzhou by any chance?

小仙女dpt 2023-06-13

No need to rush, at least 1 month.

xiaopang123 2023-06-12

It has been two weeks with the editor. Should we follow up on the manuscript?

sun 2023-06-12

Same management, half a month always with the editor.

WintersG 2023-06-12

Admire you, my brother. Since January 29th, you have experienced major and minor revisions, and now you are stuck in DIP.

昕小一_ 2023-06-12

23.3.26投稿 - Submitted on March 26, 23
23.5.6 大修 - Major revision on May 6, 23
23.5.20 小修 - Minor revision on May 20, 23
23.5.24 录用 - Accepted on May 24, 23

Editor: Xin Tong

小白东 2023-06-12

6.1投,6.12 with editor. Indeed, it is the slowest I have ever seen. I want to say, "Don't hesitate to reject me, I need to move on to the next one."

星星之火 2023-06-11

JCP is too slow now!! It has been sent to 15 reviewers, but only 1 accepted the review.

小仙女dpt 2023-06-11

Where can I respond to the reviewer's comments?

dragonlord 2023-06-10

The text "Jun 10 under review" is already in English.

yyyaccept 2023-06-10

I have checked with turuin, and the duplication rate is around 18% and it has been submitted for review, so it's not that exaggerated.

weixin peng 2023-06-10

"You only used UR for 14 days, and now it's the 6th day of DIP. Does the first-instance DIP also take that long?"

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started