Verified Reviews - IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON RELIABILITY
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

Gloria_Gugugu 2023-07-31

I just received my results today, and it says that the similarity rate is 15%. They asked me to make modifications before submitting it again. However, I had previously checked the similarity rate using plagiarism detection websites like CNKI, and it was only 1%. I don't understand why there is such a big difference in the similarity rate. I would like to ask everyone, what system does IEEE use for plagiarism detection? Thanks! ♪(・ω・)ノ

JJ_Wang 2023-07-31

Our situations are similar, may I ask what is your current status?

Gloria_Gugugu 2023-07-26

It has been one and a half months already, and it feels like it went from "under review" to "awaiting decision" without actually being reviewed. I feel certain that it is a desk reject, but does a desk reject also take this long? The editor has been holding onto my manuscript and when I urge them, they just reply with a template response asking me to be patient... But even a desk reject takes up to two months... Does anyone have any good methods for urging the editor to reject the manuscript? It is important to carefully choose the journal for urgent use of the paper...

Gloria_Gugugu 2023-07-17

There isn't even an external review, and they can't even get some feedback for revisions. Even if they want to submit to another journal, they don't know how to make the changes. I hope someone who understands can help. Thank you, thank you.

Gloria_Gugugu 2023-07-17

First time submitting to this journal. Does anyone know the usual reason for desk rejection in this journal? It is known that the research direction meets the requirements of the journal, and the format is also written according to the template. The experimental difficulty is similar to some of the papers already published in this journal. If anyone knows the reason, please kindly inform me. Thank you very much!

xu.* 2023-06-23

Is there a result now?

xu.* 2023-06-23

Have you received any news yet?

宇宙系浪漫 2023-01-09

It has been nearly two months since submission, and even the reviewers have not been found yet. This journal is too slow, isn't it?
Also, may I ask if anyone knows how long the review period is for this journal?

堤畔少年 2022-12-21

This year has already dropped to Zone 2, and even top journals are not included. Stay calm, if rejected, then switch to ress.

可靠性 2022-12-13

It has been one month since the third review, and there is still no progress.

coooooooooooookie 2022-11-20

Submitted in mid-January, major revisions in May, minor revisions in August, accepted in mid-November, the whole process took about ten months. It's not fast, but it's still acceptable. Overall, it went quite smoothly. I hope this information can be helpful to everyone. A timeframe of around ten months is considered normal.

小马哥 2022-11-15

Are you all OAs?

当然是accept啦 2022-11-15

Waiting for reviewer scores for about 3 months, today the status was updated to Awaiting Decision. What does this message mean????

大熊子 2022-10-21

Around October 15th, I sent an email to the editorial department inquiring about the status.
Still no news, I suggest friends who are anxious to switch to a different journal.

jin1256 2022-09-23

How is your condition now?

jin1256 2022-09-23

My status is like this, how about your current status?

jin1256 2022-09-23

May I ask about your current status now?

jin1256 2022-09-23

How is it now? Has there been any progress? My status changed from 27 days to "awaiting decision". It has been a week and there has been no movement.

小八月 2022-09-21

Brother, is there any news now?

大熊子 2022-09-09

I have been stuck at "Awaiting Reviewer Scores" for about two months now.

大熊维尼 2022-08-31

Has the status of your article changed? I have also been waiting for the editor's response for over ten days.

置身事内 2022-08-05

Just checked the submission system. The editor-in-chief has been changed from W. Eric Wong of the University of Texas at Dallas to Winston Shieh of National Chiao Tung University. I also sent an email to the current editor but have not received any response.

sjdiNg 2022-07-29

I have reviewed the manuscript of this journal before. I noticed that the author submitted it in April of that year, but I received it in mid-July. I am not sure how this journal selects reviewers, but it seems to be quite slow.

MichaelYi 2022-07-28

Since January of year 22, the status is still "Awaiting Reviewer Scores". I don't know why this journal is so slow. Is there anyone knowledgeable who can share their experience of submitting to this journal? Thank you~

Daisyliu 2022-07-18

It has been almost three months and I am still waiting for the assignment of a reviewer.

马晨阳 2022-06-28

May I ask if your article has been assigned a reviewer? I have also been waiting for more than ten days and it is still awaiting editor-in-chief processing.

大熊子 2022-06-28

They are changing the editor of their journal, and since around May, they have been unable to find an editor for the new submissions. We have someone here who applied for an extension to make modifications but couldn't find anyone. We can only continue to wait.

大熊子 2022-06-22

Awaiting Editor-in-Chief Processing 08-Jun-2022

It has been fourteen days now, is there something wrong with my submission?

卡了后咯 2022-05-25

The speed is quite fast.

翻译川 2022-05-25

Does changing from "awaiting reviewer scores" to "awaiting decision" mean that it has not been sent for external review? Why is it different from the normal process?

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started