民工1号 2023-06-09

I have been in "decision in process" for 14 days and still have not received any results.

X~X 2023-03-22

03.13 decision in process - This means that a decision is currently being made.
03.20 with editor - This indicates that the document or text is currently being reviewed or worked on by an editor.
03.20 accept - This implies that the document or text has been approved or accepted.

X~X 2023-03-11

3.2 Format issue, revised again, With Editor
3.4 Under Review
3.10 Required Reviews Completed

X~X 2023-02-18

2022,10.03 Submission
2023.02.13 Major revision
2023.02.18 Revised
Several reminders were sent via email, and it took a long time for the editor to submit the review. The review process took approximately over a month.

X~X 2022-11-29

What's the status of yours? Mine has been in the hands of the editor for two months, with no rejection or review. I have sent three emails to the editor-in-chief, but there has been no response or assistance in contacting the responsible editor. It's really frustrating.

hxbhero 2022-11-20

Approximately half a month for review.

X~X 2022-11-16

May I ask how long it takes for the status to change to "with editor" and "under review" after submitting your paper? It has been a month and a half for me, and it is still "with editor." I'm not sure how much longer I have to wait.

hxbhero 2022-11-10

9.1 submitted
10.26 Minor Revisions
11.4 revision submitted
11.8 decision in process
Waiting for results

casting 2022-10-12

It has been a month and a half since the external audit, and there is still no news.

小小明 2022-08-06

Don't worry, it should be fine. The editing process for each calendar orientation takes different amounts of time, depending on the selected publishing period corresponding to the calendar.

hehe243 2022-08-03

I also submitted in May, it has been two months with the editor, and only one month with the external review, there are still no results.

hehe243 2022-08-03

I also submitted in May, and it was in the hands of the editor for two months, and only underwent external review for one month.

小小明 2022-07-31

2022.05.25 Submitted to Journal
2022.05.27 With editor
2022.05.31 Under review
2022.06.15 Under review
2022.06.22 Required reviews completed
2022.07.10 Revision submitted to Journal
2022.07.13 With editor
2022.07.13 Decision in process
2022.07.26 Accepted

Translation:
2022.05.25 Submitted to Journal
2022.05.27 With editor
2022.05.31 Under review
2022.06.15 Under review
2022.06.22 Required reviews completed
2022.07.10 Revision submitted to Journal
2022.07.13 With editor
2022.07.13 Decision in process
2022.07.26 Accepted

junjun 2022-07-22

Just voted today, hoping for a good outcome.

橙子 2022-07-03

Received December 27, 2021;
Major Revisions May 15, 2022;
Accepted June 15, 2022;
Published: June 28, 2022.

hehe243 2022-06-26

It has been a month since the submission, and the status is "with editor". I haven't received any news. Does this mean it's not going to happen anymore?

XWLNEU 2022-04-13

Submitted on 2021.06.11, accepted on 2022.03.09, after nine months of process, with two major revisions (which didn't actually change much). The editor was very responsible, and I initially thought it would be rejected, but they did some polishing on the language details.
Note: The article requires a maximum of 12 figures and tables combined. It should be submitted according to the themes listed in their Editorial Calendar (https://www.tms.org/EditorialCalendar), and pay attention to the SUBMISSION DEADLINE to avoid rejection.

backseven 2022-03-17

It has been 50 days since the major revision with the editor, but there has been no response. It's really a waste of my time.

cxx2022 2022-03-17

The submission has been close to 6 months, the result is unknown. It feels like those who submitted earlier might have editor recommendations or something similar. The regular submission process is too slow (initial review takes over a month, external review takes over three months).

蛆蛆 2022-03-08

Does the total number of diagrams and tables not exceed 8?

归来仍是 2022-03-03

A few reviewers.

很丑的才人 2022-03-01

Come and share the submission process with everyone (in great detail). Overall, it is good. The editorial efficiency is extremely high, but the magazine department takes a bit longer to handle the manuscripts, around five days or so.

12.1 submitted to journal
12.3 with editor
12.12 with editor
12.16 under review
12.28 under review
01.13 required reviews completed
01.16 minor revisions
01.18 revision submitted to journal
01.21 with editor (I thought it would be directly accepted, but they added reviewers 3 and 4)
01.27 under review
02.14 required reviews completed
02.18 minor revisions
02.20 revision submitted to journal
02.24 with editor
02.27 decision in process
02.27 with editor
02.27 accept

波波3 2021-12-28

Submission to acceptance takes 2.5 months. The process involves submission, external review, major revisions, and direct acceptance.

MUYYZ 2021-12-16

Two reminder letters were sent on December 13th and December 15th respectively, but they were received on December 15th, which was too slow. Please choose this journal cautiously. However, this journal accepts review articles. If you have nowhere to submit your English review articles, you may consider it.

MUYYZ 2021-12-09

Posted on June 28, 2021, after two revisions, the status became "with editor" on November 12th. On November 19th, the status changed to "decision in process." On December 6th, it once again became "with editor." I don't know what's going on. It's just too slow!

波波3 2021-12-07

One month, gave a major repair, now repaired back, no results.

Torelli 2021-09-06

A journal with a very fast review speed, the total time from submission to acceptance is 3 months, during which it also went through major revisions, additional experiments, and paper proofreading processes. This journal has a submission calendar, under which certain areas of submission are accepted within a specific period of time. Submissions not following the calendar will be directly rejected. Additionally, the total number of figures and tables in this journal should not exceed 8, and some additional figures need to be included in a separate supplementary material document.

爱吃喵喵的鱼 2021-03-18

Journal official website, then JOURNAL UPDATES, then there is a JOM Editorial Calendar, click on the Editorial Calendar link below.

guoguoguo 2021-03-18

Excuse me everyone,
How can I check the thematic calendar of this journal?

爱吃喵喵的鱼 2021-03-01

The reviewer is very professional and the reviewing speed is relatively fast, but the editing processing speed is slightly slow. It is important to pay attention to the word count and format of the manuscript. Additionally, this journal has a submission theme calendar, and submissions must be made according to the theme calendar.

Specific submission process:
2020.9.16 submitted
2020.11.04 major revision
2020.11.16 revised submission
Two format modifications in between
2020.1.16 under review
2020.2.25 decision in process
2020.2.27 accepted