科研GoGo 2023-04-02

As expected, the submission was rejected. It seems that this journal values universality and novelty. After all, they only accept a few hundred articles per year, so research focused on specific devices or continuity of previous papers might be difficult to consider. It would be great if the editors could handle it a bit faster, haha.

科研GoGo 2023-04-01

I don't know if it's because of my luck, but I submitted it on March 12th and it's still in the hands of the editor until today (April 1st). It feels a bit slow. I'm about to graduate, and although I don't rely on this paper to graduate, I still want to get the results earlier so that I can quickly submit to other journals even if it gets rejected.

This journal has a great influence in the field of chemical engineering and I feel that they prioritize innovation.

hgwangbo 2023-03-10

November 1st, submission
November 2nd, assigning for editor
November 4th, assigning for reviews
November 7th, under review
November 8th, assigning for reviews
November 23rd, under review
November 26th, assigning for reviews
December 8th, Under Review (lowercase likely refers to internal review, uppercase to external review)
December 19th, Evaluating Reviews
December 28th, assigning for review
January 6th, Evaluating Recommendation
January 7th, Major Revision (30 days), two reviewers, one suggests revisions, one rejects, editor suggests major revisions
February 3rd, revised article received
February 7th, assigning for review
February 22nd, pending decision (did not go through under review this time)
March 7th, Accept
Thanks to the editorial team and reviewers, wishing AIChE J continued success.

Qingsun 2023-02-23

Hello, may I ask how long the "pending decision" status lasted after the repair?

Qingsun 2023-02-23

Hello, may I ask how long it took for the status "pending decision" after the repair?

Qingsun 2023-02-23

Hello, may I ask how long it took for the pending decision after the repair?

enjoy13 2023-02-22

The change in status after the initial submission is the same. The status switches between "assigning for review" and "under review" once or twice. Evaluating reviews...pending decision... is just that, the initial review time is much shorter.

hgwangbo 2023-02-20

What changes in status did you experience after returning?

hgwangbo 2023-02-18

May I ask what kinds of changes in state did the major repairs undergo before being returned?

ZFF-1991 2023-02-15

Just to add, received on February 15th, 2023.

wwwwww197 2023-02-05

The text "Success" is already in English.

等离子体化学化工 2023-01-29

Author Yi Yi has co-published four papers in total. Each article underwent strict peer review, with reviewers providing highly professional and sharp feedback. However, the review process was a bit slow.

The timeline for each paper is as follows:

Paper 1: Submitted on August 21, 2013. Received major revisions on November 14, 2013. Revised on November 19, 2013. Received minor revisions on November 25, 2013. Revised on November 26, 2013. Accepted on December 10, 2013.

Paper 2: Submitted on December 7, 2016. Revised and resubmitted on March 17, 2017. Received major revisions on April 18, 2017. Revised on August 16, 2017. Accepted on October 6, 2017.

Paper 3: Submitted on May 28, 2018. Received minor revisions on September 24, 2018. Revised on September 30, 2018. Accepted on November 9, 2018.

Paper 4: Submitted on September 25, 2020. Received major revisions on December 1, 2020. Revised on December 23, 2020. Accepted on January 10, 2021.

ZFF-1991 2023-01-24

Submission Experience:
2022.11.1 Submitted
2022.11.20 Under Review
2023.1.3 Major Revision (1 month)
2023.1.20 Submitted Revised Manuscript

enjoy13 2023-01-15

2022.10.19 Submitted
2022.12.04 First Repair (one and a half months)
2022.12.30 Returned
2023.01.14 Received

enjoy13 2023-01-05

2022.10.19 Submission
2022.12.04 First repair (one and a half months)
2022.12.30 Return
2023.01.02 Currently still under review
Looking forward to a good result!

CUP刘东阳 2022-12-22

clean, marked, response, I also uploaded files for the picture and the table.

Jie_fzu 2022-12-08

8-Dec-2022: Evaluating Reviews

王朝 2022-12-03

Hello, may I ask how many documents need to be submitted after the major revision? The marked paper, the unmarked one, and the comment responses?

一元兰蝶 2022-11-29

More than two months, accepted.

ggggumi 2022-11-27

Okay, thank you, OP.

一元兰蝶 2022-11-24

This is not very clear. Usually, I am rejected within a month. Some rejections are instant without any reason, while others have multiple reasons. There are about three reviewers, and some editors reject directly. Good luck to everyone! The admission data can be found at this link in this building.

ggggumi 2022-11-24

May I ask where can I see the data for this probability?

hdhshayebuhui 2022-11-23

May I ask how long is the period for the first instance rejection?

一元兰蝶 2022-11-23

After the first review, "under review" has remained unchanged for 14 days. I can only wait and guess that it will take another 20 days. It has been exactly 2 months since submission, fingers crossed too!!!

Jie_fzu 2022-11-18

28-Oct-2022: Submitted
29-Oct-2022: Assigning Editor
30-Oct-2022: Assigning for Review
5-Nov-2022: Under Review
6-Nov-2022: Assigning for Review
18-Nov-2022: Under Review
Finger Crossed!!!

Translated:

28-Oct-2022: Submitted
29-Oct-2022: Assigning Editor
30-Oct-2022: Assigning for Review
5-Nov-2022: Under Review
6-Nov-2022: Assigning for Review
18-Nov-2022: Under Review
Fingers crossed!!!

ZhaoJY 2022-11-15

First instance took 80 days, and a minor revision was given. It was returned for revision in 10 days, and accepted the next day. The speed is alright, but the first instance time was really long.

一元兰蝶 2022-11-08

According to the data from 2020-2021, the acceptance rate of AIChE Journal is approximately around 32%.
Based on the latest data from the journal*, the median time from manuscript submission to the first decision is 38 days, and the median time from manuscript submission to acceptance is 145 days.

Based on published articles, the majority of articles have a review period of 3-5 months.
https://www.163.com/dy/article/H0O89AG305363Q89.html
Since it is difficult to submit to this journal, why is it still listed as a Tier 3, non-TOP journal? The new classification will be released in December.

enjoy13 2022-10-24

How is it now? How long has it been under review?

CUP刘东阳 2022-10-03

2022.05.01 Submit
2022.07.07 Major Repair
2022.08.20 Return
2022.10.03 Accept

unni 2022-05-30

Personally, I think it is one of the most valuable journals in the field of chemical engineering. The number of published articles is controlled between 400-500, which makes it difficult for the journal to be flooded with irrelevant content. Particularly, this journal has high requirements for workload and systematicity, and the review process is very strict. Typically, three reviewers are required, but the review period is relatively long. Some reviewers provide feedback within a month, while others take up to six months. Most universities consider it as a top-tier journal. In the era of skyrocketing impact factors, it is possible that the impact factor remains stable, and it could be an advantage to focus on one's own research instead.