游客 2023-06-26

After a period of time, the status changes to "Decision Pending," and then it goes back to "Out for Review." What is the situation?

Schafeli 2023-06-21

Top journals in the field of Operations Research in Management Science have a mathematical level that far surpasses the superficial theoretical level of ordinary journals like OR and MS. Publishing an article in such a journal would qualify one to become the dean of Harvard Business School and potentially even be nominated for the Nobel Prize in Economics, an achievement that no Chinese person has been able to accomplish yet.

lipingxu 2023-06-11

Hello, what is your current status? I have been with the editor for over two months.

wakerr 2023-05-18

May I ask if the word count for submission must be below 9000 words?

promisejj 2022-12-16

Hello, it seems that IJPR has updated its submission system. After submission, it is not directly under review. May I ask what the status was when you submitted it?

奋斗 2022-09-09

3 reviewers, decision pending after 3 months, then another month for one review to return with minor revisions. Two major revisions were needed, taking over one month to complete. The reviewers provided constructive feedback, including pointing out formula errors. They were very responsible. After the revisions, the paper was accepted in less than a month. The entire process took 7 months.

JerryLCC 2022-08-29

Before the feedback comes back, the status is "Under Review".

daqiang9666 2022-08-06

Just to confirm, what was the status before receiving the suggestions for revision?

JerryLCC 2022-04-06

Here are the submission timeline milestones for your reference:

1. 2021.5.27 - Under review
2. 2021.7.10 - Major revision but allows resubmission
3. 2021.8.04 - A revision has been submitted
4. 2021.9.23 - Minor revision
5. 2021.10.10 - A revision has been submitted and is currently under review
6. 2021.12.07 - Minor revision
7. 2021.12.13 - A revision has been submitted and is currently under review
8. 2022.3.14 - Accepted

Ma_Cy 2022-03-17

You have been slow for the past two months.

唐宋yjk 2022-03-16

2021.8.9 submitted;
2021.10.7 major revision;
2021.12.3 returned after modification;
2022.1.10 minor revision;
2022.1.17 returned after modification;
2022.2.12 accepted.

唐宋yjk 2022-03-16

A little slower, but still acceptable.

banda 2022-03-05

April 26, 2021 - Submitted; September 6, 2021 - Major revision;
November 18, 2021 - Returned after revision; December 20, 2021 - Minor revision;
December 26, 2021 - Returned after revision; February 16, 2022 - Minor revision;
February 20, 2022 - Returned after revision; March 2, 2022 - Accepted
The journal's review process is very strict, and it seems to be increasingly difficult to get accepted.

橙子 2022-03-03

Wow, this is too smooth! Can I take a look at the article you wrote?

11131 2022-01-12

How can I upload experimental data?

11131 2022-01-12

May I ask how to upload data?

AA华蓥山NU 2022-01-04

Okay, thank you for sharing.

花椒面 2022-01-04

The opinion was given after the first review, which took about two months.

AA华蓥山NU 2022-01-04

May I ask how long it took for the original poster (OP) to go from ADM (Application Decision Made) to under review? Thank you.

AA华蓥山NU 2021-12-29

Thank you for sharing. As I am about to submit to this journal, I wanted to inquire how long the first review process took. Thank you.

花椒面 2021-12-27

Submit in May, major revisions in July, minor revisions in September, acceptance in December. The process is a bit slow, but the reviewers' comments are quite fair.

AA华蓥山NU 2021-12-24

About to submit, I would like to inquire about the time for "with editor" and "under review". Thank you.

蔡新一 2021-12-22

I don't know why the impact factor for 2020-2021 is so high. I hope it continues to stay high and reaches the top tier of the Chinese Academy of Sciences.

蔡新一 2021-12-20

2021.7.7 Submission
2021.8.27 Major revision;
2021.10.19 Submission of revised draft;
2021.11.18 Minor revision;
2021.11.25 Submission of revised draft;
2021.12.20 Accepted.

luckywd 2021-11-09

2021.3.2 Submission;
2021.4.28 Major revisions;
2021.7.14 Submission of revised manuscript;
2021.8.3 Major revisions;
2021.9.28 Submission of revised manuscript;
2021.11.6 Acceptance.

First review had four reviewers, two major revisions, and two minor revisions. Second review had only one reviewer who requested additional experiments, but had no other comments.

Brake 2021-08-11

Submitted for two months, received feedback. Both reviewers agreed on the basic modifications, but the editor rejected it due to excessive page count. What the heck...

Ustc math trash 2021-07-28

2020/4/1 First Submission
2020/6/22 Minor Revision
2020/7/1 Second Submission
2020/7/26 Accept

The submission went smoothly and it surprised me a bit, I'm happy.

syw450 2021-05-07

Just submitted the manuscript and it is under review. Is it always in this status before receiving the reviewer's comments? How long does it usually take for this journal to complete the review process?

Smile微微 2021-05-06

Hello, may I ask if it is possible to add funding during the proof stage if it was not included when submitting the journal?

叫我哈哈 2021-04-19

Just received the acceptance notification. Little Xiu went back and waited for three months, without urging the editor in the meantime. Although it took a long time, it was worth it. An authoritative journal in the field of industrial engineering. Wishing for even better.