沧海一粒沙 2023-08-05

Aug 04, 2023 Submit
Aug 04, 2023 With Editor

beyond_guo 2023-07-18

Posted on July 5, 2022, I didn't receive the first-instance opinion.

shitou05 2023-07-17

Submitted in June 2022, it is now July 2023, and I have not received the first instance opinion.

玉清 2023-07-03

2023.4.30 submit
2023.5.15 with editor
2023.5.30 with editor
2023.6.16 under review
2023.6.23 under review
2023.7.2 under review
Only one reviewer accepted, the editor keeps searching for new ones.

打工都是人上人 2023-07-02

The decision is in process. It has been rejected after two months, and the external review comments are very simple, lacking innovation.

打工都是人上人 2023-05-31

The submission has been rejected after more than two months with very brief feedback, stating insufficient innovation.
The attitude of the magazine... speechless, taking so long.

风浪雨奏 2023-05-11

How to check who the editor is?

Lucky Judy 2023-05-07

Where did you all send the reminder letter? Was it sent through the journal system or your own email? Why can't I find the editorial department's email?

8篇毕业 2023-05-05

May I ask what's the situation behind? My current situation is also like this.

LS 2023-04-28

May I ask if there is any update on your paper? Mine is also "decision in process" before being sent for review. It has been over 20 days now.

打工都是人上人 2023-04-03

Oh my god, it's been so long, mine is also "Decision in Process", I'm scared.

打工都是人上人 2023-04-03

How is your thesis? Mine is also the same result, still waiting.

退之 2023-03-30

Is this journal double-blind peer reviewed?

Doctor Ww 2023-03-17

How is the current state?

relax 2023-03-02

What is your current status now?

relax 2023-02-28

September 1, 2022 Submission
September 20, 2022 with editor
February 25, 2023 Decision in Process
The decision seems to have been made before the review, so it's probably not looking good. I hope it gets resolved quickly.

relax 2023-02-27

I also turned into "decision in process" before the initial review. Does this mean I will be rejected?

relax 2023-02-27

Before the initial review, it has already changed to "decision in process". Does it mean it will be rejected?

风浪雨奏 2023-02-20

It has been 8 months with no movement with eiitor.

哎呦不错 2023-02-17

Who is Big Z??

shitou05 2023-02-17

In English, it is translated as: "In my case, September is still with the editor."

Mascot_ 2023-02-15

August 6, 2022: Submission
February 15, 2023: With editor

quanuquan 2023-02-13

2021.11.4 Initial draft submission
2022.10.22 Revision
2022.12.17 Submission of revised draft
2023.2.13 Acceptance
Each step in between takes quite a long time. The decision process after the initial review under review takes at least 8 to 9 months. Sending reminders multiple times is not effective. The journal has a high reputation, especially in the field of rock studies, but the processing time is really slow. However, the outcome is good. Finally, it has been accepted for publication. I also wish everyone good luck in getting accepted.

aaaaa 2023-02-07

05/22/04 submitted to journal
05/22/16 with editor
12/13/22 under review
02/05/23 required reviews complete
I'm powerless to comment, and I don't know how long it will take to receive a decision. Zhao Jian is handling the manuscript.

SC---30 2023-01-12

After reading your decision, I am now in a panic, not knowing how long I have to wait!!!

鸭绒 2023-01-10

Wish everyone good luck!

鸭绒 2023-01-10

Submitted to journal on 22-05-10
With editor on 22-05-16
Under review on 22-06-06
Decision in process on 22-07-12
Major revision on 22-08-05
With editor on 22-09-27
Under review on 22-12-01
Decision in process on 22-12-29
Accepted on 23-01-10

There were a total of two reviewers who provided over forty comments. The review comments were very professional and detailed, greatly assisting in improving the quality of the manuscript. Wishing the journal continued success!

科研小咸鱼 2023-01-02

How long does the "decision in process" status last?

shitou05 2022-12-25

I would like to ask if the submission status has changed now.

shitou05 2022-12-25

Similarly, submitting in June and being "With Editor" until now, there has been no use in urging for the manuscript.