风往北吹 2023-07-30

Build a building first.
2023.5.31 Submission
2023.6.2 Awaiting TE Assignment
2023.6.3 Under review
2023.6.4 Awaiting Reviewer Assignment
2023.6.9 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
2023.7.10 Awaiting TE Recommendation
2023.7.13 Awaiting SE Recommendation
2023.7.26 Awaiting EIC Decision
2023.7.28 Reject & Resubmit
It feels like the review process was fast this time. They gave a 90-day rejection and resubmission period, and the reviewer mentioned that similar work has been done before and questioned the novelty. Ah, I don't know if there's a chance of acceptance. Praying.

C49115487 2023-07-20

Direct rejections have been made for the submitted article. Articles that solely rely on data analysis will no longer be reviewed, and the addition of hardware-based experimental validation is required.

村花王秀兰 2023-07-14

二审 - Second review
20230605-Awaiting Adimin Processing
20230605-Awaiting Reviewer Scores
20230704-Awaiting TE Recommendation
20230708-Awaiting SE Recommendation
20230710(11am)-Awaiting EIC Decision
20230710(11pm)-Accept
First time submitting to Tmech, went smoothly. Best wishes to everyone for a successful acceptance.

村花王秀兰 2023-07-14

Hiring commitment, the review cycle is for reference only.
First review
20221203-Awaiting Admin Processing
20221205-Awaiting SE Assignment
20221206-Awaiting TE Assignment
20221206-Under review (TE reviewing, not submitted for review)
20221213-Awaiting Reviewer Assignment
20221218-Awaiting Reviewer Scores (Reviewer reviewing)
20230117-Awaiting TE Recommendation
20230129-Awaiting Reviewer Scores (Possibly triggered the minimum number of reviewer opinions, or arbitration, with a higher probability of the former.)
20230329-Awaiting SE Recommendation
20230410-Awaiting EIC Decision
20230410-Major Revision (Three reviewers; 18 comments)

bigmas 2023-07-12

2022.11.08 submit - Submitted on November 8, 2022.
2023.2 awaiting reviewer scores - Waiting for reviewer scores in February 2023.
2023.3 催了一次稿 - Sent a reminder for the manuscript in March 2023.
2023.6 开始在awaiting TE recommendation和awaiting SE recommendation两个状态循环，已经循环4次，现在是awaiting SE recommendation - Started cycling between "awaiting TE recommendation" and "awaiting SE recommendation" statuses since June 2023, already cycled 4 times, currently in "awaiting SE recommendation" status.
至今已经8个月，一审还未回，请问各位大佬，这是咋回事 - It has been 8 months so far, and there has been no response for the first review. Can anyone, especially experienced individuals, explain what is happening?

清晨看露 2023-06-30

2023.6.29 submit - Submitted on June 29, 2023.
2023.6.30 Awaiting SE Assignment - Waiting for Special Examiner Assignment on June 30, 2023.
2023.7.3 Awaiting TE Assignment - Waiting for Technical Examiner Assignment on July 3, 2023.
2023.7.11 Under review - Currently being reviewed as of July 11, 2023.

Jeralyn 2023-05-28

In the first review, there were four reviewers with not many comments and the issues raised were not very critical.

我是冷锋 2023-05-18

My deadline is 25 days, and I estimate that each editor's processing speed may vary.

万万没想到 2023-05-12

I would like to ask all the experts here, how long does it usually take to publish and index after acceptance?

万万没想到 2023-05-12

I would like to ask, approximately how long after acceptance will the publication be seen?

LMR 2023-05-11

There is a saying that opinions are not unified, but I am not sure if this is the case for my situation. The final review comments consist of the reviewer's comments, technical editor's comments, and senior editor's comments. The Editor-in-Chief's comments are mostly official template phrases.

jialei 2023-05-05

"Me too" in English means "also" or "same here."

Молодец 2023-05-01

May I ask if "2022-11-08 awaiting eic decision -> awaiting te recommendation" means that the editor-in-chief has returned the status back to the technical editor? I have encountered a similar situation where the status changed from "Awaiting SE Recommendation" to "Awaiting TE Recommendation." Is this due to conflicting opinions? Are the final review comments a combination of comments from several reviewers, SE, TE, and EIC? Thank you!

我是冷锋 2023-04-23

Continuing from before:
2023.04.06 awaiting the recommendation
04.20 awaiting the second editor's recommendation
04.21 awaiting the Editor-in-Chief's decision
04.23 Accepted
Thank you to all the reviewers and editors for their efforts. Although it was long and agonizing, the result is still satisfactory! Keep up the good work!

我是冷锋 2023-04-23

Continuation from previous:
2023.04.06 awaiting the recommendation
04.20 awaiting the second recommendation
04.21 awaiting the EIC (Editor-in-Chief) decision

我是冷锋 2023-04-23

Continuing from before:
2023.04.06 awaiting the recommendation
04.01 awaiting the SE recommendation

ceshq 2023-04-18

Dude, how is it going after the re-investment? Did you win?

LMR 2023-03-29

2022-08-03 Submitted
2022-10-20 Awaiting reviewer scores -> Awaiting reviewer assignment (审稿人超期)
2022-10-30 Awaiting TE Recommendation
2022-11-07 Awaiting SE Recommendation
2022-11-08 Awaiting EIC Decision -> Awaiting TE Recommendation
2022-12-04 Awaiting SE Recommendation
2022-12-05 Major Revision
2023-01-02 Revision submitted
2023-01-03 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
2023-02-18 Awaiting TE Recommendation
2023-03-06 Awaiting SE Recommendation
2023-03-07 Awaiting EIC Decision
2023-03-07 Accept

Translation:
2022-08-03 Submitted
2022-10-20 Awaiting reviewer assignment (Reviewer overdue)
2022-10-30 Awaiting Technical Editor Recommendation
2022-11-07 Awaiting Section Editor Recommendation
2022-11-08 Awaiting EIC Decision (Editor-in-Chief) -> Awaiting Technical Editor Recommendation
2022-12-04 Awaiting Section Editor Recommendation
2022-12-05 Major Revision
2023-01-02 Revision submitted
2023-01-03 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
2023-02-18 Awaiting Technical Editor Recommendation
2023-03-06 Awaiting Section Editor Recommendation
2023-03-07 Awaiting EIC Decision
2023-03-07 Accept

我是冷锋 2023-03-13

Continuation:

10.13 awaiting EIC decision
10.14 reject & resubmit (5 reviewers, plus one TE and one SE)
12.18 resubmitted
12.19 awaiting reviewer scores
2023.01.29 awaiting TE
02.06 awaiting SE
02.16 awaiting EIC decision
02.20 major
03.03 resubmit
03.06 awaiting reviewer scores
.........To be continued (Getting ready to go pray)

清晨看露 2023-03-09

Sure, I will definitely support it. I don't have many opinions, but I still gave it a try after being rejected and revised it. Eventually, it was accepted.

pray\ 2023-03-09

Excuse me, have you resubmitted? I also received a rejection and resubmitted.

pray\ 2023-03-09

I also resubmitted the rejected article. May I ask if I should still submit this one or switch to another journal?

清晨看露 2023-03-06

Okay, thank you. After waiting for more than 20 days, the SE finally made a decision. It was really slow.

piggy_one 2023-03-05

I have been awaiting scores all along. I previously asked the editor for feedback, and they replied with their opinions. I am waiting for the Test of English (TE) and the Speaking Exam (SE), but I haven't received any communication for almost half a year.

清晨看露 2023-03-04

Excuse me, have you been stuck at TE or SE for a long time? I have been waiting for SE's decision for over 20 days now.

清晨看露 2023-03-04

Hello, may I ask if you have been stuck in TE or SE for a long time? I have been waiting for SE's decision for over 20 days now.

piggy_one 2023-03-04

Latest update, retracted, the funniest thing is, the editorial review comments were not replied to for a month, and the withdrawal email was withdrawn in less than half a day after being sent. It is suggested not to submit without mental preparation of more than a year, as the editing efficiency is too low.

dax 2023-03-01

Have you received the result of the first trial?

dax 2023-03-01

Focused Section submission has been almost 3 months now, and there is still no review feedback. Has anyone received any feedback?

NATHAN00 2023-02-22

Following a post, after nine months of submission, received the first round of comments. In January of the 23rd year, received over 20 pages of comments from nine reviewers. It was overwhelming, but ultimately, we persevered and made experimental corrections to the content. We managed to upload it before the deadline for the first round of revisions. Currently, on the second day, the status is "Awaiting Reviewer Scores". Continuing to accumulate good luck...