X.Yang 2023-07-31

Excuse me, everyone, how long does it usually take for the TPS first-instance trial?

秋竹 2023-05-11

2022.5.11 Submission
2022.11.16 Revise and resubmit
2023.1.1 Resubmit
2023.03.12 Revise and resubmit
2023.03.14 Resubmit
2023.05.10 Accept without changes
The first review took six months, I don't know why it took so long. During that period, I sent a couple of reminder emails, but the second and third reviews were done within the normal timeframe.
The reviewer was really meticulous, and during the revision, they found even the smallest symbol errors in the derivations of many formulas. I feel like they went through the derivation of all the formulas in my entire paper themselves (laughing-crying emoji).

科研yy 2023-05-11

2022.10.05 Post
2022.12.13 Revise and Resubmit
2022.12.31 Resubmit (Revised after the first review)
2023.03.12 Revise and Resubmit
2023.03.14 Resubmit (Revised after the second review)
2023.05.07 Accept Without Changes

There were three reviewers in the first review, with one minor revision and two major revisions. After the first review, reviewers 1 and 2 agreed to accept the submission, while reviewer 3 raised some minor issues. Overall, the journal has high quality standards and the reviewers' comments were very professional and detailed.

科研yy 2023-04-14

How many reviewers are there in the first review?

wizardwangjiang 2023-04-07

I have been submitting for 4 months and got rejected, really speechless.

Vurgit 2022-12-05

May I ask what is your specialty, author? Could I have the opportunity to read your previous articles?

往事如烟 2022-10-16

Does this journal have any mandatory requirements for the number of pages?

faofao 2022-08-25

I don't know what direction the original poster's thesis is about. I submitted mine two weeks later than you, and I'm feeling very anxious.

s4425838 2022-08-22

Translation: 5 experts, 2 major revisions, 2 minor revisions, 1 questioning of innovativeness, directly rejected.
Hey, translating requires both strength and luck.

s4425838 2022-05-19

2022-4-19 Post
2 editors, very anxious

guanj 2021-10-24

Submit (9-Feb-2021)
Revise and Resubmit (11-Apr-2021)
Resubmit (09-Jun-2021)
Revise and Resubmit (24-Jul-2021)
Resubmit (25-Aug-2021)
Accept Without Changes (26-Sep-2021)

Translation:
Submit (9-Feb-2021)
Revise and Resubmit (11-Apr-2021)
Resubmit (09-Jun-2021)
Revise and Resubmit (24-Jul-2021)
Resubmit (25-Aug-2021)
Accept Without Changes (26-Sep-2021)

Vurgit 2021-08-23

7.11 Return the revised draft for a second review.
8.23 Accept without changes.

Vurgit 2021-07-05

Must answer each question one by one, not missing any of them, and list out the reviewer's questions and your response one by one, including the responses and gratitude for the decisions of both editors.

Vurgit 2021-07-05

Translate the following text into English: "2021.4.12 Submit the revised manuscript in a new format. 2021.7.4 Revise and resubmit, with a request to correct some minor formatting errors and address some questions raised by one of the reviewers."

Vurgit 2021-07-05

2021.7.4 revise and resubmit, requesting minor corrections in formatting and addressing some concerns raised by one of the reviewers.

Vurgit 2021-04-01

Posted on July 24, 2020, received a reply on November 1, only given two months to make revisions, already way past the deadline...