huangxuejian 2023-06-10

It's been a month and there's still no external review.

huangxuejian 2023-05-17

It has been a week since the submission, but it is still a new submission. The layout fee is still $2,090.

sailor_1 2023-05-05

4.28 Under Review: This means that something is currently being reviewed or evaluated.

5.2 变更一次信息: This translates to "Change information once" in English.

洋芋果 2023-04-25

4.11 submit, 4.25 still with editor, is this a good sign?

sailor_1 2023-04-25

4.18 submit
4.25 It's still a new submission
Is there anyone else in the same situation as me?

network 2023-03-29

How is the speed now?

apoorman 2023-01-05

Is the handling fee EUR850 or 1400?

meilikaiguo 2022-07-03

May I ask where can I download the LaTeX template for the journal?

快乐星球的一抔土 2022-05-01

The initial review took over a month, and after major revisions, it took another month for reevaluation. It was directly accepted for publication, with an estimated impact factor of 2.2 in June 2022, slightly increasing from the previous year. It is considered a potential stock, as the overall difficulty of the journal is moderate and the quality is decent, making it suitable for master's students to practice.

不想奋斗的学生 2022-03-02

2021.11.21, submission
2021.12.8, minor revision
2022.1.17, online premiere

dongnan 2021-08-03

The journal has been acquired by Springer and is an open-access journal, but the peer review process follows non-open-access standards, which are more formal and strict. As a result, the review process is slower compared to other open-access journals, and the rejection rate is high. The submission experience is as follows:

February 6, 2021 - Submission
February 7, 2021 - Format review not passed, returned
February 9, 2021 - Resubmission
February 17, 2021 - External review
March 19, 2021 - External review completed
March 23, 2021 - Major revisions, over twenty modification suggestions from three expert reviewers
April 8, 2021 - Submission after revisions
April 16, 2021 - External review
May 18, 2021 - External review completed
May 24, 2021 - Major revisions (one expert requested additional evaluation criteria, while the other two experts suggested minor revisions)
June 3, 2021 - Revised submission
June 11, 2021 - External review
July 2, 2021 - External review completed
July 5, 2021 - Minor revisions
July 15, 2021 - Revised submission
August 1, 2021 - Acceptance
The paper has significantly improved after revisions, and it feels like it could be submitted to a Tier 2 journal.

追求卓越 2021-07-22

The journal has changed its publisher and is now under Springer. The new website is: https://www.springer.com/journal/44196.

xixi同学 2021-06-10

4.29 Submission
6.5 Under review