G_Auto 2022-12-16

How long does it take to receive the recommendation?

G_Auto 2022-12-16

Submitted in July, it has been almost 5 months and there is still no outcome from the first review.

OneTwoThree 2022-12-14

Is it normal to wait for a recommendation for more than 20 days?

accept 2022-11-30

May I ask how long does the "Awaiting Admin Processing" status usually last after submitting an issue to the journal? It has been a week already.

CxqTop 2022-11-23

Sorry, I just noticed it. At that time, I didn't submit the unmarked manuscript. Two are enough.

xxq 2022-11-10

The IEEE PEL review process has indeed become slower than before. Previously, submissions would be reviewed within 2-3 days, but now it takes about a month for the review to be completed.

xxq 2022-11-02

May I ask how long does it take for your "in review process" to change? My submission has been in this status for half a month as well.

李同学1 2022-10-23

Okay, thank you, OP. The main file is the marked manuscript, right? Then, please put the unmarked manuscript in the supplementary materials.

CxqTop 2022-10-21

The revised manuscript should be separated from the comments on the returned manuscript. It doesn't matter who comes first.

李同学1 2022-10-19

Hello, OP. May I ask what materials are needed for resubmission after rejection? It seems that the submission order of the materials on my side is incorrect. Also, should the revised manuscript be included in the same PDF document as the feedback?

李同学1 2022-10-19

Hello, may I ask what materials are needed for resubmitting a rejected paper? Do I need to upload a marked manuscript and the reviewer's comments first? I have been having problems with my submission, so if you could please reply to me when you see this, I would greatly appreciate it. Thank you.

chenhhhh 2022-10-14

The project that I invested in July has already been given early access. Sigh, my luck is not good, and my ability is also weak.

chenhhhh 2022-10-14

The review process was very fast, taking 1-2 weeks.

耿耿的论文送审了吗 2022-10-06

Brother, how long after submission did you send it for review?

chenhhhh 2022-10-06

2022.06.19 submission
2022.09.11 awaiting AE recommendation
It has been almost four months and there is still no outcome. I wish myself good luck, sobbing.

chenhhhh 2022-10-06

It has been almost a month. According to the submission, it has been almost 4 months. What's going on?

LJXTOP 2022-09-19

"I have submitted for over 2 months and am still in the review process. May I ask if there is a shortage of reviewers?"

LJXTOP 2022-09-19

It has been over two months since submission, and the paper is still in the review process. May I ask if there is a shortage of reviewers at the moment?

aming08 2022-09-16

2022.0324 Submission;
2022.0429 First review comments, three experts, one conditionally accepts, one neither accepts nor rejects, one rejects or suggests resubmission (deems it to be outside the scope of the journal);
2022.0610 Revision;
20220708 Second review comments, conditional acceptance, one reviewer agrees to accept, the other two reviewers raised a few minor issues;
20220803 Revision;
20220908 Acceptance;
I am grateful for the strong support from the first reviewer. The reviewer was very strict, and I feel like I barely passed the bottom line, meeting the graduation requirements!

Stephen Jiang 2022-09-01

My situation is the same as yours, I don't know what's going on, I can only wait.

LJXTOP 2022-08-31

My article is still in the review process. It is said to be summer vacation, and the editors are taking a break? Who knows what's going on, maybe they overlooked the email or couldn't find a reviewer? In any case, the wait is getting a bit hopeless. How about you? What's your situation now?

Stephen Jiang 2022-08-31

Mine too, it has been in the review process for over a month. Do you have any new progress with yours now?

LJXTOP 2022-08-28

May I ask if anyone has had the experience of submitting a manuscript for a month and it has been in the review process without finding any reviewers yet? At this point, should I send an email to inquire about it?

LJXTOP 2022-08-26

Excuse me, senior, have you ever experienced submitting a manuscript for a month and it has been in the "In review" process without finding a reviewer yet? Should I send an email to inquire about it at this time?

CxqTop 2022-08-21

2022.3.12 submit
2022.4.19 reject with possibility to resubmit
2022.6.23 resubmit
2022.8.19 accept
Because it was the first submission, I felt quite heavy-hearted when it was rejected for the first time and had to resubmit. Later, I practically rewrote the article, supplemented the experiments, and wrote a 26-page response to the comments. Unexpectedly, it was directly accepted in the second review. It can be considered a satisfactory outcome.

Mr.E 2022-08-09

Add the content he cares about and adjust the structure of the article carefully, so that the reviewer can directly see the situation of the new paper. Additionally, summarize the modifications made in the cover letter. Good luck~

wryssg 2022-08-09

Oh, thank you very much! I have another question. Since there is no need to upload a reply, how can I show or convince the person who rejected it? Thank you!

xixi950412 2022-07-28

Hello, I just received it a few days ago and only uploaded the required Word and PDF files. Currently, the early access of the paper has been published online, but I haven't received any notification for corrections or for uploading other files. However, in the past, when I submitted to IEEE Transactions journals, I was not asked to upload additional materials separately. In general, I use the built-in tables in Word and images from Visio.

蓝色的风18 2022-07-27

2022.01.19 Submitted
2022.01.20 in review process
2022.01.22 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
2022.02.26 Awaiting Co-EIC Recommendation
2022.02.26 Awaiting EIC Decision
2022.03.03 Reject with the possibility to resubmit
2022-06-19 Resubmission initiated
2022-06-24 In review process
2022-06-26 Awaiting reviewer scores
2022.07.22 Awaiting AE recommendation
2022.07.23 evening Awaiting Co-EIC recommendation
2022.07.24 Accepted with minor revisions or without change

蓝色的风18 2022-07-26

Excuse me, in the final checklist, it is required to upload figures, tables, or graphics after acceptance. Do I need to convert the table into an image before uploading it? Some tables in the paper are directly edited in Word, so I understand that they do not need to be uploaded. Thank you very much!