Verified Reviews - International Journal of Sediment Research
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

Advance_Lv 2023-02-03

The manuscript submitted in January 2022, and it was under review after 7 days. There were several reviewers involved during the process, which took a whole year!! It was unbelievably slow!! Then in January 2023, they rejected my submission with less than 10 comments. I suspect that the reviewers didn't take it seriously, and their suggestions made me both laugh and cry. It wasted a whole year of my time, and I'm really grateful for that! If they publish so few articles in a year, they should review them promptly instead of dragging it out for so long! I urge everyone to be cautious when submitting to this journal. I have been hurt by this experience!!!

浮游 2021-06-03

One month after submission for revision, the content of the reviewers is mediocre. I feel that this journal is overly obsessed with the formatting of the articles.
For the second revision, there were only a few scattered suggestions to change the image format. After completing the revisions and submitting them to the editor, there was no change for two months.
For the third revision, a few more images were changed, and finally it was accepted.
Overall, it's okay, but the speed of the editor's handling of the manuscript is sometimes fast and sometimes slow. The article took six months from submission to acceptance, with half of the time spent in the hands of the editor.

Publish scientific posters with Peeref

Peeref publishes scientific posters from all research disciplines. Our Diamond Open Access policy means free access to content and no publication fees for authors.

Learn More

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started