donglei123 2023-07-05

Apr 14, 2023 - Submitted to Journal
Apr 14, 2023 - Under Review
Apr 20, 2023 - Under Review
Apr 23, 2023 - Under Review
Apr 24, 2023 - Under Review
Apr 28, 2023 - Under Review
May 02, 2023 - Under Review
May 21, 2023 - Required Reviews Completed
May 23, 2023 - Major Revision
Jun 06, 2023 - With Editor
Jun 18, 2023 - Accept

donglei123 2023-06-07

Apr 14, 2023 - Submitted to Journal
Apr 14, 2023 - Under Review
Apr 20, 2023 - Under Review
Apr 23, 2023 - Under Review
Apr 24, 2023 - Under Review
Apr 28, 2023 - Under Review
May 02, 2023 - Under Review
May 21, 2023 - Required Reviews Completed
May 23, 2023 - Major Revision
Jun 06, 2023 - With Editor

史梦川 2023-06-02

What is the current situation now? Mine also required reviews completed.

donglei123 2023-05-22

The time has changed five times under review.

donglei123 2023-05-22

The editor is Professor H.S. Kim. Professor H.S. Kim is very fast in the review process, with the review being submitted on the same day! The availability of reviewers may have been difficult, as the "Under Review" status changed four times. Currently, it is stated that the required reviews have been completed. According to the Journal Article Publishing Support Center, a total of three reviewers have accepted the review, and currently, two of them have already provided their review comments. We are now waiting for the results!!

Apr 14, 2023: Submitted to Journal
Apr 14, 2023: Under Review
Apr 20, 2023: Under Review
Apr 23, 2023: Under Review
Apr 24, 2023: Under Review
Apr 28, 2023: Under Review
May 02, 2023: Under Review
May 21, 2023: Required Reviews Completed

达达达令 2023-05-09

Slow, very slow. The first review takes about two weeks. The editor gave a grammar revision, and after submitting the proofread version, it was uploaded two weeks later and entered the first review. The first review period is approximately four months. There are two reviewers for major revisions in the first review, with seven review comments. The acceptance was received three days after uploading the comments, but the proofreading has not been done for two weeks.

辛追 2023-02-21

Submitted on Sep 19, 2022
Revised on Jan 18, 2023
Accepted on Jan 26, 2023
After submitting the manuscript, a reminder letter was sent four months later. The next day, the editor provided minor revisions. The reviewer's comments were very professional and greatly improved the quality of the article. Editor Z. P. Lu was very responsible and promptly addressed any issues encountered during the manuscript modification process.

做涂层的czz 2022-08-12

Laser cladding direction:
2022/6/17 JAC resubmission
2022/6/18 under review
2022/7/11 required reviews completed
2022/7/14 Major revision (two reviewers, very friendly, one requested additional experiments, politely declined)
2022/7/25 Revision
2022/7/27 under review
2022/8/3 required reviews completed
2022/8/4 completed-accept
2022/8/10 proof
Very efficient and excellent journal!

Lucqing 2022-06-03

"Required reviews completed" indicates that the reviewers have finished reviewing and are awaiting the editor's handling. Generally, the results will be available within a week. Good luck to you!

Lucqing 2022-06-03

Recently the speed has been decent, usually around two to three months. Good luck to you!

鸩夜千羽 2022-05-31

Excuse me, how long does the status "Required Reviews Completed" last?

少年2019 2021-08-21

submission 2021-02-22
under review 2021-03-06
major revise 2021-06-05
resubmit 2021-07-16
under review 2021-07-24
accept 2021-08-20
The overall speed is a bit slow, but the annual publication volume of around 250 articles is generally normal. Since major revisions require additional experiments, a one-month revision is requested. I applied for a 7-day extension myself, and the editor was very nice and gave me a direct reply, granting a 10-day extension. Although the impact factor is not high, the overall influence of the journal is good. If you are not in a hurry to graduate, you can submit to this journal!

少年2019 2021-08-09

Generally, it is not possible to complete within three months. From editing to review, it usually takes a little over two weeks!

ahhahhah 2021-07-01

It has been 48 days under review, why is there still no decision? It's a bit slow!!!!!!1

pluto_70 2021-01-26

Is there any news now?