sieger 2023-08-08

Mid-April submission
Early June major revised
Early July submit
Until now with editor
Hope smooth

qingxuecandy 2023-08-04

I envy you so much. I submitted a few days earlier than you, but I will only receive feedback at the end of July. This is so frustrating.

qingxuecandy 2023-08-04

I have finished all 28 sides, you can submit them.

relaying2014 2023-07-20

Does this magazine have any requirements for the submission format, such as not exceeding 20 pages?

蓄风 2023-07-14

2023.2.26 Submission
2023.4.11 Major revision
2023.5.18 Revised manuscript submission
2023.6.3 Reviewers' completion required
2023.7.13 Accepted

Xiaobai 2023-07-12

+1, submitted on July 17th, 22. It is still under review and similarly, only one review has been completed.

kary60 2023-06-27

2023.4.24 Submission
2023.4.28-Present with editor (Really slow)

海南鸡饭最好吃 2023-06-24

My review process is roughly as follows:
First review:
With editor, around 17 days
Under review & major revision, around 10 days
Second review:
Resubmit on April 27th
Under review on May 5th
Decision in process on May 17th
Complete accept on June 12th
Hehe, this is my rough review process. Some dates may not be completely accurate, but they shouldn't be too far off.

一缕阳光 2023-06-20

Is the reviewing speed of this journal so fast now?

随YY 2023-06-17

Now the number of manuscripts for review in Q1 journals has increased dramatically, and it is not easy to find experts. It feels like the average review time has increased by at least two months. If we continue to struggle in finding reviewers, you can consider asking around, but it may not have a significant effect.

海南鸡饭最好吃 2023-06-13

The previous review period usually takes 2-3 months, but this time it's a bit refreshing.

QKY_NCEPU 2023-06-01

May I ask what is the email address for submitting manuscript reminders? Mine is also very slow, and I would like to send a reminder as it has been "under review" for a long time, with only one reviewer currently assigned.

QKY_NCEPU 2023-06-01

It's been two months under review, and I have only found one reviewer. Do you know an email address for requesting an update?

ransyxu 2023-04-17

2023.4.15 decision in process translates to: The decision is currently being processed on April 15, 2023.

海南鸡饭最好吃 2023-04-14

Share the submission process:
March 17, 2023 - Submitted
April 4, 2023 - Under review
April 14, 2023 - Major revision with no requirement to modify or add experiments
Didn't expect the result to come out so quickly, only 10 days. I've never experienced this before. Haha.

xiaowei000000 2023-03-30

The review process is too slow! I submitted it on July 1, 2022, and so far, it is still under review as of March 30, 2023. I have sent three reminders during this time, and the feedback received was that one reviewer has completed the review. The problem is that the other reviewers have already passed the review period, so why isn't the editor following up or finding new reviewers?

Xiaobai 2023-03-30

It's really too slow, too slow. It's advised to be cautious if you have bad luck.
Submitted on 22.7.17.
A reviewer completed the review on 23.1.30.
Still under review as of 23.3.28.
I asked Elsevier customer service and they said only one reviewer has completed the review so far.

ransyxu 2023-03-13

2022.12.14 submitted.
2023.2.21 minor revision
2023.3.4 revised and submitted.

Translation:

2022.12.14 submitted.
2023.2.21 minor revision
2023.3.4 revised and submitted.

旦逢良辰顺颂时宜 2023-03-09

May I ask if your application is currently in "Decision in progress"?

奔跑的科研小菜鸡 2023-03-08

It is really slow, very slow. I also submitted my manuscript in June 2022, and the first review did not end until March 2023. Now I am waiting for the results, hoping for some revisions.

dikesen 2023-02-13

12.13 submitted
12.15 with editor
12.23 reject
The reason for rejection is that the scope does not quite meet the requirements for publication. However, this journal clearly has had similar articles in my research area before, so it could be that the editor currently does not need them.

violet 2023-02-04

The review process is really slow in 2022. I submitted it in June 2022, but I didn't receive the first rejection until January 31, 2023. Be cautious when submitting.

Holmes_z.h 2023-01-28

First review took 5 and a half months, second review took a little over 1 month, totaling about 7 months. It was a bit slow, possibly because a second reviewer couldn't be found, so there was no news for a while. A reminder was sent during the fourth and fifth months respectively.
6.15 Submitted to journal
6.18 With Editor
6.20 With Editor
6.21 Under Review
12.06 Major Revision
12.13 Revised Resubmission
12.13 With Editor
12.23 With Editor
12.26 Under Review
1.1 Reviews Completed
1.24 Accept

旦逢良辰顺颂时宜 2022-12-26

It has been exactly two months and I am still with the editor. Hopefully, I can submit it for review in January 2023.

旦逢良辰顺颂时宜 2022-12-15

It has been almost two months since 12.19, or with the editor.

旦逢良辰顺颂时宜 2022-11-27

How long did it take for you to submit it in the end?

奔跑的科研小菜鸡 2022-10-23

I have sent a reminder letter. The editor replied, saying that it is indeed still in the "under review" stage. Please be patient and wait!

玫瑰花的葬礼咦 2022-10-21

Boss, do you have any recommendations for a faster reviewer in the field of electronics and electrical engineering?

CUG_DCC 2022-10-17

Excuse me, how do I know if the reviewer has accepted the review?

奔跑的科研小菜鸡 2022-10-14

2022.06.03 - Submitted the paper
2022.06.25 - Sent for external review
2022.10.24 - Still no news, sent two reminders
2023.02.03 - Date changed once, but status still under review
2023.02.27 - First review completed
2023.03.01 - Decision in Process
Rejected, it's really frustrating. It took 9 months for review, one expert appreciated it, another expert said it lacked innovation, and the editor rejected it directly. Such a waste of time! I will never submit to this journal again!