Adams_1 2023-07-01

2023.4.29 submitted
2023.4.29 area editor assigned
2023.5.17 ae assigned (under peer review)

Translated into English:

Submitted on April 29, 2023
Area editor assigned on April 29, 2023
AE assigned on May 17, 2023 (under peer review)

Jurgn 2023-05-15

Rejection. 2 R's, 2 RQ's.

Jurgn 2023-04-24

April 24th, Awaiting AE Decision

woshifuhongpo 2023-03-09

2022/6/22 Submission
2022/10/10 Major revision
2022/11/01 Revision after review
2023/2/27 Accepted after minor revision
2023/2/28 Revision
2023/3/8 Accepted

释怀 2023-02-19

1.19 has been officially received.

Zl9823 2023-02-15

Hello, I would like to ask, is this journal inclined towards theoretical research? Can experimental research be submitted? For example, can submissions on terahertz wireless transmission be accepted?

Zl9823 2023-02-15

Hello, I would like to ask, is this journal more focused on theoretical research? Can experimental research be submitted? For example, can submissions on terahertz wireless transmission be accepted?

Zl9823 2023-02-15

Hello, may I ask if this journal leans towards theoretical research? Can experimental research be submitted as well? For example, can submissions on terahertz wireless transmission be accepted?

Zl9823 2023-02-15

Hello, may I ask if this journal is more inclined towards theoretical research? Can experimental research be submitted? For example, can submissions on terahertz wireless transmission be accepted?

Zl9823 2023-02-15

Hello, may I ask if this journal leans towards theoretical research? Can experimental research be submitted? For example, can submissions on terahertz wireless transmission be accepted?

雄鹰 2023-02-07

I submitted on January 19th, just like your situation.

Jurgn 2023-01-28

January 28, 2023; Submission; AE: Not Assigned; ADM: Januszkiewicz, Nanette; Submitted

释怀 2023-01-21

22.7.15 submitted, 7.27 pre-review completed, 7.28 AE assignment, peer review, 11.3 major review, 12.7 resubmitted for peer review
23.1.13 awaiting AE decision, 1.17 accepted with minor revisions
The first TSP article, accepted but language needs to be improved...

mjhcq 2022-10-18

2022.1.6 Submission
2022.1.13 in peer review
2022.6.18 awaiting AE decision
2022.7.25 Major revision (deadline: 2022.9.5)
2022.9.4 (Returned for revision)
2022.10.15 awaiting AE decision
2022.10.17 ACCEPT
3 reviewers, very meticulous, with many sharp questions. The above is the submission status for reference by everyone. Good luck!

LLLLL____ 2022-09-29

The review process is not fast. It was submitted on April 1st, and now it's almost September 29th, and it is still in peer review.

thetitleis 2022-09-15

2022.08.21 submitted
2022.09.07 prescreening
2022.09.14 in peer review
Wish me good luck.

Ludy 2022-09-14

Hired. Total time used is over 2 years...

菜鸟学术搬砖 2022-08-27

SP Magazine only publishes reviews, not technical papers. Filtering and estimation theory are not TIT's main topics, but TIT does occasionally publish hardcore filtering papers.

菜鸟学术搬砖 2022-08-27

Top-tier journals in theory are all very slow, not just TSP. Don't worry, this is the price you pay for submitting to top journals, urging them won't help. Generally, after being "submitted" it takes about a month (usually around 20-40 days) to either be sent for peer review or immediately rejected. As for how long it takes to receive a first-round decision after peer review, it's hard to say. It can be as fast as within 6 weeks (counting from the start of peer review), or as slow as 6 months or even longer.

朋澄Young 2022-08-17

I would like to ask the experts and seniors here. It has been half a month since I submitted my contribution, and the status is still "Submitted" without being assigned to an Associate Editor (AE). Is this situation normal? Should I send an email to the ADM to inquire? ?

frostalker 2022-07-02

Well, the most top things are indeed tit and sp magazine, but these two things are about playing with mathematics and not accessible to ordinary people.

XDUer_RSP 2022-01-07

Top-level journal in the field of signal processing, highly influential within the industry, and widely recognized in the industry.

菜鸟学术搬砖 2022-01-04

May I ask, what is the top journal in the field of signal processing?

IEEEFELLOW 2021-05-27

May I ask if the electronic file (multimedia) included in the documents to be submitted after being hired is mandatory? Supplemental electronic materials (multimedia), if applicable, are used to illustrate the concepts described by the authors.

Ludy 2021-04-18

It has been 10 months, and there has been no response to the second reminder letter...

MichaelZgh 2021-03-28

Correction:
2020.08.06 submitted
2020.10.12 major revision
2020.12.10 a revision has been submitted
2021.02.18 accepted

MichaelZgh 2021-03-28

2020.08.06 submitted - Submitted on August 6, 2020.
2020.10.12 major revision - Major revision made on October 12, 2020.
2020.12.10 a revision has been submitted - A revision has been submitted on December 10, 2020.
2020.02.18 accepted - Accepted on February 18, 2020.

Wavingflag 2021-03-20

Submitted once, first review took 6 months. Both reviewers gave a major revision. Second review took three months, one major revision and one minor revision. The Associate Editor rejected it outright. Now, in order to speed up the review process, if it's not a minor revision, it will be rejected directly. Time to call it a night and plan to revise and resubmit.

Ludy 2021-03-18

It's already been 9 months... Is this article really that difficult to review? Please give me a response whether it's accepted, needs revisions, or rejected...

Fe1ix 2021-01-11

2019.12.28 Submitted
2020.03.08 Major Revision
2020.04.30 A revision has been submitted
2020.05.25 Accepted

Translation:
2019.12.28 Submitted
2020.03.08 Major Revision
2020.04.30 A revision has been submitted
2020.05.25 Accepted