carton83 2022-03-21

Submitted on August 19, 2021.
Received minor revision comments on January 22, 2022.
Revised on February 7, 2022.
Accepted on February 22, 2022.
Overall, the editor has very strict formatting requirements. During the review process, the handling editor has been in contact with the reviewers and has contacted the associate editor several times. The responses have been polite, but contacting the handling editor usually does not receive a response. The reviewers' questions are also quite professional. It is an established journal with a low impact factor. It is unknown when it will be indexed by WoS (Web of Science).

NUAAYLZ 2022-01-14

I just looked at it and it is indeed, but I am also not sure...

deer_啦啦 2022-01-07

Hello classmate~ I also submitted to this journal. The submission and acceptance time are similar to yours. I wanted to ask if you have noticed any inconsistency between the ISSN number on the journal's official website and the one indexed by the Chinese Academy of Sciences?

NUAAYLZ 2022-01-05

Submitted in early September, the paper underwent review by two reviewers whose opinions were not consistent. Therefore, a third reviewer was consulted, resulting in a major revision. After 20 days of modification, the revised version was returned in December, and on January 4th, it was accepted for publication. The reviewers' comments were not particularly sharp, and all could be addressed through revisions. The editors were also very responsible, and the speed of the process was acceptable. I will consider submitting future ideas as well.

天外的包子 2021-09-15

The reviewer reviewed it quickly, and the reviewer he found was a German author referenced in my literature. The only complaint is about the speed of the editorial department. They don't reply to emails, and I often need to send several before getting a response. Additionally, the proofreading process of this journal is really slow. It took two months from submitting the copyright to publication.

浸白新月 2021-01-19

From submission to final acceptance, the process took 6 months:

- July 10, 2020: Submission
- July 13, 2020: Journal sent back the manuscript due to strict formatting requirements, asking for a resubmission after modifying the format.
- November 23, 2020: First review feedback received, requiring major revisions. Three reviewers provided comments, overall attitude was not harsh and suggested that revisions could lead to acceptance. The reviewers evaluated the manuscript in the following six aspects: Originality, Relationship to Literature, Methodology, Results, Implications for research, practice and/or society, and Quality of Communication.
- December 24, 2020: Revised manuscript submitted.
- January 18, 2021: Accepted, and notification to submit the copyright transfer agreement.